Anti-myotonic Drugs Research Articles

Effects of mexiletine and its pyrroline derivative on NaV1.4 and NaV1.5 by automated patch-clamp: Toward safer anti-myotonic drugs

Effects of mexiletine and its pyrroline derivative on NaV1.4 and NaV1.5 by automated patch-clamp: Toward safer anti-myotonic drugs

The effect of methocarbamol and mexiletine on murine muscle spindle function.

The muscle relaxant methocarbamol and the antimyotonic drug mexiletine are widely used for the treatment of muscle spasms, myotonia, and pain syndromes. To determine whether these drugs affect muscle spindle function, we studied their effect on the resting discharge and on stretch-induced action potential frequencies of proprioceptive afferent neurons. Single unit action potential frequencies of proprioceptive afferents from muscle spindles in the murine extensor digitorum longus muscle of adult C57BL/6J mice were recorded under resting conditions and during ramp-and-hold stretches. Maximal tetanic force of the same muscle after direct stimulation was determined. High-resolution confocal microscopy analysis was performed to determine the distribution of Nav 1.4 channels, a potential target for both drugs. Methocarbamol and mexiletine inhibited the muscle spindle resting discharge in a dose-dependent manner with IC50 values around 300 μM and 6μM, respectively. With increasing concentrations of both drugs, the response to stretch was also affected, with the static sensitivity first followed by the dynamic sensitivity. At high concentrations, both drugs completely blocked muscle spindle afferent output. Both drugs also reversibly reduced the specific force of the extensor digitorum longus muscle after tetanic stimulation. Finally, we present evidence for the presence and specific localization of the voltage-gated sodium channel Nav 1.4 in intrafusal fibers. In this study we demonstrate that both muscle relaxants affect muscle spindle function, suggesting impaired proprioception as a potential side effect of both drugs. Moreover, our results provide additional evidence of a peripheral activity of methocarbamol and mexiletine.

Non-dystrophic myotonias: clinical and mutation spectrum of 70 German patients

IntroductionNon-dystrophic myotonias (NDM) are heterogeneous diseases caused by mutations in CLCN1 and SCN4A. The study aimed to describe the clinical and genetic spectrum of NDM in a large German cohort.MethodsWe retrospectively identified all patients with genetically confirmed NDM diagnosed in our center. The following data were analyzed: demographics, family history, muscular features, cardiac involvement, CK, EMG, genotype, other tested genes, treatment perceived efficacy.Results70 patients (age 40.2 years ± 14.9; 52.8% males) were included in our study (48 NDM-CLCN1, 22 NDM-SCN4A). The most frequent presenting symptoms were myotonia (NDM-CLCN1 83.3%, NDM-SCN4A 72.2%) and myalgia (NDM-CLCN1 57.4%, NDM-SCN4A 52.6%). Besides a more prominent facial involvement in NDM-SCN4A and cold-sensitivity in NDM-CLCN1, no other significant differences were observed between groups. Cardiac arrhythmia or conduction defects were documented in sixNDM-CLCN1 patients (three of them requiring a pacemaker) and one patient with NDM-SCN4A. CK was normal in 40% of patients. Myotonic runs in EMG were detected in 89.1% of CLCN1 and 78.9% of SCN4A. 50% of NDM-CLCN1 patients had the classic c.2680C>T (p.Arg894*) mutation. 12 new genetic variants are reported. About 50% of patients were not taking any anti-myotonic drug at the last follow-up. The anti-myotonic drugs with the best patient’s perceived efficacy were mexiletine and lamotrigine.ConclusionThis study highlights the relevant clinical overlap between NDM-CLCN1 and NDM-SCN4A patients and warrants the use of early and broad genetic investigation for the precise identification of the NDM subtype. Besides the clinical and genetic heterogeneity, the limited response to current anti-myotonic drugs constitutes a continuing challenge.

The analysis of myotonia congenita mutations discloses functional clusters of amino acids within the CBS2 domain and the C-terminal peptide of the ClC-1 channel.

