Bystander Signals Research Articles

Cx43 channels and signaling via IP3/Ca2+, ATP, and ROS/NO propagate radiation-induced DNA damage to non-irradiated brain microvascular endothelial cells

Radiotherapeutic treatment consists of targeted application of radiation beams to a tumor but exposure of surrounding healthy tissue is inevitable. In the brain, ionizing radiation induces breakdown of the blood–brain barrier by effects on brain microvascular endothelial cells. Damage from directly irradiated cells can be transferred to surrounding non-exposed bystander cells, known as the radiation-induced bystander effect. We investigated involvement of connexin channels and paracrine signaling in radiation-induced bystander DNA damage in brain microvascular endothelial cells exposed to focused X-rays. Irradiation caused DNA damage in the directly exposed area, which propagated over several millimeters in the bystander area. DNA damage was significantly reduced by the connexin channel-targeting peptide Gap26 and the Cx43 hemichannel blocker TAT-Gap19. ATP release, dye uptake, and patch clamp experiments showed that hemichannels opened within 5 min post irradiation in both irradiated and bystander areas. Bystander signaling involved cellular Ca2+ dynamics and IP3, ATP, ROS, and NO signaling, with Ca2+, IP3, and ROS as crucial propagators of DNA damage. We conclude that bystander effects are communicated by a concerted cascade involving connexin channels, and IP3/Ca2+, ATP, ROS, and NO as major contributors of regenerative signal expansion.

Ceramide-Enriched Membrane Domains Contribute to Targeted and Nontargeted Effects of Radiation Through Modulation of PI3K/AKT Signaling in HNSCC Cells

Background: It is now established that radiation can affect membranes of mammalian cells in several ways. Depending on the degree of conditioning and mobility of phospholipidic molecules within the plasma membrane, cells exhibit different degrees of sensitivity to radiation. Methods: Here, we investigated the potential involvement of ceramide-enriched membrane domains in radiation-induced targeted and nontargeted effects. Two cell lines of head and neck squamous cell carcinoma (HNSCC) with opposite radiosensitivity were used. Findings: In radiosensitive SCC61 cells, the proportion of targeted effects was 34% and nontargeted effects killed about 32% of cells. In contrast, only targeted effects (30%) are involved in the overall death of radioresistant SQ20B cells. Using methyl-β-cyclodextrin (MBCD), a lipid raft disruptor, we found in SCC61 cells that the formation of a radiation-induced ceramide-enriched domain was suppressed which resulted in a significant reduction of nontargeted effects. By contrast, the existence of ceramide-enriched platforms in radioresistant SQ20B cells, blocks the response to bystander signaling and also confers a protective effect against radiation. We also showed that lipid raft disruption was followed with strong inhibition of PI3K/AKT signaling in SQ20B cells. Combining wortmannin, a PI3K inhibitor with radiation resulted in an increase of cell death and induction of nontargeted response when compared with radiation alone in these cells. Interpretation: These results show in HNSCC cells that ceramide-enriched platforms play a significant role in targeted and nontargeted effect during radiotherapy. They also suggest the potential utility of combining drugs modulating cholesterol levels such as statins with radiation to improve the HNSCC treatment. Funding: This study was supported by LabEx Primes (ANR-11 LABX-0063). Declaration of Interests: No potential conflicts of interest are disclosed.

DNA damage in human skin and the capacities of natural compounds to modulate the bystander signalling.

Human skin is a stratified organ frequently exposed to sun-generated ultraviolet radiation (UVR), which is considered one of the major factors responsible for DNA damage. Such damage can be direct, through interactions of DNA with UV photons, or indirect, mainly through enhanced production of reactive oxygen species that introduce oxidative changes to the DNA. Oxidative stress and DNA damage also associate with profound changes at the cellular and molecular level involving several cell cycle and signal transduction factors responsible for DNA repair or irreversible changes linked to ageing. Crucially, some of these factors constitute part of the signalling known for the induction of biological changes in non-irradiated, neighbouring cells and defined as the bystander effect. Network interactions with a number of natural compounds, based on their known activity towards these biomarkers in the skin, reveal the capacity to inhibit both the bystander signalling and cell cycle/DNA damage molecules while increasing expression of the anti-oxidant enzymes. Based on this information, we discuss the likely polypharmacology applications of the natural compounds and next-generation screening technologies in improving the anti-oxidant and DNA repair capacities of the skin.

