Reviewed by: The Hermits of Big Sur by Paula Huston Judith Sutera OSB The Hermits of Big Sur. By Paula Huston. Collegeville, MN: Liturgical Press, 2021. 235pp. $24.95. This is not a book about some romanticized characters who fit the world’s image of hermits, but about a real-life Roman Catholic community of Camaldolese hermits, a subset of the Benedictines, the oldest religious institution within the church. The book starts exactly where it should, with the question of why in the world anyone would take up the life of a hermit. Huston ably distinguishes between “fuga mundi,” a conscious flight from the world for a positive purpose and “contemptus mundi,” an attempt to escape the world because it is seen as evil. The hermit must be motivated by fleeing towards rather than fleeing from. Huston sets the stage for the Big Sur community by placing it firmly within its geographical environment. She makes the important connection between this religious settlement of the 1950s and the local world of author Henry Miller, resident artists, World War II veterans [End Page 85] seeking meaning and healing, and others drawn to the “grandeur and nobility of the setting” as Miller put it. Huston writes, “But Big Sur is not only astonishingly beautiful; it also manifests what the nineteenth-century British Romantics would call ‘the Sublime.’ By this term, they meant that the full power of uncontrolled nature is on display, and humans can only stand before the spectacle in awe” (7). Eventually, the monks would share this wild coastal land with the neighboring Esalen Institute, where people seeking meaning and mystery in this powerful natural setting would include Alan Watts, Aldous Huxley, LSD experimenters, and other mid-century thinkers. “The New Age movement, alternative medicine, East-West religious dialogue, yoga, massage, mind-body interventions, Joseph Campbell’s archetypes, and Fritz Perl’s Gestalt therapy owe much of their widespread practice today to the impressive lineup of radical thinkers who passed through Esalen during the revolutionary sixties. Like the psychedelic revolution, the Esalen phenomenon was also prompted by a kind of fuga mundi” (9). Some of these practices have even cross-pollinated with the very different world of their Camaldolese neighbors. Meanwhile, the monks were drawn to this place by their own contemporaneous search for meaning and a home for their contemplative life. The bulk of this book is not about a small group of men and the home they created but about the context in which they created it. The story is solidly situated within substantial descriptions of world history and Italian politics, especially the period of Mussolini and the love/hate relationship of fascism and the church. Given the world portrayed here, it is no wonder that a 1958 Time magazine featuring the Italian monks who came to look for a foundation place claimed they already had twenty potential applicants. But it is rare that a religious community is ever founded in harmony. The book follows correspondence with famous Trappist monk Thomas Merton and the many challenging matters around the early years, especially the turmoil within the church in that time of reform and renewal that divided communities and brought pain to many individuals. This monastery, as are so many, was born in the conflicting views of the kinds of people who dare to create, and the tension between human personalities, between ideal and institution. I have personally experienced the grace and goodness of this unique sacred place and have known some of the monks; this book helped me to see all of it in a much broader and deeper way. As a monastic religious myself, I commend the author on her ability to capture both the practical, historical dimensions and the indefinable power of this place and the people who created and live in it. I believe, too, that a story about such an unusual lifestyle told in this way might engage the minds [End Page 86] and hearts of people who know little about the world of religious hermits. Judith Sutera OSB Mount St. Scholastica Copyright © 2023 American Catholic Historical Society
Read full abstract