Bispecific Antibody Formats Research Articles

Effect of Domain Order on the Activity of Bacterially Produced Bispecific Single-chain Fv Antibodies

Bispecific single-chain Fv antibodies comprise four covalently linked immunoglobulin variable (VH and VL) domains of two different specificities. Depending on the order of the VH and VL domains and on the length of peptides separating them, the single-chain molecule either forms two single-chain Fv (scFv) modules from the adjacent domains of the same specificity, a so-called scFv–scFv tandem [(scFv) 2], or folds head-to-tail with the formation of a diabody-like structure, a so-called bispecific single-chain diabody (scBsDb). We generated a number of four-domain constructs composed of the same VH and VL domains specific either for human CD19 or CD3, but arranged in different orders. When expressed in bacteria, all (scFv) 2 variants appeared to be only half-functional, binding to CD19 and demonstrating no CD3-binding activity. Only the diabody-like scBsDb could bind both antigens. Comparison of the scBsDb with a structurally similar non-covalent dimer (diabody) demonstrated a stabilizing effect of the linker in the middle of the scBsDb molecule. We demonstrated that the mechanism of inactivation of CD19×CD3 diabody under physiological conditions is initiated by a dissociation of the weaker (anti-CD3) VH/VL interface followed by domain swapping with the formation of non-active homodimers. The instability of one homodimer makes the process of diabody dissociation/reassociation irreversible, thus gradually decreasing the fraction of active molecules. The structural parameters influencing the formation of functional bispecific single-chain antibodies are indicated and ways of making relatively stable bispecific molecules are proposed.

The inter-heavy chain disulfide bonds of IgG4 are in equilibrium with intra-chain disulfide bonds

Unlike other immunoglobulin G (IgG) subclasses, IgG4 antibodies in plasma have been reported to be functionally monovalent. In a previous paper, we showed that the apparent monovalency of circulating IgG4 antibodies is caused by asymmetry of plasma IgG4 — a large fraction has two antigen-binding sites resulting in bispecificity. We postulated that the generation of bispecific antibodies was caused by a post-secretion mechanism, involving the exchange of IgG4 half-molecules (i.e. one heavy and one light chain). This hypothesis was based on the observed instability of the inter-heavy chain disulfide bonds of IgG4. To investigate this instability, we constructed IgG4 mutants and analyzed the covalent interaction between the heavy chains by sodium dodecyl sulfate-poly acrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE) under non-reducing conditions. The mutation to serine of one of the hinge cysteines involved in the inter-heavy chain bond formation, Cys226, resulted in a more stable rather than a more labile inter-heavy chain linkage. Moreover, we confirmed that mutating the IgG4 hinge sequence Cys-Pro-Ser-Cys to the IgG1 hinge sequence Cys-Pro-Pro-Cys also markedly stabilizes the covalent interaction between the heavy-chains. These two observations suggested an explanation for the observed instability of the inter-heavy chain disulfide bonds: the formation of an alternative, intra-chain cystine. Obviously, this intra-chain cystine cannot be formed in the mutant where Cys226 is replaced by Ser, and cannot easily be formed in the mutant with the IgG1 hinge sequence (Cys-Pro-Pro-Cys) due to the restricted torsional freedom of prolines. We, therefore, postulate that the lack of a covalent heavy-chain interaction in a subpopulation of IgG4 reflects an equilibrium between inter- and intra-chain cystines. Based upon the published structure of the IgG4-related hinge-deleted IgG1 myeloma protein Mcg, we propose a model for the two forms of IgG4 and for the half-molecule exchange reaction, which might result in the formation of bispecific IgG4 antibodies.