A theoretical approach is presented to quantify the effect of ionic strength on the swelling and shrinkage of the hydrodynamic coil size of a generic biopolymer. This was conducted in view of extraction methods that often utilize acids and alkali combinations and, therefore, invariably impact the levels of salt found in commercially available biopolymers. This approach is supplemented by intrinsic viscosity measurements for the purpose of validation across a variety of biopolymer architectures, type of functionalization, as well as the quoted molar mass. By accurately capturing the magnitude of change in the coil size, it is discussed how a biopolymer coil size is far more sensitive to changes in the ionic strength than it is to the molar mass (or contour length) itself. In turn, it is highlighted why the current characterization strategies that make use of weight-averaged molar mass are prone to errors and cannot be used to establish structure—property relationships for biopolymers. As an alternative, the scope of developing an accurate understanding of coil sizes due to changes in the “soft” interactions is proposed, and it is recommended to use the coil size itself to highlight the underlying structure—property relationships.