In this paper, we investigate the claimed optimality of a new method – Revised Distribution (RDI) Method – for finding optimal solution of balanced and unbalanced transportation models directly and compare the RDI method with other such methods. A large set of problems have been tested by RDI and other methods, and the results were compared with the Modified distribution (MODI) method – an optimal method. We found that the mostly the results of RDI are not optimal. For reference to prove our observations, we have added three example transportation problems here in this work and compared their results with MODI method to show that the RDI method like the direct exponential approach (DEA) method is not optimal method; but it is just an initial basic feasible solution (IBFS) for transportation problems.