Reviewed by: A Quiet Passion dir. by Terence Davies Jonnie Guerra (bio) A Quiet Passion. Dir. Terence Davies. Screenplay by Terence Davies. Perf. Cynthia Nixon, Jennifer Ehle, Duncan Duff, and Keith Carradine. Music Box Films, 2017. Film. Terence Davies's biopic of Emily Dickinson, A Quiet Passion, was released to movie theaters in the United States in April. Among its most striking features are imaginative cinematography, a compelling narrative, and exceptional performances by Emma Bell and Cynthia Nixon in the role of Emily Dickinson. No doubt the many liberties Davies takes with biographical facts in his screenplay will spark controversy among Dickinson scholars and other devotees. Even so, A Quiet Passion has the potential to inspire viewers to want to read or reread Dickinson's poetry and to question, perhaps even rethink, their conceptions about her life. Davies's two-hour film stands to become the most significant popular culture event in Dickinson studies since the 1977 premiere of William Luce's The Belle of Amherst, starring Julie Harris. A biographical film about Dickinson poses obvious challenges for its screenplay writer. How does one recount the story of a poet whose fame came posthumously and whose interior life of mind and heart, as evidenced by her poems and letters, was far richer and more interesting than what occurred in her outward life? In developing the screenplay, Davies employs known facts, events, and people identified in biographies of Dickinson as well as familiar elements of the legends that have sprung up around her story. However, most of the details and dialogue that flesh out the real events represented are fictional. In some instances, dramatic situations and characters are wholly imaginary. In contrast to plays and novels about the poet's life that rely on a romantic plot, A Quiet Passion foregrounds the Dickinson family and its internal dynamics, with the Homestead, its interior, and the surrounding gardens as the primary setting. At the same time, the film [End Page 80] creates a vivid context for Emily's life as a woman and writer by its attention to historical issues of nineteenth-century America, particularly evangelism, gender inequality, and the upheaval of the Civil War. Its portrayal of psychological and physical illness—especially the latter, which the film makes, in moments, visually terrifying—is a stark reminder of the limited medical knowledge and treatment options available during Dickinson's lifetime. A Quiet Passion opens with a scene at Mount Holyoke Female Academy. Headmistress Mary Lyon (Sara Vertongen) admonishes the teen-aged Dickinson (Bell) for being the school's only "no-hoper." This reprimand is Miss Lyon's response to Emily's audacious public admission that her feelings about salvation are "indefinite." Soon after, the movie segues to a chronicle of events in Dickinson's mature life, carrying the poet's story forward to her death and funeral. Although the narrative frame is linear, the sequencing of episodes, most of them short, is not entirely chronological, though probably only Dickinson insiders will perceive the departures from biographical truth. The film has a tripartite structure moving from harmony to contention and discord, and finally to ruptures in the family unit. The first block of scenes focuses on Emily and her siblings as teenagers. We meet Austin (Benjamin Wainwright), Vinnie (Rose Williams), and Mr. Dickinson (Keith Carradine) when they arrive to rescue Emily from Mount Holyoke. Returning to the sanctuary of her Amherst home and winning her father's permission to write poetry at night, Emily views her life as "wonderful" and the future as full of promise. The strong bond that exists among Emily and her brother and sister is illustrated well, especially in their comical interactions with strait-laced, opinionated Aunt Elizabeth (Annette Badland). Aunt Elizabeth is confounded by the playful mockery and precocious behavior of the sibling threesome and irate that their parents not only tolerate, but seem also to enjoy the children's high jinx. This segment of the film ends dramatically in the setting of a photography studio. The family members—minus Emily Norcross Dickinson—pose serially for their daguerreotypes to be taken. As the camera moves in slowly on each face, the character undergoes a transformation in age in...