Advanced medical therapies enable people to live longer with multiple comorbidities, increasing the acuity and complexity of care required upon admission into the intensive care unit. This, coupled with the shift toward a less experienced nursing workforce as skilled nurses retire or leave the critical care environment, prompted the need to re-envision how critical care is delivered. The purpose of this quality improvement project was to embed the values of staff and patient partners in a re-envisioned critical care model, which aligns the provision of high-quality care with staff skill mix and patient needs. Through a series of clinical nurse specialist-led engagement sessions with patients, families, and the members of the healthcare team who work in this environment every day, we talked about what is important in critical care. We used their words and thoughts to inform and shape a new sustainable model of critical care. The 4 components identified as essential to achieving this vision include an acuity-complexity-based approach to care, a transition from separate high-acuity and intensive care areas to integrated units, development of a career pathway to advance practice, and exploration of opportunities to optimize the scope of the interprofessional team. Embedding the values and experience of the people directly connected with providing and/or experiencing critical care increases the likelihood of success in developing, implementing, and sustaining a new model of care. This multifaceted approach resulted in 4 distinct components with achievable outcomes that support this re-envisioned patient-centered sustainable model of critical care.