Myotonia congenita (MC) is a skeletal-muscle hyperexcitability disorder caused by loss-of-function mutations in the ClC-1 chloride channel. Mutations are scattered over the entire sequence of the channel protein, with more than 30mutations located in the poorly characterized cytosolic C-terminal domain. In this study, we characterized, through patch clamp, seven ClC-1 mutations identified in patients affected by MC of various severities and located in the C-terminal region. The p.Val829Met, p.Thr832Ile, p.Val851Met, p.Gly859Val, and p.Leu861Pro mutations reside in the CBS2 domain, while p.Pro883Thr and p.Val947Glu are in the C-terminal peptide. We showed that the functional properties of mutant channels correlated with the clinical phenotypes of affected individuals. In addition, we defined clusters of ClC-1 mutations within CBS2 and C-terminal peptide subdomains that share the same functional defect: mutations between 829 and 835 residues and in residue 883 induced an alteration of voltage dependence, mutations between 851 and 859 residues, and in residue 947 induced a reduction of chloride currents, whereas mutations on 861 residue showed no obvious change in ClC-1 function. This study improves our understanding of the mechanisms underlying MC, sheds light on the role of the C-terminal region in ClC-1 function, and provides information to develop new antimyotonic drugs.

Effects of Benzothiazolamines on Voltage-Gated Sodium Channels.

Benzothiazole is a versatile fused heterocycle that aroused much interest in drug discovery as anticonvulsant, neuroprotective, analgesic, anti-inflammatory, antimicrobial, and anticancer. Two benzothiazolamines, riluzole and lubeluzole, are known blockers of voltage-gated sodium (Nav) channels. Riluzole is clinically used as a neuroprotectant in amyotrophic lateral sclerosis. Inhibition of Nav channels by riluzole is voltage-dependent due to preferential binding to inactivated sodium channels. Yet the drug exerts little use-dependent block, probably because it lacks protonable amine. One important property is riluzole ability to inhibit persistent Na+ currents, which likely contributes to its neuroprotective activity. Lubeluzole showed promising neuroprotective effects in animal stroke models, but failed to show benefits in acute ischemic stroke in humans. One important concern is its propensity to prolong the cardiac QT interval, due to hERG K+ channel block. Lubeluzole very potently inhibits Nav channels in a voltage- and use-dependent manner, due to its great preferential affinity for inactivated channels and the presence of a protonable amine group. Patch-clamp experiments suggest that the binding sites of both drugs overlap the local anesthetic receptor within the ion-conducting pathway. Riluzole and lubeluzole displayed very potent antimyotonic activity in a rat model of myotonia, a pathological skeletal muscle condition characterized by high-frequency runs of action potentials. Such results well support the repurposing of riluzole as an antimyotonic drug, allowing the launch of a pilot study in myotonic patients. Riluzole, lubeluzole, and new Nav channel blockers built on the benzothiazolamine scaffold will certainly continue to be investigated for possible clinical applications.

Repurposing of sodium channel antagonists as potential new anti-myotonic drugs

Myotonia is often a painful and disabling symptom which can interfere with daily motor function resulting in significant morbidity. Since myotonic disorders are rare it has generally proved difficult to obtain class I level evidence for anti-myotonic drug efficacy by performing randomized placebo controlled trials. Current treatment guidance is therefore largely based on anecdotal reports and physician experience. Despite the genetic channel heterogeneity of the myotonic disorders the sodium channel antagonists have become the main focus of pharmacological interest. Mexiletine is currently regarded as the first choice sodium channel blocker based on a recent placebo controlled randomized trial. However, some patients do not respond to mexiletine or have significant side effects limiting its use. There is a clinical need to develop additional antimyotonic agents. The study of Desaphy et al. is therefore important and provides in vitro evidence that a number of existing drugs with sodium channel blocking capability could potentially be repurposed as anti-myotonic drugs. Translation of these potentially important in vitro findings into clinical practice requires carefully designed randomized controlled trials. Here we discuss Desaphy's findings in the wider context of attempts to develop additional therapies for patients with clinically significant myotonia.

