Stability Of Black Holes Research Articles

Stability of generalized Einstein-Maxwell-scalar black holes

We study the stability of static black holes in generalized Einstein-Maxwell-scalar theories. We derive the master equations for the odd and even parity perturbations. The sufficient and necessary conditions for the stability of black holes under odd-parity perturbations are derived. We show that these conditions are usually not similar to energy conditions even in the simplest case of a minimally coupled scalar field. We obtain the necessary conditions for the stability of even-parity perturbations. We also derived the speed of propagation of the five degrees of freedom and obtained the class of theories for which all degrees of freedom propagate at the speed of light. Finally, we have applied our results to various black holes in nonlinear electrodynamics, scalar-tensor theories and Einstein-Maxwell-dilaton theory. For the latter, we have also calculated the quasinormal modes.

On the search for multicenter AdS black holes from M-theory

We study the effective potentials for various probe branes surrounding AdS4 black holes with massive halos in consistent truncations of M-theory on the Sasaki-Einstein7 manifolds Q111 and M111. These probes are either M2 branes extended in spacetime or “particle-like” probes such as internally wrapped M2 branes and, upon reduction to type IIA String theory, D6 branes corresponding to baryon operators in the dual Chern-Simons theory. We find both global and local minima of the potential outside the horizon, indicating the existence of stable and metastable multicenter AdS black holes in the extreme mass ratio regime, at fixed temperature and charges. For the planar case, we also find an instability towards nucleation of spacetime-filling M2 branes. With this analysis, we address some open questions on the holographic description of glassy phases of matter.

Thermodynamics of Kerr-AdS black holes in the restricted phase space

The thermodynamics for Kerr-AdS black hole in four dimensions is revisited using the recently proposed restricted phase space formalism, which includes the central charge C of the dual CFT and the chemical potential mu , but excludes the pressure and the conjugate volume, as thermodynamic variables. The Euler relation holds automatically, and the first order homogeneity of the mass and the zeroth order homogeneity of the intensive variables are made explicit. Thermodynamic processes involving each pair of conjugate variables are studied in some detail, with emphasis on the scaling properties of the equations of states. It turns out that the thermodynamic behavior of the Kerr-AdS black hole is very similar to that of the RN-AdS black hole studied earlier. In particular, it is found that, there is a first order supercritical phase equilibrium in the T-S processes at fixed nonvanishing angular momentum, while at vanishing angular momentum or at fixed angular velocities, there is always a non-equilibrium transition from a small unstable black hole state to a large stable black hole state. Moreover, there is a Hawking–Page phase transition in the mu -C processes. Due to the complicatedness of the Kerr metric, the exact critical point and the Hawking–Page temperature are worked out explicitly only in the slow rotating limit, however the characteristic thermodynamic properties do not rely on the slow rotating approximation.

Dynamic properties of thermodynamic phase transition for five-dimensional neutral Gauss-Bonnet AdS black hole on free energy landscape

Understanding the dynamic process of the thermodynamic phase transition can provide the deep insight into the black hole microscopic properties and structures. We in this paper study the dynamic properties of the stable small-large black hole phase transition for the five-dimensional neutral Gauss-Bonnet AdS black hole. Firstly, by using the first law of black holes, we prove that the extremal points of the free energy on the landscape denote the real black hole solutions satisfying the field equations. The local maximal and minimal points correspond to local unstable and stable black hole states, respectively. Especially, on the free energy landscape, the wells of the coexistence small and large black holes have the same depth. Then we investigate the probability evolution governed by the Fokker-Planck equation. Due to the thermal fluctuation, we find that the small (large) black hole state can transit to the large (small) black hole state. Furthermore, the first passage time is calculated. For each temperature, a single peak is presented, which suggests that there is a considerable fraction of the first passage events taking place at short time. And the higher the temperature is, the faster decrease of the probability is. These results will uncover some intriguing dynamic properties of the stable small-large black hole phase transition in modified gravity.

