Biallelic Loss Of Function Variants Research Articles

Biallelic variants in CCN2 underlie an autosomal recessive kyphomelic dysplasia.

Kyphomelic dysplasia is a rare heterogenous group of skeletal dysplasia, characterized by bowing of the limbs, severely affecting femora with distinct facial features. Despite its first description nearly four decades ago, the precise molecular basis of this condition remained elusive until the recent discovery of de novo variants in the KIF5B-related kyphomelic dysplasia. We ascertained two unrelated consanguineous families with kyphomelic dysplasia. They had six affected offsprings and we performed a detailed clinical evaluation, skeletal survey, and exome sequencing in three probands. All the probands had short stature, cleft palate, and micro-retrognathia. Radiographs revealed kyphomelic femora, bowing of long bones, radial head dislocations and mild platyspondyly. We noted two novel homozygous variants in CCN2 as possible candidates that segregated with the phenotype in the families: a missense variant c.443G>A; p.(Cys148Tyr) in exon 3 and a frameshift variant, c.779_786del; p.(Pro260LeufsTer7) in exon 5. CCN2 is crucial for proliferation and differentiation of chondrocytes. Earlier studies have shown that Ccn2-deficient mice exhibit twisted limbs, short and kinked sterna, broad vertebrae, domed cranial vault, shorter mandibles, and cleft palate. We studied the impact of CCN2 knockout in zebrafish models via CRISPR-Cas9 gene editing. F0 knockouts of ccn2a in zebrafish showed altered body curvature, impaired cartilage formation in craniofacial region and either bent or missing tails. Our observations in humans and zebrafish combined with previously described skeletal phenotype of Ccn2 knock out mice, confirm that biallelic loss of function variants in CCN2 result in an autosomal recessive kyphomelic dysplasia.

Novel homozygous ESAM variants in two families with perinatal strokes showing variable neuroradiologic and clinical findings.

Biallelic loss of function variants in ESAM (endothelial cell adhesion molecule) have recently been reported in 14 individuals (9 families) presenting with prenatal intracranial hemorrhage. Here, we describe four patients from two unrelated families in whom three of them presented with variable onset encephalopathy and seizures while one only displayed profound delay without seizures. Brain MRI showed variable onset intracranial hemorrhage that evolved to hydrocephalus in 3 patients, whereas hemosiderin deposits, white matter volume loss, and porencephalic cysts were noted in one patient. Unlike the majority of described cases, the youngest brother of the first family did not show microcephaly and failure to thrive. Exome sequencing identified two novel homozygous ESAM variants. A splice variant (c.731-2A>G) was identified in one family which was confirmed by investigating the patient's mRNA to result in exon skipping and early protein truncation. In addition, a missense variant (c.561G>C; p.Trp187Cys) was identified in the other family, which is the first disease causing missense variant to be described in patients with ESAM deficient phenotype. In addition, a maternally inherited pathogenic MC4R variant (c.811T>C; p.Cys271 Arg) was also identified in the youngest brother of the first family. Variants in the MC4R gene are associated with a non-syndromic form of obesity that could explain the unusual macrocephaly and obesity. Our work establishes ESAM as a tight junction gene that can present with variable neuroradiological and clinical phenotypes when mutated. Moreover, it refines the phenotype of this ultrarare syndrome and extends the number and type of variants described to date.

SCYL2-related autosomal recessive neurodevelopmental disorders: Arthrogryposis multiplex congenita-4 and beyond?

SCY1-like protein 2 (SCYL2) is a member of the SCY1-like pseudokinase family which regulates secretory protein trafficking. It plays a crucial role in the nervous system by suppressing excitotoxicity in the developing brain. Scyl2 knockout mice have excess prenatal mortality and survivors show severe neurological dysfunction. Bi-allelic loss-of-function (LOF) variants in SCYL2 were recently associated with arthrogryposis multiplex congenita-4 (AMC4) following the report of 6 individuals from two consanguineous unrelated families. The AMC4 phenotype described included severe arthrogryposis, corpus callosum agenesis, epilepsy and frequently, early death. We describe here two additional similarly affected individuals with AMC4, including one diagnosed in the prenatal period, with bi-allelic LOF variants in SCYL2, and two individuals homozygous for missense variants in the protein kinase domain of SCYL2 and presenting with developmental delay only. Our study confirms the association of SCYL2 with AMC4 and suggests a milder phenotype can occur, extending the phenotypic spectrum of autosomal recessive SCYL2-related disorders.