Serotonin and 5-HT3 receptors sensitize human skin cells to direct irradiation cell death but not to soluble radiation-induced bystander signals

Ionizing radiation (IR) is an environmental carcinogen and the biological damages it elicits are mechanistically distinct between high and low doses. Non-targeted effects occurring in nonirradiated cells such as the radiation-induced bystander effect predominate at low doses of IR. However, the role of non-targeted effects in environmental radiation protection is often overlooked because the governing mechanisms are complex and multifactorial. An improved understanding of the signaling molecules and their capacity to sensitize specific cell types are essential in establishing environmental IR risks. In particular, serotonin (5-HT) has been identified to exacerbate both direct irradiation and bystander-induced cell death (CD) in certain cell types, although not all cell types are responsive to 5-HT in this respect. In this study, we further characterize the role of 5-HT and 5-HT receptors (5-HTR) in the amplification of CD following IR exposure in human keratinocytes. We examined the survival of HaCaT cells treated with 5-HT and the 5-HTR antagonists ketanserin (5-HT2A) and ondansetron (5-HT3) following exposure to direct IR and irradiated cell condition medium (ICCM). Nonirradiated cell survival was consistent with the vehicle control among 5-HT concentrations ranging from 0.001 to 100 μM. Significant 5-HT concentration-dependent increases in CD occurred following direct IR exposure. Nonirradiated ICCM-recipient CD was not altered by 5-HT (0.001–100 μM) when present during donor cell irradiation among all IR doses. Increases in direct irradiation CD evoked by 5-HT were significantly attenuated by ondansetron, blocking the effect of 5-HT, whereas ketanserin did not alter CD. Western blotting of these target 5-HTRs revealed protein expression of the 5-HT3 receptor, while the 5-HT2A receptor was not detected. We have demonstrated a definitive role for 5-HT in the exacerbation of CD following direct IR exposure and identified the 5-HT3 receptor as a potential target for ameliorating radiation damage in keratinocytes.

Dynamics of Singlet Oxygen-Triggered, RONS-Based Apoptosis Induction after Treatment of Tumor Cells with Cold Atmospheric Plasma or Plasma-Activated Medium

Treatment of tumor cells with cold atmospheric plasma (CAP) or with plasma-activated medium (PAM) leads to a biochemical imprint on these cells. This imprint is mediated by primary singlet oxygen, which is mainly generated through the interaction between CAP-derived H2O2 and NO2−. This imprint is induced with a low efficiency as local inactivation of a few membrane-associated catalase molecules. As sustained generation of secondary singlet oxygen by the tumor cells is activated at the site of the imprint, a rapid bystander effect-like spreading of secondary singlet oxygen generation and catalase inactivation within the cell population is thus induced. This highly dynamic process is essentially driven by NOX1 and NOS of the tumor cells, and finally leads to intercellular RONS-driven apoptosis induction. This dynamic process can be studied by kinetic analysis, combined with the use of specific inhibitors at defined time intervals. Alternatively, it can be demonstrated and quantified by transfer experiments, where pretreated cells are mixed with untreated cells and bystander signaling is determined. These studies allow to conclude that the specific response of tumor cells to generate secondary singlet oxygen is the essential motor for their self-destruction, after a singlet oxygen-mediated triggering process by CAP or PAM.

Intercellular singlet oxygen-mediated bystander signaling triggered by long-lived species of cold atmospheric plasma and plasma-activated medium

Treatment of tumor cells with H2O2 and nitrite, two long-lived species derived from cold atmospheric plasma, induces a complex autoamplificatory, singlet oxygen-mediated process, which leads to catalase inactivation and reactivation of intercellular apoptosis-inducing signaling. Experimental dissection and quantification of this process is described in this study. When tumor cells were pretreated with H2O2 and nitrite, and then were added to untreated tumor cells, they propaged singlet oxygen mediated catalase inactivation and generation of singlet oxygen to the untreated cell population. This bystander effect allowed to analyze the biochemical requirements of a) induction of the bystander effect-inducing potential, b) transmission of the bystander effect to untreated neighbouring cells, and c) the biochemical consequences of these signaling events. The induction of bystander effect-inducing potential requires the generation of “primary singlet oxygen” through the reactions following the interaction between nitrite and H2O2, followed by local inactivation of a few catalase molecules. This primary effect seems to be very rare, but is efficiently enhanced by the generation of "secondary singlet oxygen" through the interaction between H2O2 and peroxynitrite at the site of inactivated catalase. Transmission of bystander signaling between pretreated and untreated tumor cells depends on the generation of secondary singlet oxygen by the pretreated cells and singlet oxygen-mediated catalase inactivation of the untreated recipient cells. This induces autoamplificatory propagation of secondary singlet oxygen generation in the population. This experimental approach allowed to quantify the efficiencies of primary and secondary singlet oxgen generation after CAP and PAM action, to dissect the system and to study the underlying chemical biology in detail. Our data confirm that CAP and PAM-derived components are merely the trigger for the activation of autoamplificatory mechanisms of tumor cells, whereas the tumor cells efficiently propagate their cell death through their own ROS/RNS signaling potential.

