Shortly after Morton et al. introduced the modern sentinel node concept and described its successful application to stage the regional lymphatics (cN0) of cutaneous melanoma, sentinel lymph node biopsy (SLNB) was adapted for other solid malignancies that spread via the lymphatics. We described the universal application of this technique in multiple solid tumors including gastric carcinoma in 1998. In this issue of Annals of Surgical Oncology, Gretschel et al. from Charite, University Medicine Berlin, Campus Bunch, Robert-Rossle-Cancer Hospital, HELIOS Klinikum Berlin, Germany, report the results from their prospective trial of SLNB in gastric cancer. In melanoma and breast cancer, SLNB can limit unnecessary lymphadenectomy in cN0 patients, thereby reducing morbidity. In early gastric carcinoma, SLNB may be used in a similar manner, allowing for limited lymphadenectomy in patients without nodal metastasis while accurately staging the regional lymphatics. The trial reported by Gretschel et al. is important because the extent of lymphatic dissection required in gastric carcinoma is controversial. Investigators from Japan prefer extensive lymphatic dissections (D2 and higher), while reports from the West have not identified an advantage in lymphadenectomy extending beyond D1. Several studies including a meta-analysis comparing D1 versus D2 lymphatic resections have concluded that D2 resections have no survival benefit and are associated with a higher morbidity. However, other investigators have shown that after slight modification of the D2 dissection, similar complication rates can be obtained when compared with D1 dissections. These findings suggest that limiting the extent of lymphatic dissection may have no advantage and could result in inadequate surgical treatment leading to understaging. The controversy regarding the extent of lymphatic dissection is further complicated as investigators from Japan who prefer extended lymphadenectomies have promoted the SLNB technique to limit the extent of lymphatic resection in selected patients. In Japan, the application of the SLNB technique in gastric cancer is well described by Kitagawa and others where 70% of patients present with T1 tumors. Prior to the SLNB technique, patients with early gastric cancer in Japan have been routinely treated with extensive lymphadenectomies (D2) for node-negative disease, resulting in some degree of unnecessary morbidity. Intra-operative SLN analysis is now used in selected cT1, N0 patients to predict the status of the remaining regional lymphatic basin; patients without metastases then undergo limited lymphatic dissections. There is a shifting paradigm in the treatment of early gastric cancer in Japan, as many patients undergo function-preserving endoscopic mucosal resection or laparoscopic wedge resections of the primary tumor in conjunction with SLNB with limited lymphatic dissections. The most critical component of implementing this technology is accurate identification of the SLN(s) within the complex regional lymphatics of the foregut. Published by Springer Science+Business Media, LLC 2007 The Society of Surgical Oncology, Inc. Received March 6, 2007; accepted March 7, 2007; published online: May 23, 2007. Address correspondence and reprint requests to: Anton Bilchik, MD, PhD; E-mail: bilchika@jwci.org Annals of Surgical Oncology 14(9):2432–2434 DOI: 10.1245/s10434-007-9411-y