Borda Methods Research Articles

APPLICATION OF GROUP DECISION MAKING IN DETERMINING CULINARY TOURISM WITH TOPSIS AND BORDA METHODS

Makassar City is one of the destination cities for traveling. Makassar City offers a variety of interesting tours, one of which is culinary tourism. The determination of the best culinary tourism is based on the criteria set by the Makassar City Tourism Office. In managing culinary destinations, tourists are often faced with many choices, so they are confused about choosing the most attractive culinary destinations. This research uses the TOPSIS and BORDA methods. The TOPSIS method is used in determining culinary tourism alternatives based on criteria that become recommendations and the BORDA method is used in determining the selected alternatives based on several DMs who evaluate alternatives. The main objective of this research is to apply group decision making in selecting the best culinary tourism destinations in Makassar City based on group preferences and related criteria with TOPSIS and BORDA methods. This research has conducted 5 iterations involving 4 DMs from the Makassar City Tourism Office. Based on the results of the interview, 8 criteria and 35 alternatives were obtained. Where the Coto Nusantara alternative is ranked the highest with a value of 109,949. While Sop Saudara Irian is ranked last with a value of 62,896. The general benefit of this research is the application of group decision making in determining culinary tourism with the TOPSIS and BORDA methods can produce more objective and representative decision results. This can increase tourist satisfaction in determining culinary tourism.

Optimization of Village Budget Plan Selection Based on Priorities Using Method Promethee and Borda

The rapid information technology that is happening now
 has a significant impact on human life, including various
 activities that occur at the village office. The village head
 is responsible for managing funds at the village level
 including the collection and accountability of funds in
 accordance with the provisions of law no.33 of 2004
 concerning the balance of central and regional
 governments. This study aims to implement a decision
 support system by combining two methods, namely the
 promethee and borda methods in selecting village budget
 plans in Tegal Sari village based on priority. The method
 used in this research is the Research and Development
 (R&D) method. The method used for calculations is the
 PROMETHEE and Borda methods. The PROMETHEE
 method is used to manage individual decisions from each
 decision maker, while the Borda method is used to
 manage group decisions resulting from the PROMETHEE
 ranking method. The criteria in this study are Cost,
 Completion Time, Impact on Regions/Society, Profits
 from Sustainable Investment, Factors of Interest. The
 results obtained from this research are Pemb. Health
 Sarpras as an alternative priority for the village budget.

A Web-based Group Decision Support System for Retail Product Sales a Case Study on Padang, Indonesia

The industrial sector's growth has led to an increase in the number of industrial products available in the market. However, this has made it more challenging for retail merchants to choose which items to sell due to the overwhelming number of options. The seller must carefully consider various factors such as the type, quality, and probability of selling the goods to turn a profit. This research proposes a group decision support system to assist retail sellers in selecting the products to sell. The system is designed to process various information on comparing retail products against specific criteria, enabling sellers to make quick and accurate decisions. To achieve optimal results, this study combines three methods in the decision-making calculation process: Fuzzy Logic, EDAS, and Borda methods. The Fuzzy Logic method is used to assign a value to an unclear criterion, followed by the EDAS method ranking process, and ending with the combination of the decision-making results using the Borda method. The group decision support system is web-based and has been proven to provide effective solutions for retail business actors to increase sales and reduce losses. By using this system, retail sellers can make informed decisions about their products, enabling them to optimize their profits and reduce their risks. In conclusion, the increase in the number of industrial products has created challenges for retail merchants, but this research proposes a solution in the form of a group decision support system. Combining Fuzzy Logic, EDAS, and Borda methods results in an effective decision-making process that allows retail sellers to make informed decisions and achieve their business goals.

Decision Support System for Selecting Rescuer Candidates for Basarnas Special Group Using SMART And BORDA

The National Search and Rescue Agency (also known as BASARNAS) is a government agency responsible for offering search and rescue services in the event of an accident or disaster. At BASARNAS there is a special team, the BASARNAS Special Group (BSG). BSG performs rescues during national and international disasters or accidents. BSG itself consists of selected people, namely BSG candidates from all search and rescue office rescuers in Indonesia. BSG candidates themselves are still calculated manually so that it can affect the time efficiency of SAR personnel in making selections, this research was conducted at the Medan Class A Search and Rescue Office. To ensure that BSG candidates are accurate and processed quickly, a decision support system is needed. This time the researchers utilized the Simple Multi Attribute Rating Technique (SMART) and BORDA methods to determine BSG candidates. With the criteria used, namely fitness (K1), physical health (K2), mental health (K3) and creativity (K4). Then the alternatives used are 25 alternatives which include 20 skilled rescuers and 5 beginner rescuers. and the results can be saved in the form of a PDF file. The results of calculations using the SMART and BORDA methods found that among skilled rescuers, Rescuer-T15 is a suitable candidate to become a BSG candidate by obtaining a total score of 6049.25 and among novice rescuers, Rescuer-P5 obtained the highest score of 756.00.

