In Europe, Castanea sativa Mill. is mainly managed as coppice. Health and market problems have raised the interest in the transformation of chestnut coppices into low-density forests for fruit production and silvopastures, or their substitution by naturally occurring broadleaves or timber-oriented plantations. In most cases, a selective or total removal of the existing chestnut stumps is required.We assessed the effectiveness of 7 methods for stump sprout control of Castanea sativa Mill. in Mediterranean conditions (NE Spain). We tested 3 cut-stump herbicide treatments: Roundup Energy Pro® (Glyphosate), Tordon 101® (Picloram + 2,4-D) and Garlon GS® (Fluoxipyr + Triclopyr) and 4 physical methods (stump uprooting or in situ fragmentation by excavator, stump cover with black polyethylene sheet or wood chips).Effectiveness was assessed by means of the number, length and basal width of sprouts in treated stumps one growing season after the treatments application. Phytotoxicity side-effects were assessed by means of foliar symptomatology during the vegetative period following treatments in untreated chestnut stumps neighbouring treated plots and in other broadleaved trees within the treated plots.Stump uprooting and Roundup® Energy Pro cut-stump application provided the highest effectiveness, with near 0 resprouts per treated stump; Garlon GS® and Tordon 101® also showed a high effectiveness (near 10 resprouts per treated stump). Other treatments showed no effectiveness and resprout intensity was not different to control. Herbicide application showed low to moderate phytotoxicity side-effects to neighbouring untreated chestnut stumps, being Roundup® Energy Pro the less phytotoxic. No side-effects were detected in other broadleaved species for any of the herbicides tested.Results suggest that herbicides are an interesting option for chestnut stump removal in poorly accessible or erosion-prone sites, where uprooting with heavy machinery is not feasible. Roundup® Energy Pro and Garlon GS® showed a low phytotoxicity on chestnut and thus can be useful for selective stump removal. The higher phytotoxicity showed by Tordon 101® on chestnut could be a disadvantage for its use if the aim is to reduce the initial density of stumps but maintain some of them in order to transform coppice to an orchard for chestnut production or silvopastures.
Read full abstract