Antiaromatic Molecules Research Articles

Bowl‐Shaped Anthracene‐Fused Antiaromatic Ni(II) Norcorrole: Synthesis, Structure, Assembly with C60, and Photothermal Conversion

The synthesis of bowl‐shaped antiaromatic molecules represents a formidable challenge, because the molecular distortion further destabilizes these already inherently reactive molecules. Here, we report the synthesis and properties of bowl‐shaped fused anthrylnorcorroles that exhibit near‐infrared (NIR) absorption reaching 1900 nm. The oxidation of meso‐anthryldibromodipyrrin provides fused anthryldibromodipyrrin, which was converted to the fused mono‐ and bisanthrylnorcorroles through Ni(0)‐mediated intramolecular coupling with a bis(dibromodipyrrin) Ni(II) complex. Single‐crystal X‐ray diffraction analyses revealed bowl‐shaped structures for the fused mono‐ and bisanthrylnorcorroles, which enables them to act as suitable receptors for C60 with bonding constants of 2.89 × 103 M–1 and 1.59 × 103 M–1, respectively. The formation of a 1:1 complex between the fused monoanthrylnorcorrole and C60 was confirmed by single‐crystal X‐ray diffraction analysis. The effective expansion of the π‐conjugation through the triple fusion of the norcorrole with the anthracene units substantially enhances the near‐infrared absorption bands, which endows these anthrylnorcorroles with effective photothermal conversion.

Bowl-Shaped Anthracene-Fused Antiaromatic Ni(II) Norcorrole: Synthesis, Structure, Assembly with C60, and Photothermal Conversion.

The synthesis of bowl-shaped antiaromatic molecules represents a formidable challenge, because the molecular distortion further destabilizes these already inherently reactive molecules. Here, we report the synthesis and properties of bowl-shaped fused anthrylnorcorroles that exhibit near-infrared (NIR) absorption reaching 1900 nm. The oxidation of meso-anthryldibromodipyrrin provides fused anthryldibromodipyrrin, which was converted to the fused mono- and bisanthrylnorcorroles through Ni(0)-mediated intramolecular coupling with a bis(dibromodipyrrin) Ni(II) complex. Single-crystal X-ray diffraction analyses revealed bowl-shaped structures for the fused mono- and bisanthrylnorcorroles, which enables them to act as suitable receptors for C60 with bonding constants of 2.89 × 103 M-1 and 1.59 × 103 M-1, respectively. The formation of a 1:1 complex between the fused monoanthrylnorcorrole and C60 was confirmed by single-crystal X-ray diffraction analysis. The effective expansion of the π-conjugation through the triple fusion of the norcorrole with the anthracene units substantially enhances the near-infrared absorption bands, which endows these anthrylnorcorroles with effective photothermal conversion.

Exploring Aromaticity Effects on Electronic Transport in Cyclo[n]carbon Single-Molecule Junctions.

Cyclo[n]carbon (Cn) is one member of the all-carbon allotrope family with potential applications in next-generation electronic devices. By employing first-principles quantum transport calculations, we have investigated the electronic transport properties of single-molecule junctions of Cn, with n = 14, 16, 18, and 20, connected to two bulk gold electrodes, uncovering notable distinctions arising from the varying aromaticities. For the doubly aromatic C14 and C18 molecules, slightly deformed complexes at the singlet state arise after bonding with one Au atom at each side; in contrast, the reduced energy gaps between the highest occupied and the lowest unoccupied molecular orbitals due to the orbital reordering observed in the doubly anti-aromatic C16 and C20 molecules lead to heavily deformed asymmetric complexes at the triplet state. Consequently, spin-unpolarized transmission functions are obtained for the Au-C14/18-Au junctions, while spin-polarized transmission appears in the Au-C16/20-Au junctions. Furthermore, the asymmetric in-plane π-type hybrid molecular orbitals of the Au-C16/20-Au junctions contribute to two broad but low transmission peaks far away from the Fermi level (Ef), while the out-of-plane π-type hybrid molecular orbitals dominate two sharp transmission peaks that are adjacent to Ef, thus resulting in much lower transmission coefficients at Ef compared to those of the Au-C14/18-Au junctions. Our findings are helpful for the design and application of future cyclo[n]carbon-based molecular electronic devices.

