Antipredator Behavior Research Articles

Winter Behavior of Juvenile Brown Trout in a Changing Climate: How Do Light and Ice Cover Affect Encounters with Instream Predators?

During winter, stream fishes are vulnerable to semi-aquatic predators like mammals and birds and reduce encounters by being active in darkness or under surface ice. Less is known about the behavior of fishes towards instream piscivorous fishes. Here, we examined how surface ice and light affected the anti-predator behavior of juvenile brown trout (Salmo trutta Linnaeus, 1758) in relation to piscivorous burbot (Lota lota Linnaeus, 1758) and northern pike (Esox lucius Linnaeus, 1758) at 4 °C in experimental flumes. Trout had lower foraging and swimming activity and spent more time sheltering when predators were present than when absent. In daylight, trout’s swimming activity was not affected by predators, whereas in darkness trout were less active when predators were present. Trout consumed more drifting prey during the day when ice was present, and they positioned themselves further upstream when under ice cover, regardless of light conditions. Trout stayed closer to conspecifics under ice, but only in the presence of pike. Piscivorous fishes thus constitute an essential part of the predatory landscape of juvenile trout in winter, and thus loss of ice cover caused by climate warming will likely affect trout’s interactions with predators.

Habitat visibility affects the behavioral response of a large herbivore to human disturbance in forest landscapes

Wildlife can perceive humans as predators and human disturbance, whether lethal (e.g., hunting) or non-lethal (e.g., hiking, biking, and skiing), triggers antipredator behavior among prey. Visibility is the property that relates habitat structure to accessibility of visual information that allows animals to detect predators and evaluate predation risk. Thus, the visibility of a habitat (hereafter referred to as habitat visibility) for prey species alters the perceived risk of predation and therefore has a strong influence on their antipredator behavior. Yet, knowledge of how habitat visibility affects the response of animals to different types of human disturbance is limited, partly, because it is challenging to measure habitat visibility for animals at a fine spatial scale over a landscape, particularly in highly heterogeneous landscapes (e.g., forests). In this study, we employed a newly described approach that combines terrestrial and airborne LiDAR to contiguously measure fine-scale habitat visibility in a forested landscape. We applied the LiDAR-derived habitat visibility to examine how habitat visibility in forests affects the summer space use of 20 GPS-collared female red deer (Cervus elaphus) modeled with integrated step-selection functions in the Bavarian Forest National Park, Germany when exposed to various types of human disturbance including recreational activities, forest roads, hiking trails, and hunting. We found that red deer in our study area avoided areas with higher all types of human disturbance, especially during daylight hours. Furthermore, habitat visibility significantly modified the use of space by red deer in response to human recreational activities, forest roads, and hiking trails, but not to the hunting area. Red deer tended to tolerate a higher intensity of human recreational activities and to use areas closer to forest roads or hiking trails when they have lower habitat visibility (i.e., more cover). Our findings highlight the importance of considering visual perception when studying the response of wild animals to human disturbance. We emphasize the potential to mitigate negative consequences of human disturbance on wildlife, through measures such as maintaining vegetative buffers around recreational infrastructure (e.g., roads and skiing tracks) in order to reduce habitat visibility around areas frequented by humans.

Behavioural adjustments enable the colonization of subterranean environments

Abstract Specialized subterranean species are iconic examples of convergent evolution driven by environmental constraints, representing an ideal model system for eco-evolutionary studies. However, scientific research on the behavioural adaptations of subterranean organisms has lagged and is biased mostly towards a few model species. Through a systematic literature review, we aimed to assess quantitatively whether a congruent evolution of behavioural traits among subterranean species exists. We considered four types of behaviours (exploratory, feeding, social and anti-predator) and tested predictions about their occurrence among species with different degrees of adaptation to subterranean environments. We argue that these behaviours constitute the earliest adaptations to three main ecological factors characterizing subterranean habitats, namely the constant darkness, the limited food resources and the reduced predator pressure. Darkness selects for individuals that rely on non-visual cues to explore their surroundings, track food resources and locate potential sexual partners. The reduced availability of food promotes high foraging plasticity and deters species from adopting aggressive behaviours towards conspecifics. The reduced predator pressure allows species to abandon specific anti-predator behaviours and permits safer execution of their biological activities. Our analyses show that these four behaviours are likely to represent the result of an early convergent adaptation to the subterranean realm.

