Movement of bivalve hard and soft tissue requires muscular action. Despite diverse bivalve lifestyles and living environments, the myostracum, a specific hard tissue formed where muscles attach to the shell, appears similar in structure for species of many bivalve orders.We investigated myostracal and non-myostracal, valve, microstructure, texture and material properties of Chamidae and Glycymerididae species with electron-backscatter-diffraction, laser-confocal and backscatter electron imaging and nanoindentation testing. Chamidae and Glycymerididae follow different lifestyles and live in distinct environments. Chamidae are cemented to substrate and live in wave-swept, shallow, waters. Glycymerididae dwell in calm water and burrow into sandy/muddy sediment.We found that myostracal aragonite of all investigated species has a crystal assembly pattern that reflects crystal growth through growth competition. Aragonite is extensively twinned in the myostracum and non-myostracal, valve, layers, not in the calcitic ornamentation. For myostracal aragonite, we found cyclic twinning, for non-myostracal aragonite the twinning was polysynthetic or polycyclic. We show how twinning and crystallographic texture are transmitted between myostracal and non-myostracal, valve, layers. Relative to non-biological aragonite, myostracal and non-myostracal, valve, indentation elastic modulus is reduced by 10–15 % and 15–20 %, respectively; myostracal and valve hardness is increased by 15–20 % and 5–10 %, respectively. Comparing modulus and hardness between aragonitic microstructures, we found that, relative to other microstructures, myostracal modulus is increased by 5 % and myostracal hardness by 15 %. Hence, the myostracal material shows a unique and specific microstructure, texture, modulus, and hardness that might be necessary for muscle attachment to enable the lifestyle-controlled requirements posed onto the organism.