Coal could be called energy’s comeback kid: sometimes forgotten, perhaps underappreciated, but always available for one more shot at the big time. It is one of humankind’s original sources of energy, and is used worldwide for cooking, heating, forging steel, and making electricity. In the United States, coal’s role today is limited almost exclusively to electricity generation; for the last decade or so, even that use has stagnated. For years new power facilities that relied on coal were spurned in favor of natural gas, as American electric companies were wooed by the cleaner-burning fossil fuel and its easier-to-site and cheaper-to-build power plants. Still, because so many coal-fired plants were built before the natural gas craze, coal accounts for over 50% of our annual electric generation. And now many energy experts say coal is poised to once again play a prominent role in the United States. Coal does have an appeal. For one thing, there’s plenty of it. It’s located here in the United States, a comfort to those worried about the political and security hazards of overdependence on imported energy. It’s cheap. And its price is stable, at least compared to natural gas. But coal can be ugly, too. If left unchecked with inadequate emissions control, it can emit ash (which has been linked to human cancers and genotoxic effects in some animal studies), sulfur dioxide (which contributes to acid rain), carbon dioxide (CO2; the chief culprit behind global warming), nitrogen oxides (NOx; which can produce smog and low-lying ozone), and mercury (linked to disorders in the kidneys and the nervous, digestive, and respiratory systems). Mining coal can also be a messy business, carving scars into the Earth, releasing clouds of dust, leaving behind sources of acidic water that can persist decades after a mine closes, and requiring dams—“impoundments” in industry lingo—that sometimes break and ravage miles of waterways. In coming years, however, what’s right about coal will almost certainly overpower what’s wrong, says Richard Gendreau, a senior market consultant for R.W. Beck, a Framingham, Massachusetts, management consulting and engineering company. And what’s wrong, he says, will be made better by new technologies and more vigorous application of existing technologies. “The ultimate driver on all of this,” he says, “is that ninety-five percent of our fossil energy reserves—the amount of fossil energy that we have within our boundaries that we can rely on for energy and economic security, as well as national security—is coal.”
Read full abstract