ISRAEL POTTER: MELVILLE'S ANTI-HISTORY Brian Rosenberg* For reasons easy enough to discover, Israel Potter: His Fifty Years of Exile is one of the most thoroughly overlooked full-length works by any major writer of the last two centuries. Herman Melville himself insisted that there would be "very little reflective writing" in Israel Potter , certainly "nothing weighty;"1 the simplicity of the plot and apparent transparency of its meaning seem to leave the enterprising critic little to do; and, most important, the text is highly derivative, drawing, as Melville concedes in his dedication, "almost as in a reprint" on Henry Trumbull 's earlier Life and Remarkable Adventures of Israel R. Potter. Generally critics have treated Israel Potter, Melville's only novel written expressly for serialized publication in a magazine, as a work written quickly and largely for profit after the popular disaster of Pierre, at best an improved version and at worst a mere reiteration of an earlier, obscure narrative. While Israel Potter clearly is among neither the most ambitious nor the most successfully realized of Melville's novels, it is nonetheless considerably more sophisticated and more typical of its mature author than is often imagined. The period of its composition, characterized by such works as Pierre, "Bartleby the Scrivener," and The Confidence Man, was for Melville a time of fairly consistent ironic commentary and formal experimentation during which everything written is—like the Confidence Man himself—more than it merely appears to be. So too is Israel Potter. Melville's elaborate insistence on the lack of artistic originality in the book, on its debased status as a mere "reprint," along with what Michael Kämmen describes as the "sarcastic" tone of the entire narrative ,2 should in truth suggest that yet another sleight-of-hand is being attempted. Israel Potter may begin by retelling Trumbull's anecdotal biography, but it ends, much more interestingly, by both assuming a place in and parodying one of the central traditions of nineteenth-century literature, the tradition of historical fiction, or more generally, imaginative history. Melville's novel about his country's rebellion against Britain is itself a wry rebellion against the confident, largely conservative beliefs of British historical literature. 'Brian Rosenberg is an Assistant Professor of English at Allegheny College. He has published articles in Studies in the Novel, South Atlantic Quarterly, Dickens Quarterly, and CEA Critic. He is currently working on books on Charles Dickens and Mary Lee Settle. 176Brian Rosenberg In the decade before Israel Potter was initially conceived in 1849, Charles Dickens published Barnaby Rudge, Thomas Carlyle Past and Present, Charlotte Bronte Shirley, and minor novelists like Harrison Ainsworth, G. P. R. James, and Bulwer Lytton a flood of mediocre historical romances; the years between the conception of the novel and its appearance in Putnam's Magazine in 1854 saw most notably the publication of William Thackeray's Henry Esmond and John Ruskin's Stones of Venice; in the subsequent ten years Dickens published A Tale of Two Cities, George Eliot Romola, Charles Reade the immensely popular Cloister and the Hearth. At no time before or since has the desire to recreate the past in imaginative literature of all kinds been more powerful or widespread. And, at least among the more important writers, this desire produced a collection of works remarkably consistent in vision, form, and purpose. George Eliot, defining in the 1870s what she calls "historic imagination," articulates in advanced but characteristic terms the conception of the ideal historical narrative: The exercise of a veracious imagination in historical picturing seems to be capable of a development that might help the judgement greatly with regard to present and future events. By veracious imagination , I mean the working out in detail of the various steps by which a political or social change was reached, using all extant evidence and supplying deficiencies by careful analogical creation. How triumphant opinions originally spread—how institutions arose—what were the conditions of great inventions, discoveries, or theoretic conceptions— what circumstances affecting individual lots are attendant on the decay of long-established systems,—all these grand elements of history require the illumination of special imaginative treatment.' The phrase "veracious imagination" and the union of...