Modeling and Dynamical Analysis of a Fractional-Order Predator–Prey System with Anti-Predator Behavior and a Holling Type IV Functional Response

We here investigate the dynamic behavior of continuous and discrete versions of a fractional-order predator–prey system with anti-predator behavior and a Holling type IV functional response. First, we establish the non-negativity, existence, uniqueness and boundedness of solutions to the system from a mathematical analysis perspective. Then, we analyze the stability of its equilibrium points and the possibility of bifurcations using stability analysis methods and bifurcation theory, demonstrating that, under specific parameter conditions, the continuous system exhibits a Hopf bifurcation, while the discrete version exhibits a Neimark–Sacker bifurcation and a period-doubling bifurcation. After providing numerical simulations to illustrate the theoretically derived conclusions and by summarizing the various analytical results obtained, we finally present four interesting conclusions that can contribute to better management and preservation of ecological systems.

Evolution of schooling drives changes in neuroanatomy and motion characteristics across predation contexts in guppies

One of the most spectacular displays of social behavior is the synchronized movements that many animal groups perform to travel, forage and escape from predators. However, elucidating the neural mechanisms underlying the evolution of collective behaviors, as well as their fitness effects, remains challenging. Here, we study collective motion patterns with and without predation threat and predator inspection behavior in guppies experimentally selected for divergence in polarization, an important ecological driver of coordinated movement in fish. We find that groups from artificially selected lines remain more polarized than control groups in the presence of a threat. Neuroanatomical measurements of polarization-selected individuals indicate changes in brain regions previously suggested to be important regulators of perception, fear and attention, and motor response. Additional visual acuity and temporal resolution tests performed in polarization-selected and control individuals indicate that observed differences in predator inspection and schooling behavior should not be attributable to changes in visual perception, but rather are more likely the result of the more efficient relay of sensory input in the brain of polarization-selected fish. Our findings highlight that brain morphology may play a fundamental role in the evolution of coordinated movement and anti-predator behavior.

How to move and when to escape: quantifying intraspecific exploratory and anti-predator behavior in an aposematic poison frog

How to move and when to escape: quantifying intraspecific exploratory and anti-predator behavior in an aposematic poison frog

Degenerate codimension-2 cusp of limit cycles in a Holling–Tanner model with harvesting and anti-predator behavior

In this paper, a Holling–Tanner predator–prey model with constant-yield prey harvesting and anti-predator behavior is investigated. It is shown that the codimension of a nilpotent cusp is 3 and a degenerate Bogdanov–Takens bifurcation of codimension 3 acts as an organizing center for rich dynamical behaviors including saddle–node bifurcation, Hopf bifurcation, saddle–node bifurcation of limit cycles, and homoclinic bifurcation. Moreover, a Hopf bifurcation of codimension 2 is found, a codimension-2 cusp of limit cycles is firstly observed, and the corresponding normal form coefficients are also obtained, which indicate that there exists an acute angle region of three coexistent limit cycles. In particular, a reversed S-shaped saddle–node bifurcation curve of limit cycles is found. In addition, we observe that the anti-predator behavior may cause nearly extinction of the predator population while the prey population reaches its maximum which is less than the carrying capacity due to the effect of harvesting; however, the constant-yield prey harvesting may drive both species to extinction suddenly. Finally, numerical simulations including bifurcation diagrams and phase portraits are given to illustrate the theoretical results.

White-tailed deer responses to acoustic predator cues are contingent upon past land use and contemporary fire regime

Abstract Prey can assess the immediate risk of predation by detecting cues of predator presence, and it is expected that prey should invest in costly antipredator behaviors when a cue of predator presence is detected. Features of the habitat in which the cue is detected, such as vegetative concealment, serve as indirect cues of risk and can mediate how prey respond to direct cues of predator presence. Past agricultural land use and contemporary fire regimes are common disturbances that may modify prey perceptions of risk and could, therefore, alter prey responses to direct cues of predator presence. We examined whether the overlap of these two disturbances affected white-tailed deer (Odocoileus virginianus) responses to cues of predator presence by measuring deer vigilance and foraging bout duration in response to coyote (Canis latrans) vocalizations across 20 woodlands that varied in past land use and contemporary fire regime. Frequent fire regimes consistently increased deer visibility to predators across both land-use history contexts. Deer exhibited no behavioral response to the predator cue in habitats containing infrequent fire regimes or agricultural legacies. Deer responded to the cue in frequently burned woodlands without agricultural legacies through increased vigilance and time spent at a foraging location. These findings reveal that land-use legacies and contemporary fire regimes can mediate how prey respond to direct cues of risk. They also suggest that prey may balance the uncertainty associated with cues of predation risk with the urgency of responding to a potential attack by being vigilant and remaining in place.