Geodesic stability and quasinormal modes of non-commutative Schwarzschild black hole employing Lyapunov exponent

We study the dynamics of test particle and stability of circular geodesics in the gravitational field of a non-commutative geometry-inspired Schwarzschild black hole spacetime. The coordinate time Lyapunov exponent ( $$\lambda _{c}$$ ) is crucial to investigate the stability of equatorial circular geodesics of massive and massless test particles. The stability or instability of circular orbits is discussed by analyzing the variation of Lyapunov exponent with radius of these orbits for different values of non-commutative parameter ( $$\alpha $$ ). In the case of null circular orbits, the instability exponent is calculated and presented to discuss the instability of null circular orbits. Further, by relating parameters corresponding to null circular geodesics (i.e., angular frequency and Lyapunov exponent), the quasinormal modes for a massless scalar field perturbation in the eikonal approximation are evaluated and also visualized by relating the real and imaginary parts. The nature of scalar field potential, by varying the non-commutative parameter ( $$\alpha $$ ) and angular momentum of perturbation (l), is also observed and discussed.

Superradiant instability of extremal black holes in STU supergravity

We investigate the superradiant (in)stability of the extremal multicharge static black holes in the STU supergravity model, which reduce to the Reissner-Nordstr\"om (RN) black hole when all the charges are equal. We first show that the frequency of quasibound states is necessarily complex and obtain the corresponding superradiant condition. We then study the effective potential of the Schr\"odinger-like equation associated with the radial function of the charged scalar field. We find that trapping-well configurations can emerge with either a single peak or double peaks. We numerically obtain the corresponding unstable quasibound states, organized under the overtone number, as well as how the charged black holes deviate from the RN black hole. We find that the STU black holes are superradiantly unstable as long as not all the charges are equal, indicating that the superradiant stability of the extremal RN black hole is a fine-tuning result in the framework of the STU supergravity model.

Dynamical scalarization in Einstein-Maxwell-dilaton theory

We study the process of fully nonlinear dynamical scalarization starting from a charged black hole or a naked singularity in asymptotically flat spacetime in the Einstein-Maxwell-dilaton theory. Initially the dilaton field is negligible compared to the gravitational and the Maxwell field. Then the dilaton field experiences an immediate growth, later it oscillates with damping amplitude and finally settles down to a finite value. For a hairy black hole develops from an original Reissner-Nordstr\"om black hole, since the dilaton oscillation and decay are almost independent of the coupling parameter, unlike the Anti-de Sitter spacetime it is not easy to distinguish the resulting hairy black hole from the original asymptotically flat charged hole. For a hairy black hole evolves from an original naked singularity, the resulting hairy black hole has rich structures. In the scalarization process, the naked singularity is soon enveloped by one outer horizon, then another horizon is developed and in the end a stable hairy black hole forms and two horizons degenerate into one to protect the singularity. The hairy black hole mass saturates exponentially in the scalarization.

Loop quantum deparametrized Schwarzschild interior and discrete black hole mass

We present the detailed analyses of a model of loop quantum Schwarzschild interior coupled to a massless scalar field and extend the results in our previous rapid communication arXiv:2006.08313 to more general schemes. It is shown that the spectrum of the black hole mass is discrete and does not contain zero. This indicates the existence of a black hole remnant after Hawking evaporation due to loop quantum gravity effects. Besides to show the existence of a stable black hole remnant in the vacuum case, the quantum dynamics for the non-vacuum case is also solved and compared with the effective one.

