Recent 15N R1ρ-relaxation studies have shown that proteins in the solid state undergo slow, low amplitude global motion in the sub-millisecond time range. This range is at the edge of the time window for R1ρ experiments and, therefore, the motional parameters obtained by this method are not precise or reliable. In this paper, we present a 2H stimulated echo study of this type of molecular dynamics. The 2H stimulated echo experiments on a static sample allow for direct measurement of the correlation function in the time range of 10-6-10-1s, making them well suited to study this type of molecular mobility. We have conducted a detailed analytical and numerical comparison of the correlation functions obtained from the relaxation and stimulated echo experiments, which are generally different. We have identified conditions and algorithms that enable a direct comparison of the relaxation and stimulated echo experimental results. Using the protein GB1 in the form of a lyophilized powder, we have demonstrated that 15N R1ρ-relaxation and 2H stimulated echo experiments yield essentially the same slow-motion correlation function. Surprisingly, this type of motion is observed not only in the protein sample but also in the tripeptide and single amino acid solid samples. The comparison of data measured in these three samples at different temperatures led us to conclude that this slow motion is, in fact, ultrasonic phonons, which seem to be inherent to all rigid biological solids.
Read full abstract