To understand the microperimetry response characteristics of regions with a truly nonresponding location, which will be useful when considering criteria for end-stage atrophic age-related macular degeneration (AMD). A simulation model was developed using data from 128 participants with bilateral large drusen at baseline seen over 36months at 6-month intervals. One hundred thousand pairs of real-world microperimetry testing results were simulated separately with and without one truly nonresponding location, where the sensitivity of one randomly selected location for the former group was derived from the distribution of responses from a truly nonresponding location at the optic nerve head from 60 healthy participants. Only 60% of the simulated test pairs with a truly nonresponding location had ≥1 location that was <0 decibel (dB) on both tests. In contrast, 91% of the simulated test pairs had ≥1 location that was ≤10dB on both tests, and 87% had ≥1 location that was ≤10dB on both tests and <0dB for one of the tests. Of the simulated test pairs without a truly nonresponding location, there were 0.04%, 1.4%, and 0.4% that met these three above criteria, respectively. Regions with a truly nonresponding test location do not almost always show a repeatable absolute scotoma (<0dB), but instead, much more often a deep visual sensitivity defect (≤10dB), with or without having an absolute scotoma on one of the tests. These findings are crucial if functional criteria are to be considered as part of a definition of end-stage atrophic AMD.