Exposure to exogenous alkylating agents, particularly N-nitroso compounds, has been associated with increased incidence of primary human brain tumors, while intrinsic risk factors are currently unknown. The DNA repair protein O6-methylguanine-DNA methyltransferase (MGMT) is a major defense against the carcinogenicity of N-nitroso compounds and other alkylators. We report here that in 55% (64/117) of cases, histologically normal brain tissue adjacent to primary human brain tumors lacked detectable MGMT activity [methyl excision repair-defective (Mer-) status]. The incidence of Mer- status in normal brain tissue from brain tumor patients was age-dependent, increasing from 21% in children 0.25-19 years of age to 75% in adults over 50. In contrast, Mer- status was found in 12% (5/43) of normal brain specimens from patients operated for conditions other than primary brain tumors and was not age-dependent. The 4.6-fold elevation in incidence of Mer- status in brain tumor patients is highly significant (chi2 = 24; p < or = 0.001). MGMT activity was independent of age in the lymphocytes of brain tumor patients and was present in lymphocytes from six of nine tumor patients whose normal brain specimen was Mer-. DNA polymerase beta, apurinic/apyrimidinic endonuclease, and lactate dehydrogenase activities were present in all specimens tested, including Mer- specimens from brain tumor patients. Our data are consistent with a model of carcinogenesis in human brain in which epigenetically regulated lack of MGMT is a predisposing factor and alkylation-related mutagenesis is a driving force.