Biallelic Loss of Function Variants in SENP7 Cause Immunodeficiency with Neurologic and Muscular Phenotypes

To evaluate a novel candidate disease gene, we engaged international collaborators and identified rare, biallelic, specifically homozygous, loss of function variants in SENP7 in four children from three unrelated families presenting with neurodevelopmental abnormalities, dysmorphism, and immunodeficiency. Their clinical presentations were characterized by hypogammaglobulinemia, intermittent neutropenia, and ultimately death in infancy for all four patients. SENP7 is a sentrin-specific protease involved in posttranslational modification of proteins essential for cell regulation, via a process referred to as deSUMOylation. We propose that deficiency of deSUMOylation may represent a novel mechanism of primary immunodeficiency.

Defects in integrin complex formation promote CHKB-mediated muscular dystrophy.

Phosphatidylcholine (PC) is the major membrane phospholipid in most eukaryotic cells. Bi-allelic loss of function variants in CHKB, encoding the first step in the synthesis of PC, is the cause of a rostrocaudal muscular dystrophy in both humans and mice. Loss of sarcolemma integrity is a hallmark of muscular dystrophies; however, how this occurs in the absence of choline kinase function is not known. We determine that in Chkb -/- mice there is a failure of the α7β1 integrin complex that is specific to affected muscle. We observed that in Chkb -/- hindlimb muscles there is a decrease in sarcolemma association/abundance of the PI(4,5)P2 binding integrin complex proteins vinculin, and α-actinin, and a decrease in actin association with the sarcolemma. In cells, pharmacological inhibition of choline kinase activity results in internalization of a fluorescent PI(4,5)P2 reporter from discrete plasma membrane clusters at the cell surface membrane to cytosol, this corresponds with a decreased vinculin localization at plasma membrane focal adhesions that was rescued by overexpression of CHKB.

Biallelic loss of function variants in FUZ result in an orofaciodigital syndrome

Orofaciodigital syndrome is a distinctive subtype of skeletal ciliopathies. Disease-causing variants in the genes encoding the CPLANE complex result in a wide variety of skeletal dysplasia with disturbed ciliary functions. The phenotypic spectrum includes orofaciodigital syndrome and short rib polydactyly syndrome. FUZ, as a part of the CPLANE complex, is involved in intraflagellar vesicular trafficking within primary cilia. Previously, the variants, c.98_111+9del and c.851G>T in FUZ were identified in two individuals with a skeletal ciliopathy, manifesting digital anomalies (polydactyly, syndactyly), orofacial cleft, short ribs and cardiac defects. Here, we present two novel variants, c.601G>A and c.625_636del in biallelic state, in two additional subjects exhibiting phenotypic overlap with the previously reported cases. Our findings underscore the association between biallelic loss of function variants in FUZ and skeletal ciliopathy akin to orofaciodigital syndrome.

The severity of MUSK pathogenic variants is predicted by the protein domain they disrupt

Biallelic loss of function variants in the MUSK gene result in two allelic disorders: 1) congenital myasthenic syndrome (CMS; OMIM 616325), a neuromuscular disorder which has a range of severity from severe neonatal-onset weakness to mild adult-onset weakness and 2) fetal akinesia deformation sequence (FADS; OMIM 208150), a form of pregnancy loss characterized by severe muscle weakness in the fetus. The MUSK gene codes for muscle specific kinase (MuSK), a receptor tyrosine kinase involved in the development of the neuromuscular junction. Here we report a case of neonatal-onset MUSK-related CMS in a patient harboring compound heterozygous deletions in the MUSK gene ,including: 1)a deletion of exons 2-3, leading to an in-frame MuSK protein lacking the Ig1 domain and 2) a deletion of exons 7-11 leading to an out-of-frame truncated MuSK protein. Individual domains of the MuSK protein have been elucidated structurally; however a complete MuSK structure generated by machine learning algorithms has clear inaccuracies. We modify a predicted AlphaFold structure and integrate previously reported domain-specific structural data to suggest a MuSK protein that dimerizes in two locations (Ig1 and the transmembrane domain). We analyze known pathogenic variants in MUSK to discover domain-specific genotype-phenotype correlations; variants that lead to a loss of protein expression, disruption of the Ig1 domain, or Dok-7 binding are associated with the most severe phenotypes. A conceptual model is provided to explain the severe phenotypes seen in Ig1 variants and the poor response of our patient to pyridostigmine.