Dynamics of Prey-Predator Interaction with Type II Holling Response Function, Additional Food, and Anti-Predator Behavior

This study discusses the interaction model of prey-predator in the presence of additional food and the ability of anti-predator behavior on prey using the type II Holling response function. This research is carried out starting from the study of the literature, contructing models, determining equilibrium points, analyzing equilibrium points, numerical simulation, and drawing conclusion. From the results of the model analysis, four equilibrium points were obtained, namely the extinction of the two unstable populations, the extinction of predators, and two points with the existence of both stable populations with conditions. Based on the results of the analysis carried out, there is a change in the system solution from the limit point which is the boundary point and , then it is continued to the right to produce two point solutions, namely, point is stable to the Hopf bifurcation point when A = 0.239884 and is unstable until A = 0.147059. after the hopf bifurcation there is a change in stability to become unstable which coincides with a stable limit cycle. The simulation results show that additional food affects the stability of prey and predators even though there is anti-predator behavior on prey.

Predation fear and its carry-over effect in a fractional order prey–predator model with prey refuge

This research article centers on the formulation and analysis of a novel prey–predator model that integrates the impacts of predation fear, prey refuge, and carry-over effects. The model is formulated and analyzed using fractional differential equations (FDEs). The model incorporates ecological concepts such as anti-predator behaviours and memory effects to maintain a better understanding of prey–predator interactions. The mathematical model is developed based on a basic prey–predator model with a Michelis–Menten functional response and includes fear-induced carry-over effects, prey refuge, and fractional order derivatives. The study investigates the well-posedness, stability, and Hopf bifurcation of the proposed model and conducts detailed numerical investigations. The integration of different anti-predatory mechanisms and the use of FDEs contribute to a comprehensive understanding of the dynamics of prey–predator interactions and provide useful insights into the complexities of ecological systems.

Shock or jump: deimatic behaviour is repeatable and polymorphic in the Apennine yellow-bellied toad, Bombina pachypus

Abstract Inter-individual variation in antipredatory behaviour has long attracted curiosity among scientists. Deimatism is a complex, multi-component antipredatory strategy consisting of prey suddenly unleashing unexpected defences to startle predators and stop their attack. Deimatic species provide an appealing system to investigate the trade-offs between alternative behavioural phenotypes when faced with a threat. Yet, inter-individual variation in deimatic behaviour is almost unexplored. Here, we simulated a predator attack on 71 yellow-bellied toads, Bombina pachypus, to investigate the extent and pattern of inter-individual variation in the unken reflex behaviour, a deimatic display performed by some amphibians. Results show that deimatic displays consistently differ among B. pachypus individuals. Only about half of the individuals reacted to the simulated predation stimuli by exhibiting the display, which varied in responsiveness, duration and intensity. All the behavioural descriptors were highly repeatable. Finally, we found significant correlations between the measured parameters, defining two prevalent behavioural profiles: individuals quickly doing the unken reflex, with high intensity and long duration of the display, and individuals avoiding the unken reflex but instead escaping. This dichotomy resembles the proactive and reactive patterns in coping styles, and raises intriguing questions on the evolutionary processes shaping multiple adaptive responses to predation within populations.

Improving the success of reinforcement programs: effects of a two-week confinement in a field enclosure on the anti-predator behaviour of captive-bred European hamsters.