Effect of mexiletine on transitory depression of compound motor action potential in recessive myotonia congenita

ObjectiveWe aim to demonstrate the effect of mexiletine on the compound muscle action potential (CMAP) amplitude transitory depression (TD) in a cohort of patients with recessive myotonia congenita. MethodsWe evaluated 21 patients with recessive myotonia congenita referred to our institute from 1990 to 2013 and treated with mexiletine chlorhydrate. All patients underwent prolonged 3Hz repetitive nerve stimulation (3Hz-PLRS) before and after the beginning of treatment. ResultsWe observed in all subjects a reduction of CMAP amplitude TD after the beginning of treatment. The mean value of the TD nadir before starting mexiletine treatment was −62.0% and reduced to −28.8% after the therapy was started (51.6% reduction, p<0.001). ConclusionsThe 3Hz-PLRS is configured as a neurophysiological test able to indirectly detect and quantify, through the measurement of TD, the clinical phenomenon of the transitory weakness that occurs in myotonic syndromes due to CLCN1 mutations. SignificanceThis neurophysiological test might be considered a helpful tool to assess the effect of anti-myotonic drugs, as mexiletine, in recessive myotonia congenita.

Preclinical evaluation of marketed sodium channel blockers in a rat model of myotonia discloses promising antimyotonic drugs

Although the sodium channel blocker mexiletine is considered the first-line drug in myotonia, some patients experiment adverse effects, while others do not gain any benefit. Other antimyotonic drugs are thus needed to offer mexiletine alternatives. In the present study, we used a previously-validated rat model of myotonia congenita to compare six marketed sodium channel blockers to mexiletine. Myotonia was induced in the rat by injection of anthracen-9-carboxylic acid, a muscle chloride channel blocker. The drugs were given orally and myotonia was evaluated by measuring the time of righting reflex. The drugs were also tested on sodium currents recorded in a cell line transfected with the human skeletal muscle sodium channel hNav1.4 using patch-clamp technique. In vivo, carbamazepine and propafenone showed antimyotonic activity at doses similar to mexiletine (ED50 close to 5mg/kg); flecainide and orphenadrine showed greater potency (ED50 near 1mg/kg); lubeluzole and riluzole were the more potent (ED50 near 0.1mg/kg). The antimyotonic activity of drugs in vivo was linearly correlated with their potency in blocking hNav1.4 channels in vitro. Deviation was observed for propafenone and carbamazepine, likely due to pharmacokinetics and multiple targets. The comparison of the antimyotonic dose calculated in rats with the current clinical dose in humans strongly suggests that all the tested drugs may be used safely for the treatment of human myotonia. Considering the limits of mexiletine tolerability and the occurrence of non-responders, this study proposes an arsenal of alternative drugs, which may prove useful to increase the quality of life of individuals suffering from non-dystrophic myotonia. Further clinical trials are warranted to confirm these results.

P.12.12 Preclinical in vitro and in vivo evaluation of sodium channel blockers as possible alternative to mexiletine in the treatment of myotonia

The efficacy of mexiletine in the treatment of non-dystrophic myotonias was recently confirmed in a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled crossover trial (Statland et al., JAMA 2012). Nevertheless, not all myotonic patients can obtain benefits from mexiletine, either due to lack of therapeutic effects or occurrence of side effects limiting the compliance. In addition, mexiletine has been withdrawn from a number of European countries, leaving patients with an unmeet medical need. Thus there is a critical need to increase the arsenal of antimyotonic drugs. In this study, we tested the antimyotonic activity of a number of marketed sodium channel blockers in vivo, by using a rat model in which myotonia is pharmacologically induced by i.p. injection of 9-anthracene carboxylic acid (Desaphy et al., Neuropharmacology 2013). The myotonic state was assessed by measuring the time of righting reflex of rats after 9-AC injection and oral administration of drugs. The dose–response curves indicate an ED50 of 7.0 ± 1.4 mg/kg for mexiletine. Propafenone and carbamazepine were twofold, orphenadrine 7-fold, flecainide 10-fold, lubeluzole and riluzole 70-fold, more efficient that mexiletine in vivo. The in vivo antimyotonic activity was in accord with the relative activity of sodium channel blockade in vitro, determined on heterologously expressed skeletal muscle hNav1.4 channels with patch-clamp technique. Two exceptions regard carbamazepine, which was more efficient in vivo compared to in vitro, and propafenone, which was less efficient in vivo than in vitro. Such discrepancies are likely related to pharmacokinetic mechanisms. The comparison of antimyotonic doses in the rat with clinical doses used in human indications suggest that all the tested sodium channels might be used safely in myotonic patients, except for lubeluzole that may present some cardiac risk. Supported by Telethon-Italy (grant GGP10101) and Association Francaise contre les Myopathies (grant 1502).