Biallelic Loss of Function Variants in Myocardial Zonula Adherens Protein Gene (MYZAP) Cause a Severe Recessive Form of Dilated Cardiomyopathy.

Biallelic Loss of Function Variants in Myocardial Zonula Adherens Protein Gene (MYZAP) Cause a Severe Recessive Form of Dilated Cardiomyopathy.

The first case of intellectual disability caused by novel compound heterozygosity for NUDT2 variants

NUDT2 is an enzyme important for maintaining the intracellular level of the diadenosine tetraphosphate (Ap4A). Bi-allelic loss of function variants in NUDT2 has recently been reported as a rare cause of intellectual disability (ID). Herein, we describe a Chinese girl with ID, attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), and motor delays with abnormal walking posture and difficulty climbing stairs, who bears compound heterozygous variants c.34 C > T (p.R12*) and c.194T > G (p.I65R) in NUDT2. Homozygous variants c.34 C > T (p.R12*) or c.186del (p.A63Qfs*3) in NUDT2 were previously reported to cause ID. This is the first patient with ID due to compound heterozygous variants in NUDT2 and p.I65R is a novel missense variant. This study enriched the genotype and phenotype of NUDT2-related ID and supported the critical developmental involvement of NUDT2.

Pathological mandibular fracture complicated by osteonecrosis in an adult patient with pycnodysostosis: clinical report and review of the literature

Pycnodysostosis is an ultra-rare osteosclerotic skeletal disorder characterized by short stature, susceptibly to fractures, acroosteolysis of the distal phalanges, and craniofacial features (frontal bossing, prominent nose, obtuse mandibular angle, micrognathia). Dental abnormalities (delayed eruption of teeth, hypodontia, malocclusion, dental crowding, persistence of deciduous teeth, enamel hypoplasia, and increased caries) are also frequent; due to bone metabolism alteration, the patients have an increased risk for jaw osteomyelitis, especially after tooth extraction or mandible fracture. Other complications are obstructive sleep apnea, endocrine alterations and cytopenia. Pycnodysostosis is caused by biallelic loss of function variants in CTSK gene, coding the lysosomal protease cathepsin K. CTSK is involved in the degradation of bone matrix proteins, such as type I and type II collagen. In pycnodysostosis, this degradation is decreased, leading to increased bone density and bone fragility with pathological fractures and poor healing.We present a clinical report of a female adult patient with typical pycnodysostosis phenotype. At the age of 52 years, she had a pathological spontaneous fracture of the right mandible complicated by osteonecrosis, treated with load bearing osteosynthesis. The direct sequencing of CTSK gene revealed the presence of the pathogenic homozygous variant c.746T>A, (p.Ile249Asn), that confirmed the diagnosis of pycnodysostosis.We also review the literature case series published to date, that suggest to always consider the diagnosis of pycnodysostosis in case of osteosclerosis, even in the absence of brachydactyly or short stature.This report details the natural history of the disease in this patient, from childhood to adulthood, and highlights the importance of a quality of life assessment. In addition, we describe a case of mandibular osteonecrosis and spontaneous fracture in pycnodysostosis, drawing attention on the maxillofacial complications in these patients and on the importance of a personalized follow-up.

Biallelic variants in the synaptic vesicle glycoprotein 2 A are associated with epileptic encephalopathy.

Synaptic Vesicle Glycoprotein 2 A (SV2A) is a membrane protein of synaptic vesicles and the binding site of antiepileptic drug levetiracetam. Biallelic Arg383Gln is reported in a family with intractable epilepsy earlier. Here, we report on the second family with early onset drug resistant epilepsy. We identified homozygous Arg289Ter variant by exome sequencing that segregated with the phenotype in the family. The affected children in these two families are normal at birth and developed recurrent seizures beginning in the second month of life and developed secondary failure of growth and development. Knock out mice models earlier had replicated the human phenotype observed in these two families. These findings support that biallelic loss of function variants in SV2A result in early onset intractable epilepsy in humans.