Selection of TikTok Content Based on User Engagement Criteria Using the Analytic Hierarchy Process

Indonesia has 106.9 million active TikTok users aged 18 and above. TikTok is designed for engagement in many ways, as it actively encourages two-way communication and eye-catching content. Uploaded content must have its uniqueness variable. In increasing the engagement of a TikTok account, criteria are chosen based on the COBRA concept (consuming, contributing, and creating) and alternatives based on social media content trends in Indonesia (tutorial, educational, a day in my life, behind the scene dan tips and trick). This research was conducted by implementing the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) method to select the content that must be prioritized to get engagement from the wider community. From the data processing results obtained, tutorial content is the best content in increasing engagement results, especially TikTok. Content that has the lowest engagement is behind the scene content. Further research can be carried out through a group decision support system with various related experts. It can also be combined with the BORDA, TOPSIS, and Profile Matching methods to optimize ranking results.

Qur’an tilawatil examination system

A group Decision Support System (GDSS) is used when a decision system has many stakeholders providing recommendations in a system. One of them is the Tilawatil of the Qur'an for students in the religious field test. The assessment consists of several raters. The purpose of this study is to apply the SMART (Simple Multi-Attribute Rating Technique) and Borda methods in calculating the results of the Tilawatil Qur'an test based on a decision support system. The SMART method is used in assessing the results of the Tilawatil Qur'an test and the Borda method is used in optimizing the overall results of the assessors on the SMART method. The results of the study were based on the SMART value accuracy test manually with the system yielding 95%. After that, the results of the optimization test of the Borda method were calculated by calculating the average value of the SMART method with optimal ranking results.

Analysis of rural infrastructure development using village funds in Bagan Nibung Village

This study aims to analyze the development of village funds for infrastructure development and the best hamlets in Bagan Nibung Village, Simpang Kanan District, Rokan Hilir Regency. The indicators of development in the hamlet are human resources, economy, and infrastructure. The sampling method is a purposive method for as many as 57 people. This study uses a descriptive method to see the development of village funds and the AHP and Borda methods to see the ranking of development between hamlets. The most significant village revenue comes from transfer receipts, while other revenues are minimal. In the village expenditure structure, the components of significant expenditure are expenditures for government and development. Spending on hamlet infrastructure activities was mostly in Pematang Lada, Inti Raya, and the least in Suka Makmur. The process hierarchy analysis results show the highest HR variable in the Inti Raya Hamlet. The results of the highest regional economic variable AHP in Suka Makmur. The AHP results show that the infrastructure variable has the highest in Pematang Lada. Borda's analysis results show that the hamlets with the best development ranking are Pematang Lada, Inti Raya, and Suka Makmur.

The Strategy Development of Marine Posture in Supporting the Main Task of Navy Using Swot and Borda Method

The Unitary State of the Republic of Indonesia is the largest archipelago country in the world. Its geological constellations which is the world cross position, place the marine territory of the national jurisdiction very strategically for Indonesia as well as for other countries. The marine posture capability can still be developed by enhancing the power and ability of the marines and optimizing the degree patterns. The marine posture development strategy can be done by learning the potential possible threats in the future and analyzing the marine posture conditions that must be improved to enhance national marine security. In this research, the strategy was analyzed with SWOT and BORDA methods. The result of this research is IFE value is 3.26 (3.00- 4.00) and the EFE value of 3.21 (3.00 – 4.00) which indicates that the marine posture is currently in a strong position. The position of marine posture strategy located at coordinates (3.26; 3.21) is Growth and Build. The marine posture development strategy lies in the position of quadrant III with coordinates (0.02;-0.11) that indicate st (strength threat) strategy, i.e. marine posture utilizes force to overcome threats.

