A finite element model with realistic bone geometries is developed to design optimal internal fixation during the fibula healing process in this study. The effect of bone plate parameters on fibula fracture healing is studied. The relationship between differences in plate length, thickness and working length, and bone healing performance is focused. The optimal combination form of the bone plate parameters was selected by the orthogonal experimental design and fracture block strain to achieve bone healing maximize the performance. The model results show that the maximum equivalent force of the bone plate was below the material yield limit; the higher mean contact stresses in the bone fragments indicate that the bone plate is prone to higher contact stresses when they are long. The working length of the bone plate has a greater effect on callus healing than the thickness and length of the bone plate. The optimal internal fixation option for distal fibula fractures is achieved when it provides the stability required for internal fixation during bone healing. It ensures lower contact stresses in the fibula as well as maximum Young's modulus during callus healing process.