Long-term follow-up of severe autosomal recessive SP7-related bone disorder

The SP7 gene encodes a zinc finger transcription factor (Osterix), which is a member of the Sp subfamily of sequence-specific DNA-binding proteins, playing an important role in osteoblast differentiation and maturation. SP7 pathogenic variants have been described in association with different allelic disorders. Monoallelic or biallelic SP7 variants cause Osteogenesis imperfecta type XII (OI12), a very rare condition characterized by recurrent fractures, skeletal deformities, undertubulation of long bones, hearing loss, no dentinogenesis imperfecta, and white sclerae. Monoallelic or biallelic SP7 variants may also cause sclerotic skeletal dysplasias (SSD), partially overlapping with Juvenile Paget's disease and craniodiaphyseal dysplasia, characterized by skull hyperostosis, long bones sclerosis, large ribs and clavicles, and possible recurrent fractures. Here, we report the long-term follow-up of an 85-year-old woman presenting with a complex bone disorder including features of either OI12 (bone fragility with multiple fractures, severe deformities and short stature) or SSD (striking skull hyperostosis with optic atrophy, very large ribs and clavicles and long bones sclerosis). Exome sequencing showed previously undescribed biallelic loss of function variants in the SP7 gene: NM_001173467.2(SP7): c.359_362del, p.(Asp120Valfs*11); NM_001173467.2(SP7): c.1163_1174delinsT, p.(Pro388Leufs*33). RT-qPCR confirmed a severely reduced SP7 transcription compared to controls.Our report provides new insights into the clinical and molecular features and long-term outcome of SP7-related bone disorders (SP7-BD), suggesting a continuum phenotypic spectrum characterized by bone fragility, undertubulation of long bones, scoliosis, and very heterogeneous bone mineral density ranging from osteoporosis to osteosclerosis.

Indian patients with CHST3-related chondrodysplasia with congenital joint dislocations.

CHST3-related chondrodysplasia with congenital joint dislocations (CDCJD, #MIM 143095), is a rare genetic skeletal disorder caused by biallelic loss of function variants in CHST3. CHST3 is critical for the sulfation of chondroitin sulfate. This study delineates the clinical presentation of nine individuals featuring the key symptoms of CDCJD; congenital joint (knee and elbow) dislocations, short trunk short stature progressive vertebral anomalies, and metacarpal shortening. Additional manifestations include irregular distal femoral epiphysis, supernumerary carpal ossification centers, bifid humerus, club foot, and cardiac abnormalities. Sanger sequencing was carried out to investigate molecular etiology in eight patients and exome sequencing in one. Genetic testing revealed five homozygous variants in CHST3 (four were novel and one was previously reported). All these variants are located on sulfotransferase domain of CHST3 protein and were classified as pathogenic/ likely pathogenic. We thus report on nine individuals with CHST3-related chondrodysplasia with congenital joint dislocations from India and suggest monitoring the health of cardiac valves in this condition.

Refining the phenotypic spectrum of CCDC88A-related PEHO-like syndrome.

Progressive encephalopathy with edema, hypsarrhythmia, and optic atrophy (PEHO) and PEHO-like syndromes are very rare infantile disorders characterized by profound intellectual disability, hypotonia, convulsions, optic, and progressive brain atrophy. Many causative genes for PEHO and PEHO-like syndromes have been identified including CCDC88A. So far, only five patients from two unrelated families with biallelic CCDC88A variants have been reported in the literature. Herein, we describe a new family from Egypt with a lethal epileptic encephalopathy. Our patient was the youngest child born to a highly consanguineous couple and had a family history of five deceased sibs with the same condition. She presented with postnatal microcephaly, poor visual responsiveness, and epilepsy. Her brain MRI showed abnormal cortical gyration with failure of opercularization of the insula, hypogenesis of corpus callosum, colpocephaly, reduced white matter, hypoplastic vermis, and brain stem. Whole exome sequencing identified a new homozygous frameshift variant in CCDC88A gene (c.1795_1798delACAA, p.Thr599ValfsTer4). Our study presents the third reported family with this extremely rare disorder. We also reviewed all described cases to better refine the phenotypic spectrum associated with biallelic loss of function variants in the CCDC88A gene.