Computational comparison of paratropicity trends in antiaromatic s‐indacene derivatives: Does the functional “make all the difference”?

AbstractA recent publication by Wu and co‐workers demonstrated that the workhorse functional B3LYP tends to overemphasize the delocalization in antiaromatic molecules, leading to poor agreement between the calculated proton NMR values and the experimentally obtained numbers. Rather, they showed that the M11 functional affords the best agreement between theory and experiment. We have computationally re‐examined our previously published NICS‐XY scan data using M11‐determined geometries and find that, aside from the placement of s‐indacene, the antiaromaticity trends for both sets of data are essentially identical.

Close Stacking of Antiaromatic Ni(II) Norcorrole Originating from a Four-Electron Multicentered Bonding Interaction.

A π-conjugated molecule with one electronic spin often forms a π-stacked dimer through molecular orbital interactions between two unpaired electrons. The bonding is recognized as a multicentered two-electron interaction between the two π-conjugated molecules. Here, we disclose a multicentered bonding interaction between two antiaromatic molecules involving four electrons. We have synthesized an antiaromatic porphyrin analogue, Ni(II) bis(pentafluorophenyl)norcorrole. Its dimer adopts a face-to-face stacked structure with an extremely short stacking distance of 2.97 Å. The close stacking originates from a multicenter four-electron bonding interaction between the two molecules. The bonding electrons were experimentally observed via synchrotron X-ray diffraction analysis and corroborated by theoretical calculations. The intermolecular interaction of the molecular orbitals imparts the stacked dimer with aromatic character that is distinctly different from that of its monomer.

A Triply Linked Porphyrin-Norcorrole Hybrid with Singlet Diradical Character.

Norcorrole Ni(II) complexes have recently received considerable attention because they are readily accessible antiaromatic molecules. Their high stability under ambient conditions and ease of synthesis have enabled the exploration of the intrinsic properties of antiaromatic molecules. Here, we report the synthesis and properties of meso-meso singly linked porphyrin-norcorrole hybrids and a triply linked porphyrin-norcorrole hybrid. The singly linked and triply linked porphyrin-norcorrole hybrids were fully characterized, including an X-ray structural analysis. Due to their orthogonal conformation, the singly linked hybrids maintain the individual electronic properties of their porphyrin and norcorrole subunits, while the triply linked hybrid shows a significantly smaller electrochemical HOMO-LUMO gap (0.45 eV) than that of Ni(II) dimesitylnorcorrole (1.08 eV). Furthermore, the triply linked hybrid exhibits singlet diradical characteristics, as confirmed by VT NMR, ESR, and SQUID experiments.

A Triply Linked Porphyrin‐Norcorrole Hybrid with Singlet Diradical Character

AbstractNorcorrole Ni(II) complexes have recently received considerable attention because they are readily accessible antiaromatic molecules. Their high stability under ambient conditions and ease of synthesis have enabled the exploration of the intrinsic properties of antiaromatic molecules. Here, we report the synthesis and properties of meso–meso singly linked porphyrin‐norcorrole hybrids and a triply linked porphyrin‐norcorrole hybrid. The singly linked and triply linked porphyrin‐norcorrole hybrids were fully characterized, including an X‐ray structural analysis. Due to their orthogonal conformation, the singly linked hybrids maintain the individual electronic properties of their porphyrin and norcorrole subunits, while the triply linked hybrid shows a significantly smaller electrochemical HOMO–LUMO gap (0.45 eV) than that of Ni(II) dimesitylnorcorrole (1.08 eV). Furthermore, the triply linked hybrid exhibits singlet diradical characteristics, as confirmed by VT NMR, ESR, and SQUID experiments.

Antiaromatic Molecules as Magnetic Couplers: A Computational Quest.

