e21561 Background: Melanoma has a high risk of recurrence and death even following complete surgical excision, specially in stages III and IV. Immunotherapy with checkpoint inhibitors, among other treatments, has been employed as adjuvant therapy in an effort to improve overall survival (OS) and disease free survival (DFS) in these patients. Cancer vaccines, particularly those based on dendritic cells loaded with tumor lysate particles (TLPLDC), have been investigated as new adjuvant therapy, these vaccines utilize autologous tumor lysate from an individual tumor, captured by dendritic cells to generate a personalized vaccine that stimulates an active cellular immune response. We conducted a meta-analysis to assess the effectiveness of these vaccines in patients with melanoma following complete resection. Methods: We searched in Pubmed, Cochrane and Embase in December 2023 for articles evaluating the effectiveness of TLPLDC vaccines on the recurrence and survival of patients with locoregional melanoma completely resected. The outcomes of interest included DFS for 3 years and OS for 2 and 3 years, comparing TLPLDC against the control. Additionally, we performed a subgroup analysis comparing an alternative TLPLDC technique named TLPLDC+G against the control. Random-effects models were employed to pool hazard ratios from studies using R software version 4.3.1. Results: We included 4 randomized controlled trials comprising 564 patients. The OS at the 3-year follow-up favored TLPLDC against control (logHR = -1.718[-2.697,-0.740], p = 0.0006,I² = 0%). In the 2-year comparison, treatment was also favored (logHR = -1.511,CI[-2.743,-0.279],p = 0.0162,I² = 36%). However, TLPLDC+G did not exhibit a statistically significant difference from the control in the 3-year long comparison (logHR = 0.043[-0.504,0.590],p = 0.8780,I² = 0%). Regarding the DFS in 36-month comparison, TLPLDC was favored with a 95% CI (logHR = -0.419,[-0.831,-0.006],p = 0.0468,I² = 48%). For TLPLDC+G, there was no statistical difference (0.269[-0.07,0.609],p = 0.1201,I² = 0%). Conclusions: Our results suggests that TLPLDC had a significant impact on OS at 2 and 3-year follow-up with a relatively low heterogeneity between the studies. Regarding the DFS, the TLPLDC group showed a significant difference favoring the vaccine; however, it presented higher heterogeneity. The TLPLDC+G subgroup did not exhibit a significant difference from control in both OS and DFS. Despite the favorable outcomes associated with the TLPLDC vaccine it is important to consider the potential effects of curve reconstruction, the limited number of studies, individual variations in patients immune responses, and differences in vaccine protocols between institutions as limitations of our analysis.
Read full abstract