Novel association of Dandy-Walker malformation with CAPN15 variants expands the phenotype of oculogastrointestinal neurodevelopmental syndrome.

Oculogastrointestinal neurodevelopmental syndrome has been described in seven previously published individuals who harbor biallelic pathogenic variants in the CAPN15 gene. Biallelic missense variants have been reported to demonstrate a phenotype of eye abnormalities and developmental delay, while biallelic loss of function variants exhibit phenotypes including microcephaly and craniofacial abnormalities, cardiac and genitourinary malformations, and abnormal neurologic activity. We report six individuals from three unrelated families harboring biallelic deleterious variants in CAPN15 with phenotypes overlapping those previously described for this disorder. Of the individuals affected, four demonstrate radiographic evidence of the classical triad of Dandy-Walker malformation including hypoplastic vermis, fourth ventricle enlargement, and torcular elevation. Cerebellar anomalies have not been previously reported in association with CAPN15-related disease. Here, we present three unrelated families with findings consistent with oculogastrointestinal neurodevelopmental syndrome and cerebellar pathology including Dandy-Walker malformation. To corroborate these novel clinical findings, we present supporting data from the mouse model suggesting an important role for this protein in normal cerebellar development. Our findings add six molecularly confirmed cases to the literature and additionally establish a new association of Dandy-Walker malformation with biallelic CAPN15 variants, thereby expanding the neurologic spectrum among patients affected by CAPN15-related disease.

DST variants are responsible for neurogenic arthrogryposis multiplex congenita enlarging the spectrum of type VI hereditary sensory autonomic neuropathy.

Arthrogryposis multiplex congenita (AMC) is a developmental condition characterized by multiple joint contractures resulting from reduced or absent fetal movements. Through whole-exome sequencing combined with arrayCGH from DNA of a fetus presenting with early onset AMC, we identified biallelic loss of function variants in Dystonin (DST): a stop gain variant (NM_001144769.5:c.12208G > T:p.(Glu4070Ter)) on the neuronal isoform and a 175 kb microdeletion including exons 25-96 of this isoform on the other allele [NC_000006.11:g.(56212278_56323554)_(56499398_56507586)del]. Transmission electron microscopy of the sciatic nerve revealed abnormal morphology of the peripheral nerve with severe hypomyelination associated with dramatic reduction of fiber density which highlights the critical role of DST in peripheral nerve axonogenesis during development in human. Variants in the neuronal isoforms of DST cause hereditary sensory and autonomic neuropathy which has been reported in several unrelated families with highly variable age of onset from fetal to adult onset. Our data enlarge the disease mechanisms of neurogenic AMC.

Five siblings expand the spectrum of GPC6-related skeletal dysplasia.

Skeletal dysplasias broadly include disorders of cartilage or bone. Omodysplasia-1 is a type of skeletal dysplasia caused by biallelic loss of function variants in the GPC6 gene. GPC6 codes for the protein glypican 6 (GPC6) (OMIM *604404), which stimulates bone growth. We report a family in which five out of nine children were presented with a skeletal dysplasia characterized phenotypically by mild short stature and rhizomelia. All affected individuals were found to have homozygous missense variants in GPC6: c.511 C>T (p.Arg171Trp). Radiograph findings included rhizomelic foreshortening of all four extremities, coxa breva, and ulna minus deformity. Using a Hedgehog (Hh) reporter assay, we demonstrate that the variant found in this family results in significantly reduced stimulation of Hh activity when compared to the wild-type GPC6 protein, however protein function is still present. Thus, the milder phenotype seen in the family presented is hypothesized due to decreased GPC6 protein activity versus complete loss of function as seen in omodysplasia-1. Given the unique phenotype and molecular mechanism, we propose that this family's findings widen the phenotypic spectrum of GPC6-related skeletal dysplasias.

