Drain networks are essential for connecting farming landscapes to waterways to help mitigate floods and convey water downstream. Unfortunately, drains also convey nutrients and sediments from surface or tile drain run-off, which can impact critical habitats for benthic macroinvertebrates and fish communities, including many species at risk of extinction. To bridge discussions around drainage and ecological values associated with sustainable management of water resources in drainage systems, we conducted a comprehensive literature synthesis on the ecological impacts of drain management practices (DMPs) and best management practices (BMPs). To inform drain management at a regional scale, we extracted key findings from 111 peer-reviewed studies with similar physical attributes and management contexts representative of southwestern Ontario’s agricultural landscapes. Across studies, impacts of management practices were assessed over relatively short time periods (1 month − 2 years), limiting understanding of the long-term impacts and ecological or management trade-offs. Frequently measured water quality indicators included carbon, nitrogen, and phosphorus concentrations. Fish biodiversity and abundance were the most commonly measured biodiversity indicators. Recent studies suggest that biodiversity in drain systems is highly resilient and consists of common species that can cope with management activities. Despite literature gaps, findings suggest that while both practices maintain critical drain functions, trade-offs between flood mitigation, biodiversity and water quality remain underexplored. BMPs have the potential to offer multiple co-benefits and greater uptake across the region and across agricultural landscapes in Canada yet place-based evidence is lacking. Cross-sector partnerships can help bolster efforts to critically assess and implement local solutions.
Read full abstract