Hebrew Studies 32 (1991) 133 Reviews In the abundance ofits book stories, bibliophilic and otherwise, Shira is exquisitely sensitive to the inscription ofobjects in history and history in objects. The dynamics of inscription situate the book in culture, while showing us the roots of culture in a relation to the body. This reinstinctualizing of the book constitutes the novel's "shameful secret," its feminine subtext; through it, culture's dissociation of book from body is undone. (p. 170) Stanley Nash Hebrew Union College - Jewish InSlilUle ofReligion New York. NY 10012 JEREMIAH 2: A COMMENTARY ON THE BOOK OF THE PROPHET JEREMIAH, CHAPTERS 26-52. By William L. Holladay. Henneneia. Pp. xxxi + 543. Minneapolis: Fortress, 1989. Cloth, $44.95. With this volume, Professor Holladay completes his monumental and comprehensive commentary on the book of Jeremiah. With its publication, a full spate of up-to-date English language Jeremiah commentaries becomes nearly complete (we await only W. McKane's second volume in the ICC series), and we mark a major milestone in the contemporary study of Jeremiah. It remains to be seen what new directions will be taken in future Jeremiah studies. (For a broad sUIVey of recent commentaries on Jeremiah, see C. S. Rodd, ExpTim 98 [1987]:171-175.) Synopsis: For those already familiar with Holladay's contributions to Jeremiah studies, and especially the prior volume of his Hermeneia commentary , the second volume, overall, offers no surprises. The extremely helpful introductory essays provide a comprehensive overview and synthetic argument for Holladay's approach to the major interpretive problems. The sustained case for a biographical-historical reading of the Jeremiah tradition is continued with creative independence and vigorous ingenuity on the part of the author. When he is done, Holladay maintains that the bulk of the book can be traced either to the historical prophet or to Baruch, the prophet's scribe and associate. Apart from minor glosses scattered throughout the book, the only secondary passages of major scope consist of the following on p. 24 of the introduction: 5:18; 8:1-3; 9:11-13; 22:8-9; 52:1-34 (exilic period texts); 9:14-15; 31:10-14, 23, 24-25, 26 (end of the sixth century texts); 3:6-11, 16-1800; 17:19-27; 23:7-8,34-40; 30:89 ; 31:29-30, 35-36, 37, 38-40 (fifth century texts). In the course of his textual and structural analysis, I also note the following which are viewed Hebrew Studies 32 (1991) 134 Reviews as additions to Jer 26-52: 30:22-24; 32:2-5, 18-20,28-40; 33:7-10*, 12-26; 39:4-10; 46:25-28; 48:5, 10, 13, 21-24, 26-27, 29-38, 47; 49:6, 9, 12-17, 27, 33, 39; 50:17-18, 30, 39-46; 51:11, 15-19,28,45-48,57. Where dates can be assigned, they range from exilic down to Maccabean periods. Such tantalizing suggestions of on-going exegetical interest in second temple Judaism are left undiscussed in terms of exegetical and theological significance. Nevertheless, this limitation of the primary fonnation of the book to the lifetime of the prophet does not preclude a very complex history of composition (summarized on pp. 15-24). Holladay reconstructs the stages of the book's development in relation to the chronology of Jeremiah's career. The latter is configured to a large degree in relation to a septennial reading of Deuteronomy at the annual festival of booths (the key dates: 615,608,601, 594,587). Each passage and stage of the book's development is assigned a historical setting within this chronological framework. Some of the more surprising and innovative proposals for Jer 26-52 are the following: (1) Oracles against the Nations: a significant core of these oracles are traced back to the prophet. The authentic core of chaps. 46-49 had all been delivered by 594; the beginnings of a short collection were made as a reaction against the Jerusalem conference of Syro-Palestinian states plotting a revolt against Nebuchadnezzar. This shorter collection was subsequently expanded by an authentic core of oracles in chaps. 50-51 directed against Babylon. The historical...
Read full abstract