Biofeedback Treatment Research Articles

Long-Term Outcomes of Pelvic Floor Exercise and Biofeedback Treatment for Patients With Fecal Incontinence

The aim of this study was to assess the long-term clinical and quality of life outcomes for patients after referral to a four-month treatment program for fecal incontinence based on pelvic floor exercises and biofeedback. Secondary objectives were to document patients' subsequent treatment activities and their perception of the biofeedback training; to establish the long-term outcomes and initial predictors for the subset of patients who did not complete the treatment, or who failed to improve during the program; and to correlate changes in clinical outcome measures and quality of life over time. Patients were contacted by telephone to determine their perception of progress subsequent to the treatment program, any subsequent treatment or activities relating to their fecal incontinence, and which aspect of the treatment program they believed was most helpful. St. Mark's and Pescatori fecal incontinence scores were also recorded, along with patients' self-assessments of their incontinence severity and quality of life. Eighty-three (69 percent) patients were contacted for interviews at a median of 42 (range, 26-56) months after program completion. At the time of follow-up, patients who completed the program continued to enjoy strongly significant improvements in all outcome measures, with 75 percent perceiving a symptomatic improvement and 83 percent reporting improved quality of life. For many patients, improvement continued subsequent to program completion. Patients whose incontinence scores became worse during treatment still reported improvement in their quality of life and perceived incontinence severity during the same time period; many experienced some degree of "catch-up" in their continence scores during the follow-up period. Fourteen patients (17 percent) went on to have surgery for fecal incontinence; of these, 6 (7 percent) had a stoma. Twenty (24 percent) regularly took antidiarrheal medication. Thirty program completers (41 percent) were continuing pelvic floor exercises. This study confirms the long-term improvement in fecal incontinence achieved through treatment with biofeedback and pelvic floor exercises. In this study, patients also continued to improve after treatment completion, possibly because of the strong emphasis placed on patients during treatment to continue the pelvic floor exercises on their own. The poor correlation between quality of life and quantitative scores of fecal incontinence suggests that there are important aspects of continence that are not being appropriately recognized.

The improvement/rehabilitation of auditory memory functioning with EEG biofeedback

Five clinical case studies (1 normal, 3 brain injured and 1 subject who had a left frontal hematoma) are presented which addressed the effectiveness of EEG biofeedback for auditory memory impairment. A normative QEEG activation database of 59 right-handed subjects was developed, which delineated the QEEG variables which were positively related to auditory memory performance (paragraphs). Persons who had experienced a brain injury underwent the same procedure employed in the development of the database. The person's values on the effective parameters of memory functioning were determined. EEG biofeedback interventions were determined by the individual's deviation from the normative reference group in terms of the relevant QEEG parameters of effective auditory memory (paragraph recall). Improvements ranged from 39% subjects who had a follow up assessment that occurred from one month to one year following termination of treatment.

Patient's perceptions of biofeedback therapy for obstructive defaecation.

OBJECTIVE: The aim of this study is to assess the long-term outcomes of a biofeedback treatment programme for obstructive defaecation up to five years after completion of treatment, reporting from the patients' perspective the subsequent progression of defaecation difficulties and the perceived usefulness of the biofeedback training and its components. METHODS: A biofeedback program for obstructive defaecation at a major hospital in Sydney provided 37 patients with reading material, taught defaecation techniques, and prescribed simulated defaecation and anal relaxation exercises to practice between their monthly biofeedback sessions. Twenty-nine of these patients were contacted by telephone an average of 23 months after last attending and asked to rate the present severity of their condition, changes since last attending biofeedback, and which aspects of the program they found most helpful. RESULTS: Of patients who completed the program, 70% achieved at least a 15% improvement in perceived symptom severity. Those who completed the program and achieved benefit were more likely to name the exercises as the most helpful program component. At the time of follow-up, however, there was no difference in perceived symptom severity between program completers and noncompleters. Program completers, and those followed up more than two years after last attending biofeedback, were more likely to report a worsening in symptom severity subsequent to their final treatment session. CONCLUSIONS: This study confirms the favourable short-term outcomes achieved by some patients completing biofeedback treatment for obstructive defaecation. The findings suggest that biofeedback equipment may be economically used in an educative and corrective role, and that other factors such as education, exercises and counselling alone play an important role. Finally, the benefits of biofeedback may not be maintained through long-term follow-up, raising questions as to the natural history of the disorder and the long-term effectiveness of biofeedback treatment.

Biofeedback and behavioral treatment of persistent pain in the older adult: a review and a study.

