…. is sure design'd, by fraud or force: trust not their presents, nor admit the horse. Virgil, Aeneid Human immunodeficiency virus type 1 (HIV-1), the lymphotropic virus that causes AIDS, has infected more than 60 million people worldwide since its clinical appearance in 1981. Despite intensive prevention efforts, the HIV/AIDS epidemic continues to spread, particularly in developing countries in sub-Saharan Africa, southeast Asia and the Caribbean, as well as the developed world [1]. Although HIV can be transmitted very efficiently parenterally, the advent of routine blood screening prior to transfusion and harm reduction programs for injection drug users, have made this mode of transmission much less common than mucosal transmission. Most new HIV infections are attributable to mucosal transmission: through genital and rectal mucosae in the case of sexual transmission and through oral or gastrointestinal mucosae in the case of mother-to-child transmission [2]. Much has been learned about HIV pathogenesis and infection mechanisms at the molecular level, but the scientific community has yet to develop an effective vaccine or microbicide for HIV prevention. Many unanswered questions remain concerning HIV-1 sexual transmission. In 1983, barely 2 years into the AIDS epidemic, we hypothesized that the agent that was subsequently identified as HIV-1 may be sexually transmitted by infected ‘Trojan Horse’ leukocytes in semen [3]. This hypothesis was based on our knowledge at the time that human semen contains substantial numbers of T lymphocytes and macrophages, which could host a T-cell tropic virus, and the following assumptions: intracellular virus would be better protected than free virus from adverse effects of antiviral factors in the genital environment such as antiviral antibodies likely to be present in genital secretions of the virus-infected transmitter, as well as antimicrobial peptides that play an important role in genital innate immune defense; and virus-infected allogeneic cells could also escape early detection by major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-restricted cytotoxic T cells in a new host. Over the intervening 25+ years, others have also championed this cause [4,5], and convincing evidence has emerged from clinical research as well as in-vitro and animal studies that infected leukocytes indeed play a role in HIV transmission. Yet, most recent research on sexual HIV transmission has focused on cell-free HIV in genital secretions because of the wide availability of HIV RNA quantification assays. Furthermore, the majority of HIV vaccines and microbicides have been designed to block transmission of cell-free virus and have been tested in animal and in-vitro models that use cell-free virus as the only infectious inoculum. As the molecular events underlying cell-associated HIV transmission differ from those underlying cell-free virus transmission, many of the current vaccine and microbicide candidates might not be expected to protect against cell-associated HIV transmission. The failure of several recent vaccine and microbicide clinical trials may be due in part to this oversight. It should be possible to design strategies that block cell-associated HIV transmission as well as cell-free HIV transmission. In this article, we present an overview of research that has been conducted on cell-associated HIV mucosal transmission and recommendations for future research. We focus on sexual HIV transmission, but this review also has relevance for mother-to-child HIV transmission, which may occur through mucosal transmission of cell-associated HIV from maternal genital or mammary gland secretions [6–8]. We review published reports that describe and enumerate HIV-infected cells in genital secretions, and compelling evidence from clinical, animal and in-vitro studies demonstrating that such cells can transmit HIV across genital tract epithelial surfaces; potential molecular mechanisms underlying cell-associated HIV transmission that could be specifically targeted by future HIV prevention strategies; and in-vitro and animal cell-associated HIV transmission models currently used for studies on cell-associated HIV transmission mechanisms and for testing vaccine and microbicide candidates. Using this information as a foundation, we discuss the evidence and probability that various current microbicide and vaccine approaches prevent cell-associated HIV transmission, and suggest additional microbicide and vaccine concepts and experiments that will move this field forward.
Read full abstract