The low dose effects of human mammary epithelial cells induced by internal exposure to low radioactive tritiated water

Tritium is an important radioactive waste which needs to be monitored for radiation protection. Due to long biological half-life of organically bound tritium (OBT), the adverse consequence caused by chronic exposure of tritiated water (HTO) attracts concern. In this study, fibroblast cells were exposed to 2 × 106 Bq/ml HTO to investigate the cellular behaviors. The dose relationship of survival fraction and γH2AX foci was a “U-shaped” curve. And the results of γH2AX intensity produced by ICCM, which was obtained from different doses, demonstrated bystander signal accounted for the protective effects induced by intermediate dose of 100 mGy. The comparison of temporal kinetics and spatial dynamics of DNA repair between tritium β-rays and γ-rays showed longer time was need for the dephosphorylation of H2AX protein after HTO exposure. It indicated complex cluster DSBs induced by tritium β-rays at the low dose impaired efficient recovery of DNA damage, which bear responsibility for the persistence of residual foci after low dose expsoure. It suggests after exposed to low dose radiation cells prefer to eliminate damage population to avoid DNA damage increasing the mutation potential.

Single and fractionated ionizing radiation induce alterations in endothelial connexin expression and channel function

Radiotherapy is an effective treatment for most tumor types. However, emerging evidence indicates an increased risk for atherosclerosis after ionizing radiation exposure, initiated by endothelial cell dysfunction. Interestingly, endothelial cells express connexin (Cx) proteins that are reported to exert proatherogenic as well as atheroprotective effects. Furthermore, Cxs form channels, gap junctions and hemichannels, that are involved in bystander signaling that leads to indirect radiation effects in non-exposed cells. We here aimed to investigate the consequences of endothelial cell irradiation on Cx expression and channel function. Telomerase immortalized human Coronary Artery/Microvascular Endothelial cells were exposed to single and fractionated X-rays. Several biological endpoints were investigated at different time points after exposure: Cx gene and protein expression, gap junctional dye coupling and hemichannel function. We demonstrate that single and fractionated irradiation induce upregulation of proatherogenic Cx43 and downregulation of atheroprotective Cx40 gene and protein levels in a dose-dependent manner. Single and fractionated irradiation furthermore increased gap junctional communication and induced hemichannel opening. Our findings indicate alterations in Cx expression that are typically observed in endothelial cells covering atherosclerotic plaques. The observed radiation-induced increase in Cx channel function may promote bystander signaling thereby exacerbating endothelial cell damage and atherogenesis.

Characterization of Radioprotective, Radiomitigative and Bystander Signaling Modulating Effects of Endogenous Metabolites - Phenylacetate, Ursodeoxycholate and Tauroursodeoxycholate - on HCT116 Human Colon Carcinoma Cell Line.

Exposures to ionizing radiation can cause depletion in stem cell reservoirs and lead to chronic injury processes that exacerbate carcinogenic and inflammatory responses. Therefore, radioprotective measures, against both acute and chronic biological effects of radiation, require frequent intake of nontoxic natural products, which have practical oral administration. The goal of this study was to characterize the radioprotective, radiomitigative and radiation-induced bystander effect-inhibiting properties of endogenous metabolites: phenylacetate, ursodeoxycholate and tauroursodeoxycholate. Compounds were administered pre- and postirradiation as well as in donor and recipient bystander flasks to analyze whether these might adequately protect against radiation injury as well as facilitate recovery from the exposures. The clonogenic HCT116 p53 wild-type cancer cell line in this study shares characteristics of stem cells, such as high reproductive viability, which is an effective marker to demonstrate compound effectiveness. Clonogenic assays were therefore used to characterize radioprotective, radiomitigative and bystander inhibiting properties of treatment compounds whereby cellular responses to radiation were quantified with macroscopic colony counts to measure cell survival in flasks. The results were statistically significant for phenylacetate and tauroursodeoxycholate when administered preirradiation, conferring radioprotection up to 2 Gy, whereas administration postirradiation and in bystander experiments did not confer radioprotection in vitro. These findings suggest that phenylacetate and tauroursodeoxycholate might be effective radioprotectors, although they possess no radiomitigative properties.