Captive breeding programs are an important pillar in biodiversity conservation, aiming to prevent the extinction of threatened species. However, the establishment of self-sustaining populations in the wild through the release of captive-bred animals is often hampered by a high mortality upon release. In this study, we investigated how a 2-week confinement period within a large field enclosure affected the anti-predator behaviour of 'naive' captive-bred hamsters and how potential modifications persisted over time. During three consecutive tests, hamsters were confronted with a moving predator model (a red fox mount, Vulpes vulpes) and their behaviour was filmed. After the initial round of confrontation with the predator model, one group of hamsters (field group) was released into a field enclosure protected from predators, while the other group (control) remained in their individual laboratory cages. After 2 weeks, hamsters from the field group were recaptured and individuals of both groups underwent a second confrontation test. A total of 1 month after their return from the field enclosure, field hamsters were subjected to a last confrontation test. Video analysis, investigating four behavioural variables, revealed that field hamsters significantly modified their behavioural response following the 2 weeks confinement in the enclosure, while this was not the case for control hamsters. In addition, most behavioural modifications in field hamsters persisted over 1 month, while others started to revert. We suggest that an appropriate pre-release period inside a field enclosure will enable naive (captive-bred) hamsters to develop an adequate anti-predator behaviour that will increase their immediate survival probability upon release into the wild. We believe that such measure will be of great importance for hamster conservation programs.

Locomotor performance differs between foraging and predator escape but is not related to survival in hatchling lizards

Abstract Behaviour is influenced by many factors, including morphology, performance capabilities and the surrounding environment. Behavioural adjustments in response to these factors have important fitness consequences, and therefore behaviour should be considered when evaluating relationships among morphology, performance and fitness. We used hatchling fence lizards (Sceloporus undulatus) to test if sprinting speed and movement behaviours (e.g. latency to approach prey, number of pauses when fleeing or foraging) differ between foraging and anti-predator contexts and if these behaviours are associated with body size, locomotor performance capacity and survival. We quantified maximal sprint performance of individuals and evaluated their running speed in laboratory trials of foraging (moving towards crickets) and predator escape (response to a swooping avian predator). We show that hatchlings run at ~17–36% of total capacity when foraging. Although the most common anti-predator behaviour was to remain still, those that fled from the predator ran at full burst speed. However, foraging and escape speed/behaviours were not associated with body size or locomotor capacity. Hatchlings were subsequently released at our field site for a recapture study to assess phenotypic relationships with survival. We found no evidence that survival was influenced by performance or behaviour, but body size was positively related to survival in the field. These results highlight how seemingly important fitness-relevant behavioural and performance traits may not mediate the relationship between body size and survival.

Interspecific differences in the effects of masking and distraction on anti-predator behavior in suburban anthropogenic noise.

Predation is a common threat to animal survival. The detection of predators or anti-predator communication signals can be disrupted by anthropogenic noise; however, the mechanism by which responses are affected is unclear. Masking and distraction are the two hypotheses that have emerged as likely explanations for changes in behavior in noise. Masking occurs when the signal and noise fall within the same sensory domain; noise overlapping the energy in the signal reduces signal detection. Distraction can occur when noise in any sensory domain contributes to a greater cognitive load, thereby reducing signal detection. Here, we used a repeated measures field experiment to determine the relative contributions of masking and distraction in mediating reduced anti-predator responses in noise. We recorded the approaches and vocalizations of black-capped chickadees (Poecile atricapillus), tufted titmice (Baeolophus bicolor), and white-breasted nuthatches (Sitta carolinensis) to both visual and acoustic cues of predator presence, either with or without simultaneous exposure to anthropogenic noise. Titmice increased their calling to both visual and acoustic cues of predator presence. However, there was no significant effect of noise on the calling responses of titmice regardless of stimulus modality. Noise appeared to produce a distraction effect in chickadees; however, this effect was small, suggesting that chickadees may be relatively unaffected by low levels of anthropogenic noise in suburban environments. White-breasted nuthatch calling behavior was affected by the interaction of the modality of the predator stimulus and the noise condition. Nuthatches had a delayed response to the predator presentations, with a greater calling rate following the presentation of the acoustic stimulus in quiet compared to the presentation of the acoustic stimulus in noise. However, there was no difference in calling rate between the quiet and noise conditions for the visual stimulus. Together this suggests that even moderate levels of noise have some masking effect for white-breasted nuthatches. We suggest that the mechanisms through which noise influences anti-predator behavior may depend on the social roles, foraging ecology and auditory capabilities of each species.

