Lin [1966] recently outlined two mechanisms by which he suggests that it is dynamically possible for the Australasian tektites to have originated from an impact on earth by some gigantic cosmic body. He calculates that the energy of such an event, in order to remove the earth's atmosphere, would excavate a crater over 300 km in diameter. It is the purpose of this critique to indicate, quite apart from pointing out that 300-km craters associated with the possibility of terrestrial tektite origin are undiscovered, that both mechanisms suggested by Lin are contradicted by present aerodynamic and petrographic data on Australasian tektites. Also, we emphasize here a conclusion inherent in Lin's analysis, but not explicitly stated by him: namely, that, in comparison to the magnitude of atmosphere-removing events, such relatively insignificant earth cavities as the Ries and Bosumtwi craters (thought by some, from age considerations, to be sources of tektites) are far too small to be associated energetically with atmosphere removal.
Read full abstract