This study evaluated the hypothesis that phytal amphipods are less susceptible to predation by fishes when on highly branched, morphologically complex algal hosts than when on seaweeds with a simple bladed morphology. Contrary to this hypothesis, laboratory experiments demonstrated that the amphipod Ampithoe longimana (Smith) was more susceptible to predation by the pinfish Lagodon rhomboides (L.) when on any of four highly branched seaweeds ( Hypnea musciformis (Wulf.) Lamouroux, H. comuta (Lamour.) J. Agardh, Gracilaria tikvahiae McLachlan, or G. verrucosa (Huds.) Papenruss) than when on either of two species with a simpler sheetlike morphology ( Padina gymnospora (Kutz.) Sonder or Ulva sp.) The morphologically intermediate alga Sargassum filipendula J. Agardh provided an intermediate level of protection. Similar experiments were conducted using plastic aquarium plants of highly branched and sheetlike morphology to evaluate the effects of host-plant morphology without the potentially confounding effects of other species-specific algal characteristics. The pattern evident in our tests with real plants was repeated in only one of two tests with plant mimics. This variable effect of host morphology combined with a demonstration that pinfish consumed the highly branched species Hypnea musciformis in preference to Padina gymnospora or Sargassum filipendula suggests that the susceptibility of phytal amphipods to predation by omnivorous fishes like Lagodon may be affected by both host-plant morphology and host-plant palatability to fishes. In field experiments the density of amphipods colonizing and surviving on Hypnea was significantly lower than their density on Padina or Sargassum regardless of whether the plants were protected from or exposed to fishes. In similar assays using only Sargassum, no clear effect offish predation on abundance of phytal amphipods could be demonstrated in the presence of high colonization rates by amphipods. Seasonal patterns of amphipod abundance on different host plants suggested that fish predation may be affecting the density of amphipods on Hypnea more than on Sargassum or Padina. In the summer, fish predation on amphipods becomes high. During this period, amphipod density per algal mass declined on Hypnea, slowly increased on Sargassum, and remained relatively constant on Padina. This field pattern of seasonal change in amphipod abundance as a function of algal host is consistent with our conclusion from laboratory studies that amphipods are more susceptible to omnivorous fish predation when on Hypnea, which is both morphologically complex and a high-preference food for the fish.