Reviewed by: Records Ruin the Landscape: John Cage, the Sixties, and Sound Recording by David Grubbs Sara Haefeli Records Ruin the Landscape: John Cage, the Sixties, and Sound Recording. By David Grubbs. Durham, NC: Duke University Press, 2014. [End Page 170] [xxv, 220 p. ISBN 9780822355762 (hardcover), $84.95; ISBN 9780822355908 (paperback), $23.95.] Illustrations, bibliography, discography, index. David Grubbs prefaces this excellent book with a description of his own relationship to records as a late baby boomer growing up in Louisville, Kentucky—first as an avid consumer of pop music, then as a teenaged editor of punk and post-punk fanzines. This love of records was inspired by the materiality of the medium as well as the multimedia nature of the physical record. There was a joy in being able to return to a record again and again. When he moved to Chicago in 1990, he was confronted with a range of different attitudes toward records, including the claim by experimental musicians that records were antithetical to their art practice. What he valued about his encounters with experimental music and avant-garde jazz was that it was always different and unrepeatable—they were art practices based on the moment and one’s physical presence in the art space. Yet he also loved the culture of the record store and the joy of chance encounters and browsing through the bins. This introductory autobiography may seem self-indulgent, but it is not. Throughout this study we are reminded that Grubbs is not only deeply knowledgeable about these art practices and the time period in question, but that records genuinely captivate him. It is this love that seems to drive the encyclopedic knowledge demonstrated in this book. Part of the brilliance of this book is that it is a joy to read. It is virtually free of social-theory jargon, although the content demonstrates that Grubbs has all the theory firmly in grasp. He moves easily through discussions of the aesthetic theory of Nelson Goodman, Roland Barthes, and Walter Benjamin without veering off into the ether. It is engagingly written, often poetically descriptive, and well-edited. The selected discography and the links to database resources make the book a useful reference resource after a first reading. In short, this is the best kind of study that is clearly motivated by a passion for its subject, and it is executed with aplomb. Grubbs’s project is shaped by the tantalizing paradox that John Cage publicly disparaged records and yet continued to make and sell records. There are a number of famous quotes by Cage that make his disdain for records clear. He told interviewers that he did not own records, that records “destroy one’s need for real music,” and that they “make people think that they’re engaging in a musical activity when they’re actually not” (p. 10). In the collection of interviews published as For the Birds (Boston: M. Boyars, 1981), Daniel Charles said, “Records, according to you, are nothing more than postcards … ” to which Cage replied, “which ruin the landscape” (p. 1). Yet Cage is one of the most widely recorded composers of the twentieth century. Given Cage’s central position in the avant-garde arts of the 1960s, these records were significant and helped to shape how others outside of the immediate circle of the New York School understood his work. Grubbs analyzes how these records continue to shape our understanding of the avantgarde today. Unlike fans in the post-Cage 1960s, we have easy access to this repertoire, as it is increasingly available through archival releases and rereleases, and is often downloadable for free via sites like UbuWeb (http://www.ubuweb.com, accessed 20 March 2015). Another paradoxical aspect of Cage’s antipathy for recordings is that he was a pioneer in the field of electronic music and wrote some of the very first pieces using magnetic tape; he also used recorded sound as source material for live performance. Part of the irony of the title of the book—Records Ruin the Landscape—is that it reminds us of Cage’s series of early experiments in electronic music called Imaginary Landscapes composed between 1939 and 1952. Grubbs...
Read full abstract