Group Decision Support System Using AHP, Topsis and Borda Methods for Loan Determination in Cooperatives

Cooperatives are one of the business units which purpose is to help the economy of small and medium-sized communities. One of the cooperatives in the city of Padang, West Sumatra, Indonesia is KPN Kapur Warna. The routine business unit managed by KPN Kapur Warna is for savings and loans. So far, the savings and loan process is still done manually, including determining the eligibility of members to receive loans. Determination of the eligibility of members is carried out less objectively, by only looking at the profile of participants in general and the decision-making process is only carried out by one person, namely the chairman of the cooperative. The process that has been carried out so far has often resulted in wrong targets, namely providing loans to members who are not appropriate, resulting in bad credit or delays in paying monthly installments of participants. Therefore, we need a group decision support system that can help solve the above problems. In this study, a group decision support system was made using the AHP, TOPSIS and BORDA methods using five main criteria. The AHP method is used to determine the priority value for each criterion and the TOPSIS method is used to rank each alternative. Each decision maker performs the same process with the two methods, and then voting is carried out using the BORDA method of combining assessments for different decision makers. This study succeeded in providing a reference in determining the eligibility of which members are entitled to receive loans from cooperatives, with results that are more subjective and can help cooperatives in their work efficiently.

Implementasi 360 Degree untuk Membantu Proses Pelaporan Kinerja Dosen (Studi Kasus; JTI Polinema)

Untuk menuju tujuan pendidikan nasional tersebut diperlukan dosen yang professional. Evaluasi kinerja dosen diperlukan agar dalam melaksanakan tugas dan tanggung jawabnya sejalan dengan apa yang diisyaratkan dalam UU No. 14 Tahun 2005 tentang guru dan dosen, Dalam melaksanakan penilaian yang benar, maka penilaian dilakukan oleh pihak yang tepat yang dapat memberikan kontribusi penilaian yang baik. Hal ini cocok dengan metode 360 degree yang menilai seseorang dari pihak-pihak yang berada di sekitarnya. Penelitian ini menggunakan konsep sistem pendukung keputusan kelompok (GDSS) sebagai metode pengolahan data dengan 3 penilai yaitu atasan, mahasiswa, dan rekan sesama dosen. Sistem pendukung keputusan kelompok yang dikembangkan dalam penelitian ini menggunakan metode AHP (Analytical Hierarchy Process) dan Borda untuk penentuan keputusan kelompok. Metode AHP digunakan untuk penentuan bobot kriteria dari setiap alternatif. Metode Borda digunakan untuk penggabungan hasil perangkingan yang didapat oleh setiap pengambil keputusan sehingga mendapatkan perangkingan akhir dan mendapatkan skor setiap alternatif. Kriteria yang digunakan antara lain: Kepribadian, Pedagogik, Sosial, dan Profesional. Hasil dari pengujian dari 10 data uji, dapat disimpulkan tingkat akurasi yakni sebesar 20 %. Presentase yang rendah ini disebabkan penilaian kinerja yang selama ini diterapkan tidak menggabungkan penilaian dari mahasiswa, atasan dan rekan sejawat. Selain itu tidak ada penilaian untuk rekan kerja.

A hybrid of Borda-TOPSIS for risk analysis of Islamic state network development in southeast Asia

In a decision-making environment related to risk, there are four basic circumstances, namely certainty, risk, uncertainty and conflict. The dynamics of the strategic environment in Southeast Asia cannot be separated from the movement of the development of the Islamic State (IS). The terror threat in Southeast Asia is currently divided into different generations of terror, namely the threat of the Al-Qaeda terror network and the threat of the ISIS terror network. This study aims to analyze and identify the risk value of the development of the Islamic State network in Southeast Asia using the Borda and TOPSIS methods. The Borda method is used to give weight to the criteria related to risk analysis. The TOPSIS method is used to provide a criteria-based risk score. This research is limited to the Southeast Asia region with 4 (four) major countries, namely Indonesia, Malaysia, Thailand, and the Philippines. This research is expected to contribute to control the development of Islamic state networks in the Southeast Asian region. Based on the results of the overall risk analysis, it was found that the Philippines has the highest risk factor value for Islamic State (IS) with a value of 0.550 at level 4 in the High category. Indonesia maintains a risk factor value of 0.307. Thailand has a risk factor value of 0.427. Indonesia and Thailand are at level 3 with the Medium category. Meanwhile, Malaysia has a risk factor value of 0.203 at level 2 in the Low category.

Sistem Pendukung Keputusan Penyeleksian Colour Guard Pada Marching Band Ginada Dengan Menggunakan Metode Vikor Dan Borda

Decision support system for selecting color guard with VIKOR and Borda methods. It has been made as a tool to select color guard at the Sei Rampah High School. The criteria used in the decision support system for color guard selection are: height, weight, agility, stamina, and body language. Color guard selection activities are a routine activity every year, so GINADA marching band coach Sei Rampah hereby selects to select permanent members in the marching band. Decision Support System in an organization can be seen as important in supporting the smooth running of activities and achieving an organizational goal. SPK can come in various forms, ranging from simple forms of data processing to complex application forms, and can also be used to accelerate and improve the quality of the decision-making process in the organization.

