Faced with three classes of senior English students certain that our upcoming poetry unit would be painful and worthless, I was determined to find an approach that would develop understanding of poetry's rudiments and appreciation of its power. Being seniors, i.e., hard-core adversaries of poetry study, my students were smugly confident that I had nothing new to say that could make poetry worthwhile. So, on the first day, I challenged their favorite excuses or, as I called them, myths regarding the study of poetry. Myth #1: Poetry's themes are the intimate thoughts of the poet. How can I be expected to understand someone else's personal feelings? It didn't take them long to admit that love, jealousy, fear, pain, etc., are universal emotions. My experience may not have taken place in the same location or with the same persons, but, being human, I have or will experience these feelings. Dispel Myth #1. Other typical excuses were contradicted in this first day's discussion, and it was fun to let students challenge their peers' weak arguments until it was generally agreed that their prejudices were unfounded and they would give this one more chance with an open mind. To say, It's boring, is unfair. The student has to be specific about what makes it boring. I was gratefully surprised to find agreement that all song or rock lyrics are not good poetry, but as in all genres, excellence can be found among volumes of mediocrity. I believe it is important to present a wide range of poetry in this unit, from Shakespeare to Bob Dylan. Why not give students at least some works with which they are familiar? I tied up this day's discussion with talk about two other myths; often the students bring these up themselves, but it is important to clarify them before moving on. Myth #2: It is worthless to study poetry themes because most themes have endless levels of meaning. Most poems can mean anything I want them to mean. The theme of nearly all poems can be bounded by reasonable limits, from narrow to broad. Once I have established these limits, I am free to interpret a poem on all plausible levels. This rationale can be applied to all art. Myth #3: It is a waste of time to study the rudiments of poetry. Why not just enjoy it? Just as a basic lesson on the freedoms and restrictions
Read full abstract