The evolution of phase behavior and interactions in anionic silica nanoparticles (Ludox HS40), surfactants [non-ionic decaethylene glycol mono-dodecyl ether (C12E10) and anionic sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS)], and nanoparticle–surfactant solutions in the presence of salt (NaCl) has been studied using small-angle neutron scattering and dynamic light scattering. In an anionic silica nanoparticle solution (1 wt. %), the phase behavior is controlled by salt concentrations (0–1 M) through screening electrostatic interactions. In the case of 1 wt. % surfactant solutions, the anionic SDS surfactant micelles show significant growth upon adding salt, whereas non-ionic surfactant C12E10 micelles remain spherical until a high salt concentration (1 M). In the mixed system of HS40–C12E10, a transition from a highly stable transparent phase to a two-phase turbid system is observed with a small amount of salt addition CS* (∼0.06 M). The single transparent phase of this system corresponds to sterically stabilized micelles-decorated nanoparticles. For the turbid phase, the results are understood in terms of depletion attraction induced by non-adsorption of C12E10 micelles, which explains the appearance of turbidity at a much lower concentration of salt. In the mixed system of similarly charged nanoparticles and micelles (HS40-SDS), the phase behavior is governed by no physical interaction between the components, and salt screens the repulsive interaction among nanoparticles. These results are further utilized to tune multicomponent interactions and phase behavior of nanoparticles with a mixed C12E10-SDS surfactant system in the presence of salt. The mixed surfactants provide tuning of nanoparticle–micelle as well as micelle–micelle interactions to dictate the phase behavior of a nanoparticle–surfactant solution. In these systems, the effective potential can be described by double-Yukawa potential taking account of attractive and repulsive parts at low and intermediate salt concentrations (<CS*). At high salt concentrations (>CS*), the aggregation of nanoparticles is characterized by fractal aggregates.