Higher-Dimensional Regular Reissner–Nordström Black Holes Associated with Linear Electrodynamics

Following the interpretation of matter source that the energy-momentum tensor of anisotropic fluid can be dealt with effectively as the energy-momentum tensor of perfect fluid plus linear (Maxwell) electromagnetic field, we obtain the regular higher-dimensional Reissner–Nordström (Tangherlini–RN) solution by starting with the noncommutative geometry-inspired Schwarzschild solution. Using the boundary conditions that connect the noncommutative Schwarzschild solution in the interior of the charged perfect fluid sphere to the Tangherlini–RN solution in the exterior of the sphere, we find that the interior structure can be reflected by an exterior parameter, the charge-to-mass ratio. Moreover, we investigate the stability of the boundary under mass perturbation and indicate that the new interpretation imposes a rigid restriction upon the charge-to-mass ratio. This restriction, in turn, permits a stable noncommutative black hole only in the 4-dimensional spacetime.

Linear Stability of Black Holes and Naked Singularities

A review of the current status of the linear stability of black holes and naked singularities is given. The standard modal approach, that takes advantage of the background symmetries and analyze separately the harmonic components of linear perturbations, is briefly introduced and used to prove that the naked singularities in the Kerr–Newman family, as well as the inner black hole regions beyond Cauchy horizons, are unstable and therefore unphysical. The proofs require a treatment of the boundary condition at the timelike boundary, which is given in detail. The nonmodal linear stability concept is then introduced, and used to prove that the domain of outer communications of a Schwarzschild black hole with a non-negative cosmological constant satisfies this stronger stability condition, which rules out transient growths of perturbations, and also to show that the perturbed black hole settles into a slowly rotating Kerr black hole. The encoding of the perturbation fields in gauge invariant curvature scalars and the effects of the perturbation on the geometry of the spacetime is discussed. These notes follow from a course delivered at the V José Plínio Baptista School of Cosmology, held at Guarapari (Espírito Santo) Brazil, from 30 September to 5 October 2021.

Stability and phase transition of rotating Kaluza\u2013Klein black holes

In this paper, we investigate the thermodynamics and phase transitions of a four-dimensional rotating Kaluza–Klein black hole solution in the presence of Maxwell electrodynamics. Calculating the conserved and thermodynamic quantities shows that the first law of thermodynamics is satisfied. To find the stable black hole’s criteria, we check the stability in the canonical ensemble by analyzing the behavior of the heat capacity. We also consider a massive scalar perturbation minimally coupled to the background geometry of the four-dimensional static Kaluza–Klein black hole and investigate the quasinormal modes by employing the Wentzel–Kramers–Brillouin (WKB) approximation. The anomalous decay rate of the quasinormal modes spectrum is investigated by using the sixth-order WKB formula and quasi-resonance modes of the black hole are studied with averaging of Padé approximations as well.

Bound orbits around charged black holes with exponential and logarithmic electrodynamics

We present exact black hole solutions endowed with magnetic charge coming from exponential and logarithmic nonlinear electrodynamics (NLED). Classically, we analyze the null and timelike geodesics, all of which contain both the bound and the scattering orbits. Using the effective geometry formalism, we found that photon can have nontrivial stable (both circular and non-circular) bound orbits. The noncircular bound orbits for the one-horizon case mostly take the form of precessed ellipse. For the extremal and three-horizon cases we find many-world orbits where photon crosses the outer horizon but bounces back without hitting the true (or second, respectively) horizon, producing the epicycloid and epitrochoid paths.Semiclassically, we investigate their Hawking temperature, stability, and phase transition. The nonlinearity enables black hole stability with smaller radius than its RN counterpart. However, for very-strong nonlinear regime, the thermodynamic behavior tends to be Schwarzschild-like.