Biallelic variants in NOS3 and GUCY1A3, the two major genes of the nitric oxide pathway, cause moyamoya cerebral angiopathy

BackgroundMoyamoya angiopathy (MMA) is a rare cerebrovascular condition leading to stroke. Mutations in 15 genes have been identified in Mendelian forms of MMA, but they explain only a very small proportion of cases. Our aim was to investigate the genetic basis of MMA in consanguineous patients having unaffected parents in order to identify genes involved in autosomal recessive MMA.MethodsExome sequencing (ES) was performed in 6 consecutive consanguineous probands having MMA of unknown etiology. Functional consequences of variants were assessed using western blot and protein 3D structure analyses.ResultsCausative homozygous variants of NOS3, the gene encoding the endothelial nitric oxide synthase (eNOS), and GUCY1A3, the gene encoding the alpha1 subunit of the soluble guanylate cyclase (sGC) which is the major nitric oxide (NO) receptor in the vascular wall, were identified in 3 of the 6 probands. One NOS3 variant (c.1502 + 1G > C) involves a splice donor site causing a premature termination codon and leads to a total lack of eNOS in endothelial progenitor cells of the affected proband. The other NOS3 variant (c.1942 T > C) is a missense variant located into the flavodoxine reductase domain; it is predicted to be destabilizing and shown to be associated with a reduction of eNOS expression. The GUCY1A3 missense variant (c.1778G > A), located in the catalytic domain of the sGC, is predicted to disrupt the tridimensional structure of this domain and to lead to a loss of function of the enzyme. Both NOS3 mutated probands suffered from an infant-onset and severe MMA associated with posterior cerebral artery steno-occlusive lesions. The GUCY1A3 mutated proband presented an adult-onset MMA associated with an early-onset arterial hypertension and a stenosis of the superior mesenteric artery. None of the 3 probands had achalasia.ConclusionsWe show for the first time that biallelic loss of function variants in NOS3 is responsible for MMA and that mutations in NOS3 and GUCY1A3 are causing fifty per cent of MMA in consanguineous patients. These data pinpoint the essential role of the NO pathway in MMA pathophysiology.

Understanding complex begins with knowing the simple

Diagnosing rare genetic disorders is clinically challenging. Patients undergo extensive investigations, including multiple genetic/genomic tests. Despite being seen by several specialists, they often remain without a genetic diagnosis. A 4-year-old female with consanguineous parents presents with skeletal abnormalities, dysmorphism, global developmental delay, slow growth, and recurrent severe systemic infections. Initial next generation sequencing based primary immunodeficiency gene panel and SNP microarray detected no causative pathogenic variants. The final diagnosis was possible only following a special cytogenetic test, C-banded karyotype, which revealed heterochromatin repulsion and premature centromere separation in all metaphases, suggestive of Roberts syndrome (RS). RS/ESCO2-spectrum disorder is a rare autosomal recessive disorder caused by biallelic loss of function variants in the ESCO2 gene, with only 150 cases reported to date. Microarray analysis also showed long contiguous stretches of homozygosity at the 8p21 locus, which encompasses the ESCO2 gene. ESCO2 gene sequencing was recommended for molecular confirmation of the diagnosis. This case illustrates the importance of appropriate selection of genomic tests and highlights the critical role of karyotyping (including the use of specialized stains) in the diagnosis of some rare genetic disorders.

Mosaic variegated aneuploidy syndrome 2 with biallelic novel CEP57 splice site variation in Indian siblings: Expanding the clinical and molecular spectrum.

Mosaic variegated aneuploidy syndrome 2 (MVA2) (MIM# 614114) is a rare autosomal recessive condition caused by biallelic loss of function variants in the CEP57 gene. MVA2 is characterized by a variable phenotype ranging from poor growth to facial dysmorphism, short stature and congenital heart defects. Only 11 families and 5 pathogenic variants of MVA2 have been described so far. Intragenic duplication of 11 nucleotides (c.915_925dup11) in homozygous or compound heterozygous state is the commonest genetic aberration (10/13). We describe the first Indian family with two siblings with a novel homozygous splice site variant (c.382+2T>C) in CEP57. Molecular characterization demonstrated skipping of exon 3 due to the variant with protein modeling predicting subsequent complete loss of function. This is the first report of a splice site variation in CEP57 leading to MVA2.