Sistem Pendukung Keputusan Pemilihan Lokasi Pre-Wedding di Kota Medan dengan Menggunakan Metode VIKOR dan BORDA

Decision Support System for the selection of pre-wedding locations using the Vikor and Borda methods. A tool has been made to select the pre-wedding location in the city of Medan. The criteria used in the decision support system for pre-wedding location selection are: access to the location, costs, location conditions and location situation. Knowing the process of selecting the best pre-wedding location that is still experiencing obstacles in the process of decision-making results for brides who want to do a pre-wedding photo session. Pre-wedding venue selection is very important because it determines the good results of the pre-wedding photo. Very many places that are very suitable for pre-wedding photo sessions for example in the city of medan. Decision Support Systems can come in forms, ranging from simple forms of data management to complex application forms and can also be used to accelerate and improve the quality of decision making processes in an organization

Group decision support system for employee performance evaluation using combined simple additive weighting and Borda

Subjectivity in performance appraisal is almost inevitable. Subjectivity is defined as a perspective based on personal views or feelings about a thing. Eliminate subjectivity factors so that assessing objectively based on certain criteria is difficult to implement, whereas subjectivity causes unfair competition and giving rise to an uncompetitive environment. This research was conducted to reduce subjectivity in a performance appraisal using the Group Decision Support System with Simple Additive Weighting and Borda methods. Employee performance appraisal at PT. Krakatau Osaka Steel was the object of this research. The Group Decision Support System has selected the best employees from 59 employee samples taken by the Purposive Sampling method resulted the 7 best employees according to the assessors with a Decision Support System, these results are then reselected to become the 3 best employees provided by the Group Decision Support System. The results of Group Decision Support System were found that A2 was in the first place with a Borda score of 0.218336, followed by 2 other employees, namely A52 and A1, with a Borda score of 0.206507 and 0.205753, respectively.

Group Decision Support System Using The Analytic Network Process and Borda Methods for Selecting

The amount of land for the current location of housing development has resulted in developers choosing the location of housing development regardless of the condition of the land, infrastructure, socio-economic. To overcome this problem a computer system is needed in the form of a GDSS that can assist in the selection of Housing Development Locations.This study aims to implement a GDSS with ANP and Borda methods to determine the selection of the right and fast housing development location. GDSS is needed because there are 3 Individual Decision Makers, DM-1 assessing based on Land Conditions, DM-2 assessing Infrastructure-based, DM-3 assess the Socio-Economic and Decision Maker based groups to make the final decision. The ANP method is used to weight the criteria from each alternative location, to the alternative ranking of housing construction locations for each individual Decision Maker. The Borda method is used to combine the results of ranking carried out by the Group Decision Maker so that it gets the final ranking as a determinant of the Location of Housing Development.The final result of this research is a decision support system that can help developers to get a priority recommendation according to the needs of the developer.

Sistem Pendukung Keputusan Kelompok Promosi Jabatan dengan Metode AHP dan BORDA

Abstract Determination of the best employees in a company aims to improve competitiveness and give awards to employees who have high dedication to the company. Difficulties in evaluating employees are the many assessment factors and characteristics of the appraisal and who will provide the appraisal, so that the appraisal is appropriate and transparent. Employee performance appraisal is carried out by 2 assessors namely the company manager and the head of the human resource management department (HRD) and consists of a number of criteria. The assessment will be difficult if done manually considering that each assessor has their own preferences in conducting the assessment. To overcome this we need a computer system that helps decision making, namely a group decision support system (GDSS) determining the best employees in a company
 The group decision support system developed in this study uses the AHP and BORDA methods to assist group decision making. AHP method is used for decision making in each appraiser, while the Borda method is used to combine the decision results of each appraiser so that the final result is the best employee in the company. Based on the final results of the best employee determination system in the form of ranking the final value of each employee. The highest value is used as a recommendation as the best employee.