In vivo evaluation of antimyotonic efficacy of β-adrenergic drugs in a rat model of myotonia

The sodium channel blocker mexiletine is considered the first-line drug in myotonic syndromes, a group of muscle disorders characterized by membrane over-excitability. We previously showed that the β-adrenoceptor modulators, clenbuterol and propranolol, block voltage-gated sodium channels in a manner reminiscent to mexiletine, whereas salbutamol and nadolol do not. We now developed a pharmacological rat model of myotonia congenita to perform in vivo preclinical test of antimyotonic drugs. Myotonia was induced by i.p. injection of 30 mg/kg of anthracene-9-carboxylic acid (9-AC), a muscle chloride channel blocker, and evaluated by measuring the time of righting reflex (TRR). The TRR was prolonged from <0.5 s in control conditions to a maximum of ∼4 s, thirty minutes after 9-AC injection, then gradually recovered in a few hours. Oral administration of mexiletine twenty minutes after 9-AC injection significantly hampered the TRR prolongation, with an half-maximum efficient dose (ED50) of 12 mg/kg. Both propranolol and clenbuterol produced a dose-dependent antimyotonic effect similar to mexiletine, with ED50 values close to 20 mg/kg. Antimyotonic effects of 40 mg/kg mexiletine and propranolol lasted for 2 h. We also demonstrated, using patch-clamp methods, that both propranolol enantiomers exerted a similar block of skeletal muscle hNav1.4 channels expressed in HEK293 cells. The two enantiomers (15 mg/kg) also showed a similar antimyotonic activity in vivo in the myotonic rat. Among the drugs tested, the R(+)-enantiomer of propranolol may merit further investigation in humans, because it exerts antimyotonic effect in the rat model, while lacking of significant activity on the β-adrenergic pathway. This study provides a new and useful in vivo preclinical model of myotonia congenita in order to individuate the most promising antimyotonic drugs to be tested in humans.

Searching for novel anti-myotonic agents: Pharmacophore requirement for use-dependent block of skeletal muscle sodium channels by N-benzylated cyclic derivatives of tocainide

Drug screening on sodium currents of native myofibers by means of voltage-clamp recordings is predictive of pre-clinical anti-myotonic activity in vivo and ex vivo. By this approach we identified the N-benzylated beta-proline derivative of tocainide (To10) as the most potent use-dependent blocker of Nav1.4 so far. We tested novel analogs with modifications on the pharmacophore groups of To10. The substitution of the proline cycle with less planar piperidine or piperazine rings disclosed the importance of a two carbon atom distance and/or an additional nitrogen atom for potency. Structural changes on the xylididic group corroborated the role of a proper electronic cloud for hydrophobic interactions with the binding site. The N-benzylated moiety lead to a stereoselective behavior only in the rigid alpha-proline analog To11 vs. To10 and N-benzylated tocainide (To12). The results confirm the strict structural requirements of Nav1.4 blockers and allow to refine the drug design toward novel anti-myotonic drugs.

