Elastic behaviour controls hydraulic fracture propagation and ultimately, the productivity of unconventional reservoirs. Various index tests and single stage triaxial tests are used to characterize elastic moduli but it can be difficult to obtain enough samples and sufficient information. This is partly due to the fissile nature of shales, which results in a paucity of representative core plugs. It is also partially due to the complex and heterogeneous nature of unconventional reservoir's geomechanical behaviour. The failure mechanics of unconventional rocks are poorly understood and seldom incorporated in hydraulic fracturing or geomechanical models. Yet, failure is major influence on fracture complexity and reservoir drainage volumes.The objectives of this study were to evaluate the variability in geomechanical properties and characterize the post-peak behaviour of a stiff siltstone from the Montney Formation in Alberta, Canada. The multiple failure state triaxial test was used to define the pre-peak elastic behaviour, post-peak behaviour, and failure envelope of a single core plug. This is beneficial for practitioners that are faced with a paucity of samples. The multiple failure state triaxial test is difficult to implement for stiff specimens, which fail in a brittle and unstable manner and a methodology to improve the stability near and beyond sample failure was therefore developed.The results from this study, which were also compared to various index tests and publicly available data, show that the samples had low porosity, low clay, and high stiffness. Significant variability in elastic behaviour was observed due to non-linearities in the loading curve – an effect that overshadowed changes due to confining pressure and highlighted that need for careful consideration of elastic parameter variability. Several oriented samples sets were used to characterize elastic and strength anisotropy. The improved test methodology was able to capture stable post-peak behaviour on almost all the tested samples. Brittle stick-slip failure was observed and an exponential model for approximating post-peak behaviour was presented. The combination of triaxial testing and index testing was able to completely characterize the constitutive law and failure envelope of the samples, save the Biot coefficient. These results can be incorporated into both routine and advanced geomechanical models and hydraulic fracturing simulators.