In the absence of systematic cardiovascular preparticipation screening (PPS) practices in Canada, the Canadian Cardiovascular Society and Canadian Heart Rhythm Society published a joint position statement outlining PPS recommendations for competitive athletes in an effort to standardize screening. The Queen’s University Cardiovascular Screening and Care of Athletes Program aimed to translate these recommendations into practice. Screening packages were administered to athletes in 2017 and 2018. Each package required completion of a medical/history questionnaire, a physician’s examination, and 12-lead electrocardiogram performed by the athlete’s primary care physician. A tiered approach to screening, as recommended by the position statement, was implemented. A multidisciplinary team flagged at-risk athletes and determined the need for follow-up testing and participation eligibility. Over a 2-year period, 517 varsity athletes were screened, with 438 (84.7%) completing all recommended screening components. Analysis of completed packages resulted in 114 (26.0%) athletes flagged for initial review. After subsequent review by an emergency care physician, only 12 (2.7%) athletes required further referral to cardiology for assessment or further testing. All athletes referred for cardiology assessment were cleared for participation, except for one, who was eventually cleared after a shared decision-making process and cardiovascular intervention. The Queen’s University Cardiovascular Screening and Care of Athletes Program shows the successful implementation of a cardiovascular PPS program that used shared decision-making and a multidisciplinary approach to screening, allowing for efficiency and effective resource utilization.