Persistent pain is a common health problem for older adults, age 60+, with a prevalence twice that in younger adults. Yet, older adults with chronic pain and headache are underrepresented in behaviorally oriented clinical programs that have proven effective for younger adults. A review of the literature indicates that older adults develop multiple pain-related problems that are similar to those of younger individuals. When offered the opportunity, older pain patients accept and benefit from multidisciplinary pain programs, cognitive-behavioral therapies and biofeedback training. A study comparing 58 older and 59 younger adults in a multidisciplinary pain program indicates that older pain patients readily acquire the physiological self-regulation skills taught in biofeedback-assisted relaxation training, and achieve comparable decreases in pain for the pain program as a whole.

Time-related decay of the benefits of biofeedback therapy.

Although immediate results are good to excellent in great majority of patients who undergo biofeedback treatment (BFT) for chronic constipation and fecal incontinence, they tend to loose the benefit over a period of time. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the long-term sustainability of results after successful biofeedback treatment. Two groups of patients who successfully completed BFT at our institution from 1995 to 1997 were created based on the date of completion. The first had a mean follow-up of 35 months and the second group was followed for an average of 12 months. Both groups were questioned as to the presence of constipation and incontinence. The questioning was focused depending on the patient's diagnosis. This information was then compared with the initial BFT results. Overall, all patients were satisfied by the initial BFT results. All patients initially had an excellent or good response to BFT. However, after a mean of 35 months, in the first group, 19 of 22 patients had a near complete regression back to their pre-biofeedback status. In the 14 patients in the second group with mean follow-up of 12 months, 11 had a significant decay in benefits. Only time was a significant factor in the decay of BFT benefits. In conclusion, BFT is highly effective in the treatment of selected patients with complex defecation disorders. Although there is a high initial success rate, there is a clear loss of the immediate benefits over time. Other factors such as dietary habits, pelvic floor exercises, manometry, invasive EMG, and rectal sensation did not correlate with long-term outcomes. The comparison between the two groups reveals a linear model describing the time decay of the benefits of BFT. Based on the linear model, patients may need reevaluation after one year and may benefit from additional BFT.

Electromyographic biofeedback–controlled exercise versus conservative care for patellofemoral pain syndrome

Dursun N, Dursun E, Kiliç Z. Electromyographic biofeedback–controlled exercise versus conservative care for patellofemoral pain syndrome. Arch Phys Med Rehabil 2001;82:1692-5. Objective: To determine the effects of electromyographic biofeedback treatment in patients with patellofemoral pain syndrome. Design: Randomized controlled trial. Setting: A physical medicine and rehabilitation department in a research hospital of a university referral center. Patients: Sixty patients with patellofemoral pain syndrome. Patients were randomly placed into 2 groups: biofeedback group (n = 30) and a control group (n = 30). Intervention: The biofeedback group received electromyographic biofeedback training and a conventional exercise program, whereas the control group received a conventional exercise program only. Main Outcome Measures: Maximum and mean contraction values of the vastus medialis and the vastus lateralis muscles were assessed with the biofeedback device. Pain and functional status of the patients were measured by a visual analog scale (VAS) and the Functional Index Questionnaire (FIQ), respectively. Results: Contraction values improved significantly at the end of the first month, compared with the pretreatment values in both groups. Mean contraction values in the biofeedback group of the vastus medialis muscles in all 3 monthly measurements, and the vastus lateralis muscles at the end of the first month, were significantly higher than those of the control group. Significant improvements were shown for both the VAS and the FIQ in both groups. Monthly follow-ups showed no VAS and FIQ differences between the groups. Conclusion: Electromyographic biofeedback treatment did not result in further clinical improvement when compared with a conventional exercise program in patients with patellofemoral pain syndrome. © 2001 by the American Congress of Rehabilitation Medicine and the American Academy of Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation

Response to a behavioural treatment, biofeedback, in constipated patients is associated with improved gut transit and autonomic innervation

BACKGROUNDAlthough behavioural treatment (biofeedback) successfully treats the pelvic floor abnormalities in patients with idiopathic constipation, many patients also normalise their impaired bowel frequency. We postulated that a response may be...

EEG Biofeedback Treatment of ADD

Literature searches dating back to 1968 were conducted through Psychlit and Medline services to review the scientific literature on EEG biofeedback treatment of ADD. While anecdotal and case reports cite promising evidence, methodological problems coupled with a paucity of research precludes any definitive conclusions as to the efficacy of enhanced alpha and hemisphere-specific EEG biofeedback training. One of the more promising EEG biofeedback treatment paradigms involves theta/beta training. Studies have reported that academic, intellectual, and behavioral gains have been attained with this approach. Significant behavioral and cognitive changes have also been reported following SMR training. However, research into these treatment approaches has also been marred by methodological inadequacies and lack of sufficient follow-up studies. A number of recommendations for future research into this treatment approach are made.

