Significant R-curve effect is very common in the mode I fracture of composite laminates. Accurate simulation of fracture with R-curve effect is important for damage tolerance design of composite structures. However, traditional numerical methods usually do not consider the R-curve effect. In this work, four methods, including three phenomenological methods and cohesive zone model with multi-linear constitutive relation are presented. The three phenomenological methods are based on bilinear cohesive zone model, virtual crack closure technique and extended finite element method respectively with the consideration of R-curve. It is interesting to know which method is more suitable for modelling delamination growth with significant R-curve effect. To achieve this goal, double cantilever beam specimen is modeled and delamination growth is simulated using above four methods. Comparisons between the numerical results and the experimental results of laminates with different material types and stack sequences are made for these methods. Finally, the accuracy, computational efficiency and parameter acquisition of these methods are discussed with the goal of finding a suitable method for delamination modelling in laminated composites. It is shown that the cohesive zone model with multi-linear constitutive relation shows good accuracy in all studied cases.
Read full abstract