In this study, we investigate a set of organic diradical structures in which two oxo-verdazyl radicals are selected as radical spin centers that are connected (coupled) via six coupler molecules (CM), resulting in various magnetic (ferromagnetic (FM) or antiferromagnetic (AFM)) characteristics, as reflected by their exchange coupling constants (J). We have designed 12 diradicals with 6-antiaromatic couplers coupled with bis-oxo-verdazyl diradicals with meta-meta (m-m) and para-meta (p-m) positional connectivities. The nature of the magnetic coupling (ferromagnetic, nonmagnetic, or antiferromagnetic) and the magnitude of the exchange constant J depend on the type of coupler, the connecting point between each radical center and CM, the degree of aromaticity of the coupler, and the length of the through-bond distance between radical centers. The computed magnetic exchange coupling constants J for these diradicals at the B3LYP/6-311++G(d,p) and MN12SX/6-311++G(d,p) levels of theory are large for many of these structures, indicating strong ferromagnetic coupling (with positive J values). In some cases, magnetic couplings are observed with J > 1000 cm-1 (B3LYP/6-311++G(d,p)) and strong antiferromagnetic coupling (with negative J values) with J < -1000 cm-1 (B3LYP/6-311++G(d,p)). Similarly, in some cases, magnetic couplings are observed with J > 289 cm-1 (MN12SX/6-311++G(d,p)) and strong antiferromagnetic coupling (with negative J values) with J < -568 cm-1 (MN12SX/6-311++G(d,p)). Furthermore, while numerous studies have reported that the degree of aromaticity of molecular couplers often favors strong ferromagnetic coupling, displaying the high-spin character of diradicals in their ground states, the couplers chosen in this study are characterized as antiaromatic or nonaromatic. The current investigation provides evidence that, remarkably, antiaromatic couplers are able to enhance stability by favoring electronic diradical structures with very strong ferromagnetic coupling when the length of the through-bond distance and connectivity pattern between radical centers are selected in such a way that the FM coupling is optimized. The findings in this study offer new strategies in the design of novel organic materials with interesting magnetic properties for practical applications.

Unraveling the enigma of Craig-type Möbius-aromatic osmium compounds.

Nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) chemical shifts and the magnetically induced current density (MICD) susceptibility of four osmium containing molecules have been calculated at the density functional theory (DFT) level using three relativistic levels of theory. The calculations were performed at the quasi-relativistic level using an effective core potential (ECP) for Os, at the all-electron scalar exact two-component (X2C) relativistic level, and at the relativistic X2C level including spin-orbit coupling (SO-X2C). In earlier studies, the osmapentalene (1) and the osmapentalynes (2 and 3) were considered Craig-type Möbius aromatic and it was suggested that the analogous osmium compound (4) is Craig-type Möbius antiaromatic. Here, the ring-current strengths were obtained with the gauge including magnetically induced currents (GIMIC) method by integrating the MICD susceptibility passing through planes that intersect chemical bonds and by line integration of the induced magnetic field using Ampère-Maxwell's law. The ring-current calculations suggest that 1, 2 and 3 are weakly aromatic and that 4 is nonaromatic. The accuracy of the MICD susceptibility was assessed by comparing calculated NMR chemical shifts to available experimental data. Visualization of the MICD susceptibility shows that the ring current does not pass from one side of the molecular plane to the other, which means that the MICD susceptibility of the studied molecules does not exhibit any Möbius topology as one would expect for Craig-type Möbius aromatic and for Craig-type Möbius antiaromatic molecules. Thus, molecules 1-3 are not Craig-type Möbius aromatic and molecule 4 is not Craig-type Möbius antiaromatic as previously suggested. Calculations of the 1H NMR and 13C NMR chemical shifts of atoms near the Os atom show the importance of including spin-orbit effects. Overall, our study revisits the understanding of the aromaticity of organometallic molecules containing transition metals.

The unprecedented strong paratropic ring current of a bis-PdII complex of 5,10,23-trimesityl [28]heptaphyrin(1.1.0.0.1.0.0).