Evoked myotonia can be “dialed‐up” by increasing stimulus train length in myotonic dystrophy type 1

It is unknown how evoked myotonia varies with stimulus frequency or train length, or how it compares to voluntary myotonia in myotonic dystrophy type 1 (DM1). First dorsal interosseous (FDI) tetanic contractions evoked by trains of 10-20 ulnar nerve stimuli at 10-50 HZ were recorded in 10 DM1 patients and 10 normals. For comparison, maximum voluntary handgrip contractions were also recorded. An automated computer program placed cursors along the declining (relaxation) phase of the force recordings at 90% and 5% of peak force (PF) and calculated relaxation times (RTs) between these points. For all stimulus frequencies and train lengths, evoked RTs were much shorter, and evoked PFs were much greater in normals than in DM1. In normals, evoked RT was independent of stimulus frequency and train length, while in DM1 RT was longer for train lengths of 20 stimuli (mean: 9 s in DM1; 0.20 in normals) than for 10 stimuli (mean: 3 s in DM1, 0.19 in normals), but it did not change with stimulus frequency. In both groups PF increased greatly as stimulus frequency rose from 10-50 HZ but only slightly as train length rose from 10-20 stimuli. Voluntary handgrip RT (mean: 1.9 s) was less than evoked FDI RT (mean: 9 s). In DM1, evoked RT can be "dialed up" by increasing stimulus train length. Evoked myotonia testing utilizing a stimulus paradigm of at least 20 stimuli at 30-50 HZ may be useful in antimyotonic drug trials, particularly when grip RT is normal or equivocal.

Drug treatment for myotonia

Abnormal delayed relaxation of skeletal muscles, known as myotonia, can cause disability in myotonic disorders. Sodium channel blockers, tricyclic antidepressive drugs, benzodiazepines, calcium-antagonists, taurine and prednisone may be of use in reducing myotonia. To consider the evidence from randomised controlled trials on the efficacy and tolerability of drug treatment in patients with clinical myotonia due to a myotonic disorder. We searched the Cochrane Neuromuscular Disease Group trials register (April 2004), MEDLINE (January 1966 to December 2003) and EMBASE (January 1980 to December 2003). Grey literature was handsearched and reference lists of identified studies and reviews were examined. Authors, disease experts and manufacturers of anti-myotonic drugs were contacted. We considered all (quasi) randomised trials of participants with myotonia treated with any drug treatment versus no therapy, placebo or any other active drug treatment. The primary outcome measure was:reduced clinical myotonia using two categories: (1) no residual myotonia or improvement of myotonia or (2) No change or worsening of myotonia. Secondary outcome measures were:(1) clinical relaxation time; (2) electromyographic relaxation time; (3) stair test; (4) presence of percussion myotonia; and (5) proportion of adverse events. Two authors extracted the data independently onto standardised extraction forms and disagreements were resolved by discussion. Nine randomised controlled trials were found comparing active drug treatment versus placebo or another active drug treatment in patients with myotonia due to a myotonic disorder. Included trials were double-blind or single-blind crossover studies involving a total of 137 patients of which 109 had myotonic dystrophy type 1 and 28 had myotonia congenita. The studies were of poor quality. Therefore, we were not able to analyse the results of all identified studies. Two small crossover studies without a washout period demonstrated a significant effect of imipramine and taurine in myotonic dystrophy. One small crossover study with a washout period demonstrated a significant effect of clomipramine in myotonic dystrophy. Meta-analysis was not possible. Due to insufficient good quality data and lack of randomised studies, it is impossible to determine whether drug treatment is safe and effective in the treatment of myotonia. Small single studies give an indication that clomipramine and imipramine have a short-term beneficial effect and that taurine has a long-term beneficial effect on myotonia. Larger, well-designed randomised controlled trials are needed to assess the efficacy and tolerability of drug treatment for myotonia.

Gating of myotonic Na channel mutants defines the response to mexiletine and a potent derivative.