Biofeedback treatment of fecal incontinence: a critical review.

The aims of this review are 1) to critically evaluate the literature on the efficacy of biofeedback treatment for fecal incontinence, 2) to compare different types of biofeedback, and 3) to identify patient characteristics which predict a successful outcome. The MEDLINE database was searched for articles published between 1973 and 1999 which included the terms "biofeedback" and "fecal incontinence." Pediatric and adult articles in any language were screened. Inclusion for review required that the study be prospective, have five or more subjects, and have a description of the treatment protocol. Thirty-five studies were reviewed. Only six studies used a parallel treatment design and just three of those randomized subjects to treatment groups. A meta-analysis (weighted by subjects) was performed to compare the results of two treatment protocols that dominate the literature. The mean success rate of studies using Coordination training (i.e., coordinating pelvic floor muscle contraction with the sensation of rectal filling) was 67 percent, while the mean success rate for studies using Strength training (i.e., pelvic floor muscle contraction) was 70 percent. Furthermore, the mean success rate for those Strength training studies using electromyographic biofeedback was 74 percent, while the mean success rate for studies using anal canal pressure biofeedback Strength training was 64 percent. However, these conclusions are limited by the absence of clearly identified criteria for determining success. There are also inconsistencies in the literature regarding the patient selection criteria, severity and cause of symptoms, amount of treatment, as well as the type of biofeedback protocols and instrumentation used. Finally, no patient characteristics were identified that would assist in predicting successful outcome. Although most studies report positive results using biofeedback to treat fecal incontinence, quality research is lacking. Recommendations are made for future investigations to 1) improve experimental design, 2) include long term follow-up data, and 3) to use an adequate sample size that allows for meaningful analysis.

A comparison of two approaches to biofeedback treatment in children with recalcitrant constipation/encopresis. Long term follow up

A comparison of two approaches to biofeedback treatment in children with recalcitrant constipation/encopresis. Long term follow up

A comparison of two approaches to biofeedback treatment in children with recalcitrant constipation/encopresis. Long term follow up

A comparison of two approaches to biofeedback treatment in children with recalcitrant constipation/encopresis. Long term follow up

Extending the efficacy of a thermal biofeedback treatment package to the management of tension-type headaches in children.

This study explored the efficacy of a thermal biofeedback treatment package as an intervention with children with tension-type headaches. In a within-subject, time-lagged, multiple baseline design, five children, aged 8 to 14 years, were assigned to baselines of varying lengths prior to receiving treatment. Treatment was introduced sequentially across subjects and involved six thermal biofeedback treatment visits. Parents were also given guidelines for how best to encourage children to independently use the biofeedback skills. Data confirm that the participants learned the handwarming skill, practiced the skill on a regular basis during treatment, and independently used the skills to manage their pain. All participants demonstrated clinically significant reductions in one or more headache parameters (frequency, duration, intensity) following treatment. At 6-month follow-up, four of the five participants were headache-free. Although the thermal biofeedback treatment package was generally effective for these children with tension-type headaches, the specific type of headache experienced by each child appeared to influence the specific response to treatment. In addition, no single measure of headache activity was the best indicator of response to treatment. The efficacy of the thermal biofeedback treatment package is supported as an alternative treatment for children suffering from tension-type headaches.

Biofeedback treatment in patients with refractory epilepsy: Changes in depression and control orientation

Depression is a common and serious interictal problem in patients with epilepsy. The genesis of depressive disorders is multifactorial. One aetiological aspect focuses on psychosocial factors. It was hypothesized that uncontrollable, unpredictable chronic aversive events (i.e. epileptic seizures) result in cognitive deficits ofexternal control orientation. If this is true, biofeedback training could represent a possible treatment strategy to lower depression, because biofeedback is known to mediate success experiences and control. Measures of depression and locus of control were administered to 20 patients with refractory partial epilepsy before and after biofeedback treatment. The biofeedback consisted of slow cortical potentials or breathing parameters in 10 patients each. A clear relationship occurred between depression and locus of control in the subjects. After biofeedback training control orientation moved towards a more internal locus of control. Also, depression scores were significantly reduced six months after training. Results show that in patients with refractory epilepsy depression is highly correlated with locus of control, in a way that external control orientation relates to high depression scores. Biofeedback is able to improve internal control orientation through personal success mediation.