Multiple layer kernel extreme learning machine modeling and eugenics genetic sparrow search algorithm for the state of health estimation of lithium-ion batteries

High precision state of health (SOH) estimation of lithium-ion batteries (LIBs) is a research hotspot in battery management system (BMS). To achieve this goal, an improved integrated algorithm based on multiple layer kernel extreme learning machine (ML-KELM) and eugenics genetic sparrow search (EGSS) algorithm is proposed to estimate the SOH of LIBs. First, a kernel version of ML-ELM model is constructed for initial SOH estimation of LIBs. The kernel function parameters are used to simulate sparrow foraging and anti-predatory behaviors, and the parameter optimization process is completed in the proposed EGSS algorithm by iteratively updating the position of sparrows to improve SOH prediction accuracy and model stability. The cycle data of different specifications of LIB units are processed to construct the high-dimensional health feature (HF) dataset and the low-dimensional fusion feature (FF) dataset, and each version of ML-ELM network is trained and tested separately. The numerical analysis of the prediction results shows that the best root mean square error (RMSE) of the comprehensive algorithm for SOH estimation is limited within 0.29%. The results of the multi-indicator comparison show that the proposed algorithm can track the true value stably and accurately with satisfactory high accuracy and strong robustness.

Human disturbance affects behavioural time allocation in a fiddler crab (<em>Austruca annulipes</em>) in Southern Thailand

Human disturbances affect the macroinvertebrate populations in coastal regions. They respond to disturbances by altering their density and behaviour. Therefore, many of them are used as bioindicator species of human disturbance. Here, we pioneer the use of fiddler crabs to examine whether they alter their behaviour under human disturbance. Male fiddler crabs possess one large claw used for courting (waving) and fighting, and one small feeding claw, whereas females have two feeding claws. They show several surface activities. This study investigates (1) the effects of human disturbance on density and sex-ratio, and (2) the effects of human disturbance, and sex on behavioural time allocations in Austruca annulipes. Their density, sex-ratio, and time allocations were investigated in human-disturbed area (DA) and nondisturbed area (NDA). They showed feeding, feeding and walking, walking, running, standing/vigilance, inside burrows, burrowing, grooming, fighting, and waving. The results showed that crab density was higher and the sex ratio was more male biased in NDA than in DA. Human disturbance and sex affected time allocations but their interaction had no effect. Crabs in DA spent more time running, standing, and inside burrows but less time walking, burrowing, fighting, and waving than crabs in NDA. Between sexes, males spent more time standing, burrowing, grooming, and fighting but less time feeding, and walking than females. This indicates that human disturbances force the crabs to spend more time on anti-predator and escape behavior (standing/vigilance, running, inside burrows) rather than courting (waving) and constructing burrows (mating/breeding sites), which are important for breeding.

Wolf contact in horses at permanent pasture in Germany.

Wolves returned to Germany in 2000, leading to fear in German horse owners that their horses could be in danger of wolf attacks or panic-like escapes from pastures when sighting wolves. However, reports from southern European countries indicate that wolf predation on horses diminishes with increasing presence of wildlife. Therefore, we conducted a long-term, filed observation between January 2015 and July 2022 on 13 non breeding riding horses, mares and geldings, kept permanently on two pastures within the range of wildlife and a stable wolf pack with annual offspring. Wildlife cameras at the fences of the pastures made 984 times recordings of wolves and 3151 times recordings of wildlife in and around the pastures. Between 1 January 2022 and 23 March 2022 we observed two stable horse groups. Pasture 1 was grazed by five horses of mixed breed, four mares and one gelding, with the median age of 8 years (min. = 6y, max. = 29y). Pasture 2 was grazed by eight heavy warmbloods and draught horses, three mares and five geldings, with the median age of 16 years (min. = 13y, max. = 22y). During this period no wolf was recorded at pasture 2, but wild boar several times, whereas at pasture 1, wolves were recorded 89 times, and for the wildlife mostly hare. Wolves may have avoided pasture 2 because of the presence of wild boar or because the large group of older, heavy breed horses may have formed a stable, protective group. The latter needs to be confirmed in a follow-up field observation, which records anti-predator behavior and welfare indicators in horses. In conclusion, wolves did not attack the mature horses on pastures with plenty of wildlife and the horses did not respond to the presence of wolves with visible signs of reduced welfare or panic. This indicates that wolves may prefer to prey on easily accessible wildlife around and at horse pastures and that Central European horses become accustom to the presence of non-hunting wolves.

