The S100A1 protein is ubiquitous in the human body and is particularly localized to the heart and brain tissue, within which it may influence the onset of debilitating cardiomyopathy or Alzheimer's disease. S100A1 is a homodimer that binds four calcium ions to drive a conformational change, whereby two helices separate to expose target protein binding sites. However, the physiochemical drivers of this conformational transition between the apo (no bound ions) to the holo (bound ions) states remain unclear. To understand the atomistic basis of conformational changes in S100A1, we performed nanosecond-scale molecular dynamics simulations (MD) of the apo and holo states in explicit solvent. These MD studies reveal a variety of conformational trends including helical orientations, hydrogen bond contacts, and backbone fluctuations of the calcium binding regions. In response to previous studies demonstrating that the addition of polar functional groups to cysteine residue 85 (Cys85) increases the calcium ions’ binding affinity, we furthermore examined the influence of glutamic acid and glutamine mutations at site 85 (Cys85Glu/Cys85Gln) on the aforementioned conformational behavior. We finally relate structural differences between the apo and holo states for the wild-type and Cys85 mutant cases to alterations on S100A1's experimentally observed alterations in calcium handling. We speculate that similar trends may emerge in similar calcium-binding proteins.