Chronic idiopathic constipation: a psychological enquiry.

Intractable idiopathic constipation in women is often associated with psychosocial problems. To determine the past and current psychological factors associated with slow and normal transit constipation. Twenty-eight consecutive patients referred for biofeedback treatment were interviewed before the procedure. All were women. Transit studies revealed that 12 had slow transit constipation (STC) and 16 had normal transit constipation (NTC). Patients were assessed for evidence of previous and current psychiatric diagnoses using a standardized diagnostic interview schedule. A full family and social history was noted. Self-rating scales were used to measure psychological distress, abnormal attitudes to eating and current psychosocial functioning. The mean age of the 28 patients was 38.2 years (SD = 10.8) with a mean duration of symptoms of 17.5 years (SD = 16.9). Seventeen (61%) had a current psychiatric disorder and 18 (64%) a previous episode of psychiatric illness. The mean age of the 16 NTC patients was 38.4 years (SD = 10.1) with a mean duration of symptoms of 12.4 years (SD = 15.9). By contrast, the 12 STC patients had a much longer mean duration of constipation (24.3 years; SD = 16.4), a mean age of 37.9 years (SD = 12.1), with half having an onset in childhood. The STC patients reported more psychosocial distress on the rating scales than those with NTC, and only one did not experience some form of adverse life event or gynaecological procedure in the 6 months before the onset of constipation. Eleven (39%) of the 28 women had had a hysterectomy at a mean age of 36 years, but only four (14%) reported a history of sexual abuse. Of the nine (32%) patients who reported markedly distorted attitudes to food, six had NTC and three had STC. Of consecutive patients undergoing psychological assessment for intractable constipation, three fifths had evidence of current, and two thirds a previous, affective disorder. One third reported distorted attitudes to food. Although STC is a chronic disorder accompanied by high rates of psychological distress, it does not appear to be associated with gross functional impairment. We suggest that patients who present to surgical departments with chronic intractable constipation should routinely have a psychological assessment.

Biofeedback Using Telemedicine: Clinical Applications and Case Illustrations

Telecommunications technology is dramatically changing our world, allowing healthcare professionals to offer medical healthcare, in the form of consultation, assessment, and treatment, through the use of new communications media. In behavioral medicine, advances in telecommunications have brought about new ways of offering services by expanding healthcare to patients located all over the world and simultaneously reducing costs and improving outcome efficacy. This article describes the use of biofeedback to treat various pain and psychophysiological disorders through telemedicine technology. The authors provide a description of “off-the-shelf,” low-cost, and low-bandwidth telemedicine equipment used to deliver clinical biofeedback treatment when the patient and provider are in two different locations. In addition, the authors discuss practical issues of behavioral telehealth.

Efficacy of electromyographic treatment is supported for temporomandibular disorders

Objective To determine the efficacy of electromyographic (EMG) biofeedback-based treatments and to estimate the size of treatment effect. Data sources Medline (1966–1995), Psychlit (1990–1997), review articles and the authors' files. Study selection Thirteen studies were identified, six of which were controlled trials, four were comparative trials and three were uncontrolled trials. Results Data from 12 studies contributed to a meta-analysis that compared the size of pre- and post-treatment effect for EMG biofeedback with the size of effect for control conditions. Mean effect sizes for both reported pain and clinical examination outcomes were substantially larger for biofeedback treatments than for control conditions. In addition, 69% of patients who received EMG biofeedback treatments were rated as symptom-free or significantly improved, compared with only 35% of patients who were treated with a variety of placebo interventions only. Conclusion Although limited in extent, the available data support the efficacy of EMG biofeedback treatments for temporomandibular disorders (TMD).

Biofeedback-Therapie bei somatoformen Störungen

Biofeedback in the Treatment of Somatoform Disorders Using a controlled clinical trial we evaluated the effect of a 6-session biofeedback treatment for somatoform disorders. The intervention included the demonstration of psychophysiological mechanisms to change patients’ catastrophizing cognitions of bodily symptoms. In addition, the control of physiological processes by biofeedback should enhance self-control strategies in the management of symptoms. The patients of the comparison group received a relaxation-based treatment. In total, 50 patients with somatization syndrome (at least 8 somatoform symptoms) were randomized to the 2 treatment groups. The biofeedback group showed a reduction of catastrophizing cognitions (assessed by the questionaire ‘body and health’), whereas patients of the control group did not. All patients evaluated each therapy session separately. Patients of the biofeedback group rated ‘confidence and credibility’ as well as ‘perceived success and coping strategies’ better than patients of the control group. They did not differ in the ratings of ‘quality of therapeutical relation’.