Dynamic Behaviours and Bifurcation Analysis of a Filippov Ecosystem with Fear Effect

Evidences of the fear effect of the prey are well documented, which can greatly affect the dynamics of the predator-prey system. In this study, considering that the fear effect of the prey is triggered on as the density of the predator reaches and exceeds a threshold value, we develop a Filippov system of predator-prey model with the fear effect. In addition, we also include a modify factor of the growth rate of the prey when they adopt the antipredator behaviours due to the fear effect. We initially analyze the dynamics of the two subsystems, including the existence and stability of the equilibria. Utilizing the theory of the Filippov system, we discuss the sliding dynamics, i.e., the existence of sliding region and sliding equilibria. By choosing the threshold as the bifurcation parameter, we investigate the bifurcations near the regular equilibria. The solution curve has three cases: crossing the threshold curve, sliding on the threshold curve, and approaching the pseudoequilibrium. Finally, we numerically verified the existence of the global sliding bifurcation near the regular equilibrium and also the touching bifurcation.

Effects of amplitude and duration of noise exposure on the hearing and anti-predator behaviour of common roach (Rutilus rutilus) and sand goby (Pomatoschistus minutus).

This study investigates whether an exposure to two different received sound pressure levels at equal cumulative energy affects anti-predator behaviour and auditory detection thresholds of common roach (Rutilus rutilus) and sand goby (Pomatoschistus minutus) differently. This was examined in regard to a vessel slowdown as a management strategy to decrease vessel noise impact on fishes. Using continuous broadband noise, we found significant temporary threshold shifts (TTS) in roach, with 11.9 and 13.4 dB at 250 and 1000 Hz respectively, for the louder exposure. In contrast, gobies exhibited a non-significant shift of 6.6 dB at 125 Hz. Group cohesion increased in roach exposed to an artificial predator in the control group, but not during noise exposures. Gobies showed an initial freezing reaction towards the predator stimulus remaining motionless regardless of treatment. Our results show that a reduction in vessel speed with a corresponding reduction in source level could mitigate the effects on the auditory senses of sensitive fish, but does not appear to have any mitigating effect on their noise-induced behavioural changes. Further studies should investigate the effects of multiple vessel passages, but also the ecological consequences of the described effects on hearing and behaviour at individual and population level.

Anti-predator behavior in two brown frogs: differences in the mean behaviors and in the structure of animal personality variation

Predation is a major source of selection and prey are known to modify their behavior depending on their past experiences and the current perceived risk. Within a species, variation in experience and in the response to perceived risk combine to explain variation in personality and individual plasticity. Between species, variation in personality and plasticity might also be the evolutionary consequence of different selective regimes. In this study, we describe the anti-predator behavior of two closely related brown frogs, Rana dalmatina and Rana latastei, and compare their structures of personality variation. We raised tadpoles in a common garden experiment with either fish, dragonfly larvae, or no predators. Tadpoles were then repeatedly tested in the presence of the three acute stimuli and their behavioral variation was described in terms of quantity and quality of movements and of path sinuosity. In these tests, tadpoles of both species and ontogenetic treatments responded flexibly to predators by moving less, faster, and with more tortuous movements, and tadpoles raised with predators tended to move even faster. Independent of the acute treatment, R. dalmatina moved more and faster than R. latastei and the differences were larger without than with predators, demonstrating its higher plasticity. At the individual level, the two species showed qualitatively similar but quantitatively different structures of personality variation. R. dalmatina, more active, faster, and more plastic than R. latastei, showed also higher repeatability and a larger behavioral variation both among and within individuals.Significance statementPredators are a major source of selection and preys have evolved the ability to flexibly respond to them. These responses often vary among species, because of their different evolutionary histories, and among individuals, because of their different experiences. We analyzed both these sources of behavioral variation in two closely related brown frogs, Rana dalmatina and R. latastei. We raised tadpoles either with or without predators and tested them in open field trials both with and without predators. The effects of the raising environment were similar in the two species, whereas the effects of the testing arena differed. Both species decreased activity and increased speed and sinuosity with predators, but R. dalmatina moved always more and faster than R. latastei and it showed higher plasticity, larger variation among and within individuals, and relatively higher values in repeatability.