GR-Athena++: Puncture Evolutions on Vertex-centered Oct-tree Adaptive Mesh Refinement

Abstract Numerical relativity is central to the investigation of astrophysical sources in the dynamical and strong-field gravity regime, such as binary black hole and neutron star coalescences. Current challenges set by gravitational-wave and multimessenger astronomy call for highly performant and scalable codes on modern massively parallel architectures. We present GR-Athena++, a general-relativistic, high-order, vertex-centered solver that extends the oct-tree, adaptive mesh refinement capabilities of the astrophysical (radiation) magnetohydrodynamics code Athena++. To simulate dynamical spacetimes, GR-Athena++ uses the Z4c evolution scheme of numerical relativity coupled to the moving puncture gauge. We demonstrate stable and accurate binary black hole merger evolutions via extensive convergence testing, cross-code validation, and verification against state-of-the-art effective-one-body waveforms. GR-Athena++ leverages the task-based parallelism paradigm of Athena++ to achieve excellent scalability. We measure strong-scaling efficiencies above 95% for up to ∼1.2 × 104 CPUs and excellent weak scaling is shown up to ∼105 CPUs in a production binary black hole setup with adaptive mesh refinement. GR-Athena++ thus allows for the robust simulation of compact binary coalescences and offers a viable path toward numerical relativity at exascale.

Superradiance and stability of Kerr black hole enclosed by anisotropic fluid matter

Focusing on the rotating black hole (BH) surrounded by the anisotropic fluid matters; radiation, dust, and dark matter, we study the massive scalar superradiant scattering and the stability in the Kiselev spacetime. Superradiance behavior is dependent on the intensity parameter of the anisotropic matter K in the Kiselev spacetime. By adopting the manifest of low-frequency and low-mass for the scalar perturbation, we find K<0 enhances the superradiance scattering within the broader frequency range, compared to K=0 while K>0 suppresses within the narrower frequency range. As a result, the radiation and dark matter around the rotating BH act as amplifier and attenuator for the massive scalar superradiance, respectively. This is while the dust has a twofold role because of admitting both signs of K. Through stability analysis in the light of the BH bomb mechanism, we show in the presence of dark matter, the instability regime of standard Kerr BH (K=0) gets improved in favor of stabilization while the radiation and dust do not affect it. In other words, by taking the dark matter fluid around BH into account, we obtain a broader regime that allows the massive scalar field dynamic to enjoy superradiant stability.

Analytic topological hairy dyonic black holes and thermodynamics

We present and discuss a new family of topological hairy dyonic black hole solutions in asymptotically anti--de Sitter space. The coupled Einstein-Maxwell-scalar gravity system, that carries both the electric and magnetic charges is solved, and exact hairy dyonic black hole solutions are obtained analytically. The scalar field profiles that give rise to such black hole solutions are regular everywhere. The hairy solutions are obtained for planar, spherical, and hyperbolic horizon topologies. In addition, analytic expressions of regularized action, stress tensor, conserved charges, and free energies are obtained. We further comment on different prescriptions for computing the black hole mass with hairy backgrounds. We analyze the thermodynamics of these hairy dyonic black holes in canonical and grand canonical ensembles, and we find that both electric and magnetic charges have a constructive effect on the stability of the hairy solution. For the case of planar and hyperbolic horizons, we find thermodynamically stable hairy black holes that are favored at low temperatures compared to the nonhairy counterparts. We further find that, for a spherical hairy dyonic black hole, the thermodynamic phase diagram resembles to that of a Van der Waals fluid not only in canonical but also in the grand canonical ensemble.

Quantum work and information geometry of a quantum Myers-Perry black hole

In this paper, we will obtain quantum work for a quantum scale five dimensional Myers-Perry black hole. Unlike heat represented by Hawking radiation, the quantum work is represented by a unitary information preserving process, and becomes important for black holes only at small quantum scales. It will be observed that at such short distances, the quantum work will be corrected by non-perturbative quantum gravitational corrections. We will use the Jarzynski equality to obtain this quantum work modified by non-perturbative quantum gravitational corrections. These non-perturbative corrections will also modify the stability of a quantum Myers-Perry black hole. We will define a quantum corrected information geometry by incorporating the non-perturbative quantum corrections in the information geometry of a Myers-Perry black hole. We will use several different quantum corrected effective information metrics to analyze the stability of a quantum Myers-Perry black hole.