Myotonia and periodic paralysis caused by sodium channel mutations show variable responses to the anti-myotonic drug mexiletine. To investigate whether variability among sodium channel mutants results from differences in drug binding affinity or in channel gating. Whole-cell sodium currents (I(Na)) were recorded in tsA201 cells expressing human wild-type (WT) and mutant skeletal muscle sodium channels (A1156T, hyperkalemic periodic paralysis; R1448C, paramyotonia congenita; G1306E, potassium-aggravated myotonia). At a holding potential (hp) of -120 mV, mexiletine produced a tonic (TB, 0.33 Hz) and a use-dependent (UDB, 10 Hz) block of peak I(Na) with a potency following the order rank R1448C > WT approximately equal A1156T > G1306E. Yet, when assayed from an hp of -180 mV, TB and UDB by mexiletine were similar for the four channels. The different midpoints of channel availability curves found for the four channels track the half-maximum inhibitory value (IC50) measured at -120 mV. Thus differences in the partitioning of channels between the closed and fast-inactivated states underlie the different IC50 measured at a given potential. The mexiletine-derivative, Me7 (alpha-[(2-methylphenoxy)methyl]-benzenemethanamine), behaved similarly but was approximately 5 times more potent than mexiletine. Interestingly, the higher drug concentrations ameliorated the abnormally slower decay rate of myotonic I(Na). These results explain the basis of the apparent difference in block of mutant sodium channels by mexiletine and Me7, opening the way to a more rationale drug use and to design more potent drugs able to correct specifically the biophysical defect of the mutation in individual myotonic patients.

Homologation of mexiletine alkyl chain and stereoselective blockade of skeletal muscle sodium channels

The optical isomers (-)-( S)- and (+)-( R)-3-(2,6-dimethylphenoxy)-2-methyl-1-propanamine (Me2), homologues of the antiarrhythmic and antimyotonic drug mexiletine (Mex), were synthesized and assayed as new potential antimyotonic agents. As observed with Mex, Me2 exhibits an enantioselective behaviour. Tests carried out on sodium currents of single muscle fibres of Rana esculenta demonstrated that (-)-( S)- and (+)-( R)-Me2 were less potent than Mex in producing tonic block, but showed a higher use-dependent block. (-)-( S)-Me2 and (-)-( R)-Mex were also used to study the excitability of muscle fibres of myotonic ADR mice, a phenotype of a recessive form of low G Cl myotonia. (-)-( S)-Me2 reduced spontaneous discharges and after discharges better than (-)-( R)-Mex in agreement with the use-dependent block of sodium currents.

Different effects of mexiletine on two mutant sodium channels causing paramyotonia congenita and hyperkalemic periodic paralysis.

Effects of the antiarrhythmic and antimyotonic drug mexiletine were studied on two sodium channel mutants causing paramyotonia congenita (R1448H) and an overlap paramyotonic and hyperkalemic paralytic syndrome (M1360V). Channels were expressed in human embryonic kidney cells and studied electrophysiologically, using the whole-cell patch-clamp technique. Compared to the wild-type, channel, both mutants showed alterations of inactivation, i.e. slower inactivation, left shift of steady-state inactivation and faster recovery from inactivation. Mexiletine caused a significantly larger use-dependent block of the R1448H mutant when compared to M1360V and wild-type channels. This can be explained by a prolonged recovery from mexiletine block as observed for R1448H channels, since the affinity of mexiletine for the inactivated state was similar for all three clones. The use-dependent block of sodium channels by mexiletine reduces repetitive series of action potentials and therefore improves muscle stiffness in myotonic patients. The enhanced use-dependent block as seen with R1448H may explain the extraordinary therapeutic efficacy of mexiletine in most patients with paramyotonia congenita.

The quantification of myotonia: A problem in the evaluation of new antimyotonic drugs

The evaluation of an antimyotonic drug is often difficult since the severity of myotonia is itself hard to assess. The rise in arterial potassium level produced by the infusion of increasing concentrations of potassium chloride brought about reproducible changes in the excitability level of myotonic muscles proportional to the plasma potassium concentration. The excitability changes were assessed by three methods commonly used for evaluating antimyotonic drugs. The duration of the electromyographic relaxation time after maximal voluntary effort proved to be the only test which reliably assessed the variations of muscular excitability proportional to the increased plasma potassium. By contrast, the duration of percussion- or electrically-induced myotonic after-discharges was extremely variable and independent of plasma potassium.