Negative Modulation of Bystander DNA Repair Potential by X-Ray Targeted Tissue Volume in Arabidopsis thaliana.

Radiation-induced bystander effects (RIBE) entail a cascade of bystander signals produced by the hit cells to the neighboring cells to regulate various biological processes including DNA damage repair. However, there is little clarity regarding the effect of radiation-targeted volume (hit cell amount) on the DNA repair potential of the bystander cells. This is especially important to understand in the context of the whole organism, where the target usually consists of multiple types of cells/tissues. To address this question, model plant Arabidopsis thaliana was locally irradiated, and the DNA repair potential of bystander root-tip cells was assessed based on their radioresistance to subsequent high-dose radiation, i.e. radioadaptive responses (RAR). We found that X-ray irradiation of the aerial parts (AP) of A. thaliana seedlings (5 Gy) initiated RAR in the root-tip cells, which exhibited an alleviated repression of root growth and root cell division, and reduced amount of DNA strand breaks. We also observed an improvement in the repair efficiency of the homologous recombination (HR) and non-homologous end joining (NHEJ) pathways in the bystander root tip cells. We further expanded the X-ray targeted volume to include the aerial parts with upper parts of the primary root and compared it with X-ray irradiated aerial parts alone. Comparative analysis revealed that RAR for these end points either disappeared or decreased; specifically, the repair efficiency of HR was significantly reduced, indicating that radiation-targeted volume negatively modulates the bystander DNA repair potential. In contrast, X-ray irradiation of upper part of the primary root alone did not induce RAR of the root tip cells. Thus, we propose that additional X-ray irradiation of upper part of the primary root reduces the bystander DNA repair potential, possibly by selectively disturbing the transport of bystander signals responsible for HR repair.

Senolytics and senostatics as adjuvant tumour therapy.

Cell senescence is a driver of ageing, frailty, age-associated disease and functional decline. In oncology, tumour cell senescence may contribute to the effect of adjuvant therapies, as it blocks tumour growth. However, this is frequently incomplete, and tumour cells that recover from senescence may gain a more stem-like state with increased proliferative potential. This might be exaggerated by the induction of senescence in the surrounding niche cells. Finally, senescence will spread through bystander effects, possibly overwhelming the capacity of the immune system to ablate senescent cells. This induces a persistent system-wide senescent cell accumulation, which we hypothesize is the cause for the premature frailty, multi-morbidity and increased mortality in cancer survivors.Senolytics, drugs that selectively kill senescent cells, have been developed recently and have been proposed as second-line adjuvant tumour therapy. Similarly, by blocking accelerated senescence following therapy, senolytics might prevent and potentially even revert premature frailty in cancer survivors.Adjuvant senostatic interventions, which suppress senescence-associated bystander signalling, might also have therapeutic potential. This becomes pertinent because treatments that are senostatic in vitro (e.g. dietary restriction mimetics) persistently reduce numbers of senescent cells in vivo, i.e. act as net senolytics in immunocompetent hosts.

BIOPHOTONS IN RADIOBIOLOGY: INHIBITORS, COMMUNICATORS AND REACTORS.

Radiation-induced bystander effects refer to the production of signals from irradiated cells which induce responses in unirradiated, or bystander, cells. There has been a recent resurgence of interest in low-energy photon biology. This is due to concerns about health effects, increased use of biophoton imaging techniques, and the fact that biophotons can act as a bystander signal. This review discusses the history of light signaling in biology and potential mechanisms involved in the generation and transduction of signaling mechanisms. The role of photons in signaling in the animal and plant kingdoms is also reviewed. Finally, the potential to harness these mechanisms in radiation protection or therapy is discussed with emphasis on promising future directions for research.

Radiation Induced Bystander Signalling

Radiation Induced Bystander Signalling

BYSTANDER WI-38 CELLS MODULATE DNA DOUBLE-STRAND BREAK REPAIR IN MICROBEAM-TARGETED A549 CELLS THROUGH GAP JUNCTION INTERCELLULAR COMMUNICATION.