Higher-dimensional black hole solutions with scalar hair and dilaton field and toroidal horizons and interior solution

In this study, we investigate black hole solutions with toroidal horizons in scalar hair and dilaton gravity. First, we obtain the field equations in n-dimensions. Then, we propose different models (ansatz) and find the exact solutions for these types of ansatzs. These solutions are not asymptotically (anti) de Sitter or flat, except in one special case. We also show that the BTZand BTZ-like solutions emerge from some of these solutions as a special case. We also show that when the event horizon radius increases, the temperature will be the same in various dimensions. The only difference is noticeable near the origin (this statement is clear from the figures). For these solutions, we obtained a new version of the Smarr formula. In addition, we show that the presence of the scalar field makes the black holes more stable near the origin, except for the BTZ case. In general, the presence of a scalar field is an important factor in black hole stability investigations. In the critical behavior analysis, we find that there is no evidence to show the existence of P-V criticality. Here, we present a class of interior solutions corresponding to the solution in a scalar hair gravity exterior. The solution obtained in the linear case was regular and well-behaved at the stellar interior.

Odd-parity stability of black holes in Einstein-aether gravity

In Einstein-aether theory, we study the stability of black holes against odd-parity perturbations on a spherically symmetric and static background. For odd-parity modes, there are two dynamical degrees of freedom arising from the tensor gravitational sector and aether vector field. We derive general conditions under which neither ghosts nor Laplacian instabilities are present for these dynamical fields. We apply these results to concrete black hole solutions known in the literature and show that some of those solutions can be excluded by the violation of stability conditions. The exact Schwarzschild solution present for ${c}_{13}={c}_{14}=0$, where ${c}_{i}$'s are the four coupling constants of the theory with ${c}_{ij}={c}_{i}+{c}_{j}$, is prone to Laplacian instabilities along the angular direction throughout the horizon exterior. However, we find that the odd-parity instability of high radial and angular momentum modes is absent for black hole solutions with ${c}_{13}={c}_{4}=0$ and ${c}_{1}\ensuremath{\ge}0$.

Slowly rotating black holes and their scalarization

We study scalarization of slowly rotating black holes in the Einstein-scalar-Gauss-Bonnet (GB)-Chern-Simons (CS) theory. In the slow rotation approximation of $a\ll1$ with rotation parameter $a$, the GB term is given by a term for Schwarzschild black hole, whereas the CS term takes a linear term of $a$. The tachyonic instability for slowly rotating black holes represents the onset of spontaneous scalarization. We use the (2+1)-dimensional hyperboloidal foliation method to show the tachyonic instability for slowly rotating black holes by considering the time evolution of a spherically symmetric scalar mode. A threshold (existence) curve is obtained from the constant scalar modes under time evolution, which means the boundary between stable and unstable black holes. It is found that the slowly rotating black holes turn out to be unstable against a spherically symmetric scalar-mode propagation for positive coupling $\alpha$. However, we could not find tachyonic instability and any $a$-bound for scalarization for negative coupling $\alpha$.

Effective thermodynamical system of Schwarzschild–de Sitter black holes from Rényi statistics

It has been known that the Schwarzschild-de Sitter (Sch-dS) black hole may not be in thermal equilibrium and also be found to be thermodynamically unstable in the standard black hole thermodynamics. In the present work, we investigate the possibility to realize the thermodynamical stability of the Sch-dS black hole as an effective system by using the R\'{e}nyi statistics, which includes the non-extensive nature of black holes. Our results indicate that the non-extensivity allows the black hole to be thermodynamically stable which gives rise to the lower bound on the non-extensive parameter. By comparing the results to ones in the separated system approach, we find that the effective temperature is always smaller than the black hole horizon temperature and the thermodynamically stable black hole in effective approach is always larger than one in separated approach at a certain temperature. There exists only the zeroth-order phase transition from the the hot gas phase to the black hole phase for the effective system while it is possible to have the transition of both the zeroth order and the first order for the separated system.