Composer anniversaries can be an excellent opportunity to stimulate interest in a musician both from scholars and performers. This and last year's special Early Music issues on Buxtehude and Agricola, for example, reflected such developments. Domenico Scarlatti has in 2007 had a less successful year, alas. Although the composer has featured at various festivals, there has not been very much in the way of important new books, articles or recordings. A newly completed recording of all the composer's 560-odd keyboard sonatas on 36 discs in Scarlatti: Complete keyboard sonatas (Brilliant Classics 93546, rec 2000–7, 2307′) from the talented young Dutch harpsichordist Pieter-Jan Belder makes some amends, however. The obvious comparison is with the complete set of these sonatas on 34 CDs by the late-lamented Scott Ross, originally issued on Erato and now available on Warner. Ross recorded all the works in an intensive 18-month period, finishing just in time for the Scarlatti anniversary in 1985, and already suffering from the illness that was to kill him four years later. This set displays every facet of his prodigious technique, mercurial style and delight in the music, and is a very worthy memorial. It was inevitable that one day another harpsichordist would tackle this corpus of wonderful and still too-little-known music. The number of performers with both the stamina and technique to do justice to the astonishing fertility of Scarlatti's invention is never going to be large, and one must admire Belder's achievement. He studied with Bob van Asperen at the Amsterdam Sweelinck Conservatory, and has something of his teacher's ‘determined’ performance style, though without the aggressive edge that van Asperen's recordings occasionally display. Compared to players like Ross himself, Andreas Staier, Trevor Pinnock and Anthony Newman, among the most exciting Scarlatti performers on disc, Belder suffers from some lack of flair, but there is always a place for a thoughtful player who eschews the ‘sempre furioso’ Scarlatti style from which some pianists (and harpsichordists) suffer.
Read full abstract