Bi-directional signaling involved in radiation-induced bystander effect (RIBE) between irradiated carcinoma cells and their surrounding non-irradiated normal cells is relevant to radiation cancer therapy. Using the SPICE-NIRS microbeam, we delivered 500 protons to A549-GFP lung carcinoma cells, stably expressing H2B-GFP, which were co-cultured with normal WI-38 cells. The level of γ-H2AX, a marker for DNA double-strand breaks (DSB), was subsequently measured up to 24-h post-irradiation in both targeted and bystander cells. As a result, inhibition of gap junction intercellular communication (GJIC) attenuated DSB repair in targeted A549-GFP cells, and suppressed RIBE in bystander WI-38 cells but not in distant A549-GFP cells. This suggests that GJIC plays a two-way role through propagating DNA damage effect between carcinoma to normal cells and reversing the bystander signaling, also called 'rescue effect' from bystander cells to irradiated cells, to enhance the DSB repair in targeted cells.

Transmembrane domain-mediated Lck association underlies bystander and costimulatory ICOS signaling

The B7-family inducible costimulator (ICOS) activates phosphoinositide-3 kinase (PI3K) and augments calcium mobilization triggered by the T-cell receptor (TCR). We surprisingly found that the entire cytoplasmic domain of ICOS is dispensable for its costimulation of calcium mobilization. This costimulatory function relies on the unique transmembrane domain (TMD) of ICOS, which promotes association with the tyrosine kinase Lck. TMD-enabled Lck association is also required for p85 recruitment to ICOS and subsequent PI3K activation, and Lck underlies both the bystander and costimulatory signaling activity of ICOS. TMD-replaced ICOS, even with an intact cytoplasmic domain, fails to support TFH development or GC formation in vivo. When transplanted onto a chimeric antigen receptor (CAR), the ICOS TMD enhances interactions between T cells and antigen-presenting target cells. Therefore, by revealing an unexpected function of the ICOS TMD, our study offers a new perspective for the understanding and potential application of costimulation biology.

Radiobiological characteristics of descendant progeny of fish and amphibian cells that survive the initial ionizing radiation dose

PurposeTo evaluate the development of delayed lethal mutations, the production of medium borne lethal bystander signals, and the acquirement of radiosensitive or radioresistant traits in distant descendant progeny of fish and amphibian cells surviving ionizing radiation Materials and methodsAmerican eel brain endothelial cells (eelB) and African clawed frog epithelial cells (A6) were initially irradiated with gamma rays at 0.5 Gy or 2 Gy. Ionizing radiation (IR)-surviving cells were grown for 27 population doublings (PDs) for eelB and 43 PDs for A6. Reproductive cell death as quantified by clonogenic survival assays was used to determine the development of delayed lethal mutations, the production of medium borne lethal bystander signals, and the acquirement of radiosensitive or radioresistant traits in the progeny survivors. ResultsOnly medium borne bystander signals produced by 2-Gy-irradiated eelB progeny survivors at 12 PDs could reduce the clonogenic survival of the bystander reporter cells. IR-induced delayed lethal mutations occurred in irradiated eelB cells at 15–18 PDs; however, subsequently propagated progeny cells retained normal replicative abilities. No IR-induced delayed lethal mutations developed in progeny of irradiated A6 cells at up to 43 PDs. eelB progeny survivors did not develop new radiosensitive or radioresistant traits while A6 progeny survivors acquired a new radiosensitive characteristic. ConclusionThis study enriches the current literature on the radiobiological characteristics of distant surviving progeny of irradiated fish and amphibian cells and highlights cell-type/species-dependent differential responses to IR. This study is the first to examine the potential transgenerational effects of progenitor irradiation in amphibian cells.

Evaluation of the Bystander effect caused ultrasound waves on the MCF-7 cell line

Introduction: Non-target radiation effects are damages and effects that occur without the need for direct radiation exposure in cells. Bystander signals cause non-targeted irradiation effect that has been defined as radiation responses in which non-irradiated cells exhibit irradiated effects as a result of signals from adjacent irradiated cells. In this study, the bystander effects of ultrasound radiation on the MCF-7 cell line have been investigated. Materials and Methods: Two main groups were defined as target group and bystander group. Target group contained 3 subgroups. The first subgroup is control group which has no intervention. The second subgroup was exposed to ultrasound with the frequency of 1MHZ and intensity of 0.5 . The Third subgroup was exposed to ultrasound with the frequency of 1MHZ and intensity of 1 . The bystander group has 3 subgroups, too. Bystander subgroups received cell culture medium of target subgroups, respectively. The MTT assay has been investigated for bystander subgroups. Results: The MTT assay results showed cell viability in bystander cells that received the culture medium from irradiated target cells has not been reduced. In other words, no significant difference was observed between first and second bystander subgroups with control group (P > 0.05). Conclusion: Ultrasound waves with intensity of 0.5 and 1 do not induce the bystander effect on MCF-7 cell line.

