Purpose: EUS/FNA is performed on pancreatic cystic lesions (PCL) when feasible and fluid sent for CEA/amylase. Although the literature has varied CEA cutoff values, many centers use CEA (ng/mL) of <5 for distinguishing non-mucinous cysts from mucinous cysts (MC) and >192 for mucinous cystadenomas (MCA). Amylase of 250 U/L is often used to differentiate pseudocysts (PC) from other cysts. Sensitivities (SN) and specificities (SP) differ between studies. Analyses of PCL in a community/non-academic setting may be an important addition to exiting data. Using our cyst data, our goals were to: (1) analyze the performance of CEA in differentiating MC from non-MC and benign from malignant; (2) test the ability of amylase in differentiating MC from non-MC, benign from malignant, IPMN from MCA, PC from non-PC; (3) calculate SN and SP of commonly used CEA and amylase values. Methods: Retrospective review of PCL which had EUS/FNA for CEA and amylase then confirmation of cyst type via cytology/histopathology. Results: Twenty-three cases met the search criteria between December 2007 and November 2011. Median (IQR, interquartile range) of CEA (ng/mL) in MC and non-MC were 642.50 (68.53-9,278.25) and 10.05 (1.65-22,238), respectively (p=0.19). Median (IQR) of CEA in benign MC and malignant MC were 642.50 (28.38-9,466.75) and 2,283 (284-4,282), respectively (p=1.00). Median (IQR) of amylase (U/L) in MC and non-MC were 283 (131-800) and 800 (411.5-14,579), respectively (p=0.35). Median (IQR) of amylase in benign MC and malignant MC were 541.50 (104.25-800) and 227 (227-227), respectively (p=0.60). Median (IQR) of amylase in IPMN and MCA were 125.50 (24-227) and 800 (207-800), respectively (p=0.11). Median (IQR) of amylase in PC and non-PC were 14,579 (800-28,358) and 314.5 (88.75-800), respectively (p=0.06). None of the differences were statistically significant; small sample size was a limitation. CEA <5 for diagnosis of non-MC had SN of 50% and SP of 94%. CEA >192 for the diagnosis of MCA had SN of 57% (increased to 64% when IPMN included) and SP of 67%. CEA of >800 in distinguishing MCA/MCAC (mucinous cystadenocarcinoma) from SCA (serous cystadenoma)/PC had SN of 46% and SP of 75%. Ability of amylase <250 to distinguish SCA, MCA, and MCAC from PC had SN of 30% and SP of 100%. Amylase in IPMN were low in our data with median (IQR) of 125.5 (24-227), which is contrary to prior reports of much higher IPMN amylase values. Conclusion: In a non-academic setting, commonly used CEA and amylase values for the diagnosis of PCL yielded similar SN and SP (slightly lower in some cases) as those reported in the medical literature. Cyst fluid CEA and amylase analyses pose diagnostic challenges in differentiating PCL. Amylase in IPMNs were lower compared to prior reports.
Read full abstract