Sistem Pendukung Keputusan Kelompok Pemilihan e-commerce/marketplace menggunakan metode profile matching dan BORDA

The increasing development of information technology, brings developments to the pattern of life of the Indonesian people, especially the pattern of consumption and shipping of goods. Indonesian society is greatly facilitated and spoiled in getting the desired goods and services. This development was caused by the spread of online shopping providers in Indonesia, which can be accessed via smartphones and computers. Indonesia has a very high number of smartphone users, judging from the number of unique audiences at the end of the second quarter, the data obtained from MMX Multi-platform, June 2017. One of the models used in this study is the Profile Matching method, the method can overcome problems ranking by giving weights based on matching two profiles examined on the criteria of each cell phone. The criteria obtained by the user will be the profile value which is then matched with the conformity profile provided by DM. This study uses three decision makers, including economists, IT experts, and the public. To combine the three decisions used the BORDA method approach. The BORDA method is a voting method that can resolve group decision making, wherein its application each decision maker (DM) provides a rating based on the alternative choices available. Furthermore, this research will use the approach of profile matching and BORDA methods in choosing the best marketplace. The results showed that Sophie's marketplace was ranked first.

Risk Assessment of Human Activities on Protected Areas: A Case Study

ABSTRACTNo study has been done on the impact of anthropogenic risks on protected areas. This may be due to complexity and diversity of risk assessment indices. In this research, using multicriteria decision-making methods, qualitative and complex indices were converted to simple and quantitative indices by which anthropogenic risks affecting the Helleh Protected Area in Iran were analyzed. To this end, a questionnaire was prepared and delivered to Delphi panelists consisting of environmental expertise. In order to prioritize the identified risks, Technique for Order Preference by Similarity to Ideal Solution (TOPSIS), Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP), and Simple Additive Weighting Technique (SAW) were used as a subset of Multiple Attribute Decision-making methods (MADM). In this study, risk factors were evaluated using three criteria of severity, probability of occurrence, and sensitivity of the recipient environment. In order to reach enough transcendence (consensus on priority of risks), an integrated approach comprising average, Borda, and Copeland methods was used. The obtained results suggested that “dam inundation upstream of the study area” is a top-priority risky factor threatening the wetland. “Stopping water pumps from the wetland” and “use of modern irrigation systems” were recommended as the most effective managerial strategies to control the identified risk.

Proposta de um modelo para a avaliação da segurança operacional em aeroportos baseado nos métodos Borda e Promethee II

Este trabalho propõe uma abordagem para a obtenção de um índice global de segurança operacional em pistas aeroportuárias, através da análise de eventos de segurança. Nela ponderam-se os eventos de forma proporcional aos riscos à segurança deles resultantes. A partir da classificação de risco de cada evento, utiliza-se o método Borda para a obtenção de pesos e o método Promethee II para o cálculo de um índice global de segurança. Esta abordagem foi aplicada no Aeroporto Internacional de São Paulo/Guarulhos. Os resultados indicam quedas similares de 3,5% em relação à média no nível de segurança global nos anos 3 e 4. No período mais recente os desempenhos unicriteriais foram positivos em 7 dos 10 critérios avaliados, apresentando queda de 37%, 41% e 17% em relação à média nos indicadores de colisões de aeronaves, colisões de propriedades e danos causados por objetos estranhos respectivamente. Por fim, foram recomendadas ações para elevar os níveis de segurança do sistema aeroportuário. A ponderação com o método Borda foi considerada consistente e o índice global, obtido com o método Promethee II, foi considerado representativo do nível de segurança atingido no sistema aeroportuário.

Environmental Risk Assessment of Dams in Construction Phase Using a Multi-Criteria Decision-Making (MCDM) Method

ABSTRACTThis study was conducted to identify environmental and human health risks caused by Balarood Dam, in construction phrase. The first step, all risk-generating factors were identified using a Delphi Questionnaire. Afterwards, the identified criteria were prioritized once using the Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP) method and then by the Technique for Order of Preference by Similarity to Ideal Solution (TOPSIS). Due to the complex and uncertain nature of decision-making in times of risk, it was necessary to use more than one weighting method to ensure accuracy of weights. The results from AHP and TOPSIS revealed a mismatch in priorities; therefore, an integration method was presented blending Mean-Rank, Borda, and Copeland methods. According to the TOPSIS results, factors including cut and fill, explosion, and transportation, were first to third highest-priority risk-generating factors, respectively. Considering the results from the AHP method, factors cut and fill, drilling, and explosion were identified as first to third top-priority risk-generating factors, respectively. The results obtained from the integration method suggested that cut and fill, explosion, and drilling are the most important environmental risks at construction phase. As a general conclusion, different weighting methods can lead to different results by which the fate of a decision may be changed and it is essential to control final scores by applying more than one weighting method.