Operando synchrotron radiation-based characterization techniques applied to energy storage materials are becoming a widespread characterization tool as they allow for non-destructive probing of materials with various depth sensitivities through spectroscopy, scattering, and imaging techniques. Moreover, they allow for faster acquisition rates, variable penetration depths, higher spectral or spatial resolution, or access to techniques that are only possible with a continuous tuneable source over a wide photon energy range. Compatibility between the electrochemical cell designs and the experimental setups may force some specific design features and care must be taken to ensure that these do not perturb the electrochemical response of the materials under investigation. The use of operando techniques has intrinsic advantages, as they enable the detection of metastable intermediates, if any, and ensure characterization under real conditions avoiding the risk of ex situ sample evolution during its preparation. However, they do not come with the extent of risks. The interaction between synchrotron radiation and samples, particularly within the intricate milieu of an operational electrochemical cell, can induce unexpected effects in the sample at the measurement spot, thereby jeopardizing the experiment's reliability and biasing data interpretation. While beam-induced effects are well-recognized for their critical impact on characterizing biological samples, macromolecules, or soft matter, they have, until recently, received scant attention within the battery research community, being vaguely referenced and incompletely understood. With the aim of contributing to this ongoing debate, a systematic investigation into these phenomena was carried out conducting a root cause analysis of beam-induced effects during the operando characterization of two commercially employed positive electrode materials: LiNi0.33Mn0.33Co0.33O2 and LiFePO4. The study spans across diverse experimental conditions involving various cell types, absorption and scattering techniques and seeks to correlate beam effects with factors such as radiation energy, photon flux, exposure time, and other parameters associated with radiation dosage. As a conclusion, a set of guidelines and recommendations are provided to evaluate and mitigate beam-induced effects that can affect the outcome of battery operando experiments.
Read full abstract