Gap Junction Intercellular Communication Positively Regulates Cisplatin Toxicity by Inducing DNA Damage through Bystander Signaling.

The radiation-induced bystander effect (RIBE) can increase cellular toxicity in a gap junction dependent manner in unirradiated bystander cells. Recent reports have suggested that cisplatin toxicity can also be mediated by functional gap junction intercellular communication (GJIC). In this study using lung and ovarian cancer cell lines, we showed that cisplatin cytotoxicity is mediated by cellular density. This effect is ablated when GJA1 or Connexin 43 (Cx43) is targeted, a gap junction gene and protein, respectively, leading to cisplatin resistance but only at high or gap junction forming density. We also observed that the cisplatin-mediated bystander effect was elicited as DNA Double Strand Breaks (DSBs) with positive H2AX Ser139 phosphorylation (γH2AX) formation, an indicator of DNA DSBs. These DSBs are not observed when gap junction formation is prevented. We next showed that cisplatin is not the “death” signal traversing the gap junctions by utilizing the cisplatin-GG intrastrand adduct specific antibody. Finally, we also showed that cells deficient in the structure-specific DNA endonuclease ERCC1-ERCC4 (ERCC1-XPF), an important mediator of cisplatin resistance, further sensitized when treated with cisplatin in the presence of gap junction forming density. Taken together, these results demonstrate the positive effect of GJIC on increasing cisplatin cytotoxicity.

Effect of gamma radiation on the production of bystander signals from three earthworm species irradiated in vivo

The effect of gamma radiation delivered over 24 h on the induction of bystander signals of three earthworm species exposed in vivo was investigated: A. chlorotica, A. caliginosa, and E. tetraedra. Worms were exposed to external gamma irradiation (Co-60 source) for 24 h and samples of head, body, and clitellum were dissected from exposed and control worms and placed in culture medium for 24 h at 19 C. The harvested medium was filtered and assayed for expression of bystander signals using both clonogenic and mitochondrial reporter assays. Different responses were observed in the different species and in the different tissues. A. chlorotica worm-treated reporters show insignificant mitochondrial response for all sections, yet a significant clonogenic reduction in survival for body sections. A. caliginosa worm-treated reporters show a significant mitochondrial response for some sections and insignificant mitochondrial response and insignificant reduction in clonogenic survival for the rest. E. tetraedra worms from a control site show significant evidence of bystander signalling, measured by mitochondrial response in reporter cells, for all sections while those harvested from a contaminated site show insignificant changes in baseline signalling when exposed to the challenge dose. In vivo exposure of earthworm species shows evidence of bystander signalling using two different reporter assays. This effect varied between the different species and tissues. There is also evidence of attenuated bystander signalling in worms harvested from a site contaminated with radiation.

Models for the bystander effect in gradient radiation fields: Range and signalling type

Bystander responses to radiation are responsible for a significant fraction of cell death, but are not included in the conventional linear-quadratic (LQ) radiobiological model. Strong dose gradients in radiation fields affect the distribution of bystander signals and can be used to decrease the survival of cancer cells. Predictive models incorporating bystander effects are needed to design the dose gradients in modulated fields to improve cancer treatments.Fundamental questions concern the nature and range of bystander signalling. Some authors propose bystander signals are carried by diffusing molecular factors expressed into the extracellular medium and that strong dose gradients drive their diffusion. Others propose bystander effects occur between neighbouring cells through gap-junctions, leaving no universal agreement. Here we test three assumptions concerning the effective range of bystander signals using both average and local measures of survival. Model 1 assumes short range signalling (e.g. gap-junction mediated) proportional to the local dose gradient, without relying on diffusion across the extracellular medium; Model 2 assumes metabolite diffusion governed by Fick's second law with either negative or both signs of bystander effect; Model 3 assumes that the extent of signal production is dependent on the average of the dose gradient over the field and that the signals have long range distribution.A single bystander parameter for each model was fitted to observed average survival of cancer cells in uniform and modulated fields. All models gave better fits than the classical LQ model. Model 2 fitted best with one sign of bystander effect on survival. Model 3 gave the best overall fit of average survival. The models were then used to predict local survival and survival as a function of dose in modulated fields, using independent datasets, without changing the bystander parameter. Model 3 gave the best overall prediction. This study demonstrates that the bystander effect can be controlled by design of the radiation field modulation.