BIOFEEDBACK TRAINING FOR DETRUSOR OVERACTIVITY IN CHILDREN

We evaluated biofeedback training for incontinence due to detrusor overactivity in children. Included in our study were 22 boys and 17 girls with a mean age of 11.2 years. We noted nighttime incontinence in 3 patients, nighttime incontinence and daytime urinary symptoms in 26, and daytime incontinence in 10. All patients had detrusor overactivity and incontinence refractory to conventional treatment, including bladder training, tricyclic antidepressants, anticholinergics, desmopressin and/or conditioning therapy. Urodynamic study was performed using an 8Fr double lumen transurethral catheter for cystometry, a double balloon transrectal catheter for rectal pressure and external anal sphincter pressure measurement, and surface electrodes for sphincter electromyography. During biofeedback training patients were instructed to contract the anal sphincter without raising abdominal pressure to inhibit overactive bladder contractions. Biofeedback training was repeated monthly until cystometry revealed a stable bladder or lower urinary tract symptoms improved considerably. Four patients were lost to followup. Of the remaining 35 children urinary symptoms were cured in 23 and improved in 4. Urodynamic studies after 6 months of biofeedback training in 33 cases showed that bladder overactivity disappeared in 10 and improved in 18. Bladder capacity at the initial desire to void and maximum cystometric capacity increased significantly (p = 0.0115 and <0.0001, respectively). Detrusor-sphincter dyssynergia in 2 patients before biofeedback training resolved in each after therapy. Biofeedback training for detrusor overactivity is effective even in pediatric cases refractory to conventional treatment.

Review of the treatment literature for encopresis, functional constipation, and stool-toileting refusal.

This review summarizes the literature on randomized, controlled, published studies involving medical, behavioral, psychological, and biofeedback treatments for encopresis/functional constipation and stool-toileting refusal in preschool-age and school-age children. Nine such studies were located in the literature involving school-age children. No randomized, controlled treatment studies involving preschool-age children have been published. This review revealed no evidence to support the routine use of psychotherapy or anal sphincter biofeedback in the treatment of pediatric fecal elimination dysfunctions, beyond those benefits derived from a comprehensive medical-behavioral intervention. Further, this review indicated that paradoxical constriction of the External Anal Sphincter does not influence the treatment outcome of either biofeedback or medical-behavioral interventions. There are remarkably few controlled treatment outcome studies in this most important clinical area. More research is needed that employs standard treatment outcome variables.

A Self-directed home biofeedback system for women with symptoms of stress, urge, and mixed incontinence

Purpose: To evaluate a self-directed home biofeedback treatment system in a group of community dwelling, otherwise healthy women with symptoms of stress, urge, and mixed urinary incontinence (UI). Setting and subjects: Fifty-five women, aged 25 to 81 years, participated in the study. Methods: Initial evaluation included a self-reported continence assessment, a 24-hour bladder and fluid habits diary, severity indices for stress and urge UI, and assessment of pelvic floor strength using a pneumatic biofeedback device. Subjects completed a 16-week self-directed program. Assessment and severity index data were self-reported using a continence assessment form, a 24-hour bladder habit and fluid form, and stress and urge incontinence severity indices. Strength level of the trainer, number of digital bands lit on the screen during contraction, number of sessions, and program (starter, intermediate, advanced, or maintenance) were recorded on data sheets. Instruments: The treatment system includes an 8-minute educational and motivational video; a journal for education, instructions, and daily documentation forms; and a home biofeedback trainer with pneumatic vaginal sensors that displays the strength of pelvic muscle contraction. Results: Forty-four women completed the 16-week program. At the end of treatment, 19 (43%) were dry and 16 (36%) reported 50% or more improvement in number of leaks per day, number of voids per day, or both. Women with stress leakage experienced a significant reduction in the number of incontinent episodes per day and the mean severity index of incontinence (P < .001). Participants with urge UI experienced a significant reduction in the mean number of voids per day and mean severity index for UI (P < .001). Younger subjects were more likely to improve when compared with older participants, but no significant differences were found when comparing women who take estrogen with those who do not take estrogen or when comparing those with a history of bladder surgery with those who had no previous surgery. Conclusions: These data suggest that self-selected healthy women with symptoms of urge, stress, and mixed incontinence can improve their symptoms and lower their severity index with a minimal intervention, comprehensive, self-directed home biofeedback continence system. (J WOCN 2000;27:240–6)