Using the empirical Tsyganenko (1987) long model as a prime example of a magnetospheric field model, we have attempted to identify the boundary between open and closed field lines. We define as “closed” all field lines that are connected with the Earth at both ends and cross the equatorial plane earthward of x = −70RE, the tailward validity limit of the Tsyganenko model. We find that the form of the open/closed boundary at the Earth's surface, identified with the polar cap boundary, can exhibit the arrowhead shape, pointed toward the Sun, observed in “horse collar auroras” (Hones et al., 1989). The “polar cap” size in the Tsyganenko model increases with increasing Kp values, and it becomes rounder and less pointed. The superposition of a net By field, which is the expected consequence of an IMF By, rotates the polar cap pattern and, for larger values, degrades the arrowhead shape, resulting in polar cap configurations consistent with known asymmetries in the aurora. The pointedness of the polar cap shape also diminishes or even completely disappears if the low‐latitude magnetopause is assumed open and located considerably inside of the outermost magnetic flux surface in the Tsyganenko model. The arrowhead shape of the polar cap is found to be associated with a strong increase of Bz from midnight toward the tail flanks, which is observed independently, and is possibly related to the NBZ field‐aligned current system, observed during quiet times and strongly northward IMF Bz. The larger Bz values near the flanks of the tail cause more magnetic flux to close through these regions than through the midnight equatorial region. Since field lines at the flanks primarily map to the dayside polar regions, it becomes plausible that the closed field line region extends to higher latitudes on the dayside than on the nightside, when the increase of Bz becomes more pronounced. By comparison with a different field model we demonstrate that this association is not unique to the Tsyganenko model. The similarity of the quiet symmetric polar cap pattern to “horse collar” auroras suggests that the bright “bars,” observed at the sides of the arrowhead shaped polar cap, are connected with the separatrix layers (or plasma sheet boundary layers) extending to the distant X line or separator, while the adjacent “web” regions, located between the bars and the main auroral oval, are connected with the low‐latitude boundary regions along the flanks of the magnetotail.
Read full abstract