The escalation of global plastic production, reaching an annual output of 400 million tons, has significantly intensified concerns regarding plastic waste management. This has been exacerbated by improper recycling and disposal practices, contributing to the impending crisis of plastic pollution. Predictions indicate that by 2025, the environment will bear the burden of over ten billion metric tons of accumulated plastic waste. This situation has led to the concerning release of microplastics and nanoplastics (NPs) into the environment as plastic materials degrade, thereby posing risks to both ecosystems and human health. Nanoparticle interactions with living organisms have garnered significant attention due to their potential to disrupt vital biological processes. Of particular interest are lipid membranes, acting as crucial gatekeepers, underscoring the importance of comprehending the intricate process of NP penetration. Molecular dynamics (MD) simulations serve as a robust tool, offering molecular-level insights into these intricate interactions. In this study, we leverage all-atom MD simulations to delve into the interactions between lipid bilayers and polyethylene (PETH) chains of varying lengths. The investigation spans diverse lipid bilayer compositions—ranging from pure POPC to POPC:DPPC mixtures—revealing how PETH accommodates itself, adopts extended conformations, and influences membrane structure and ordering. Significantly, while longer PETH chains demonstrate limited passive diffusion, their potential to penetrate bilayers over extended timescales emerges as a significant revelation. Overall, this research significantly advances our comprehension of NP-membrane interactions, shedding light on the potential environmental and health implications that lie ahead.