The gut microbiota (GM) influences multiple processes during host development and maintenance. To study these events, fecal microbiota transfer (FMT) to germ-free (GF) recipients is often performed. Mouse models of disease are also susceptible to GM-dependent effects, and cryo-repositories often store feces from donated mouse strains. Shipping live mice may affect the GM and result in an inaccurate representation of the baseline GM. We hypothesize that the use of such fecal samples for FMT would transfer shipping-induced changes in the donor GM to GF recipients. To test this, donor mice originating from two suppliers were shipped to the University of Missouri. Fecal samples collected pre- and post-shipping were used to inoculate GF mice. Pre- and post-shipping fecal samples from donors, and fecal and/or cecal contents were collected from recipients at one and two weeks post-FMT. 16S rRNA sequencing revealed supplier-dependent effects of shipping on the donor microbiome. FMT efficiency was independent of shipping timepoint or supplier, resulting in transmission of shipping-induced changes to recipient mice, however the effect of supplier-origin microbiome remained evident. While shipping may cause subtle changes in fecal samples collected for FMT, such effects are inconsistent among supplier-origin GMs and minor in comparison to other biological variables.