Acid-catalyzed Friedel-Crafts-type cyclization of tetrapyrrolic BF2 complex 1 and α,α'-dibromotripyrrin 2 gave 5,10,23-trimesityl [28]heptaphyrin(1.1.0.0.1.0.0) BF2 complex 3BF2 as a stable and moderate antiaromatic macrocycle. Demetalation of 3BF2 with methanesulfonic acid followed by treatment with HCl gave free-base salt 3HCl that holds a chloride anion at the core. This salt displays a planar structure with an inverted pyrrole and a stronger paratropic ring current. Metalation of neutral free-base 3 with PdCl2 gave bis-PdII complex 3Pd2 as a stable antiaromatic molecule. The 1H NMR spectrum of 3Pd2 displays signals due to pyrrolic β-protons in the range of -1.06 ∼ -1.90 ppm, indicating the unprecedented strong paratropic ring current.

Theoretical insight into the doubly antiaromatic carbon allotrope cyclo[16]carbon.

A new carbon allotrope, cyclo[16]carbon (C16), has recently been successfully synthesized. It is hypothesized to exhibit double antiaromatic properties owing to the 4n π electrons. Theoretical calculations are a feasible method for systematically studying the structures and properties of unstable antiaromatic molecules. The results show that C16 has a planar structure characterized by alternating long and short bonds with D8h, and a strong antiaromatic characteristic originates from the two perpendicular π systems. We performed an extensive comparative analysis of C16 and the aromatic cyclo[18]carbon, C18. This study offers valuable insight into the structural and electronic characteristics of C16 and could inspire innovative applications and avenues for its utilization in various fields.

Interaction strength in molecular junctions consisting of π-stacked antiaromatic molecules

The interaction force was measured as the adhesive force acting between norcorrole molecules anchored to the probe surface and the sample surface. This study reveals substantial interactions in π-stacked antiaromatics at the single-molecule scale.

Porphene and porphite as porphyrin analogs of graphene and graphite

Two-dimensional materials have unusual properties and promise applications in nanoelectronics, spintronics, photonics, (electro)catalysis, separations, and elsewhere. Most are inorganic and their properties are difficult to tune. Here we report the preparation of Zn porphene, a member of the previously only hypothetical organic metalloporphene family. Similar to graphene, these also are fully conjugated two-dimensional polymers, but are composed of fused metalloporphyrin rings. Zn porphene is synthesized on water surface by two-dimensional oxidative polymerization of a Langmuir layer of Zn porphyrin with K2IrCl6, reminiscent of known one-dimensional polymerization of pyrroles. It is transferable to other substrates and bridges μm-sized pits. Contrary to previous theoretical predictions of metallic conductivity, it is a p-type semiconductor due to a predicted Peierls distortion of its unit cell from square to rectangular, analogous to the appearance of bond-length alternation in antiaromatic molecules. The observed reversible insertion of various metal ions, possibly carrying a fifth or sixth ligand, promises tunability and even patterning of circuits on an atomic canvas without removing any π centers from conjugation.

Synthesis and Characterization of Dibenzothieno[a,f]pentalenes Enabling Large Antiaromaticity and Moderate Open-Shell Character through a Small Energy Barrier for Bond-Shift Valence Tautomerization.

Experimental and theoretical rationalization of bond-shift valence tautomerization, characterized by double-well potential surfaces, is one of the most challenging topics of study among the rich electronic properties of antiaromatic molecules. Although the pseudo-Jahn-Teller effect (PJTE) is an essential effect to provide attractive characteristics of 4nπ systems, an understanding of the structure-property relationship derived from the PJTE for planar 4nπ electron systems is still in its infancy. Herein, we describe the synthesis and characterization of two regioisomers of the thiophene-fused diareno[a,f]pentalenes 6 and 7. The magnetic and optoelectronic properties characterize these sulfur-doped diareno[a,f]pentalenes as open-shell antiaromatic molecules, in sharp contrast to the closed-shell antiaromatic systems of 3 and 5, in which these main cores consist of the same number of π electrons as 6 and 7. Notably, thiophene-fused 6b and 7b showed pronounced antiaromaticity, the strongest among the previous systems, as well as moderate open-shell characteristics. Our experimental and theoretical investigations concluded that these properties of 6b and 7b are derived from the small energy barrier Ea‡ for the bond-shift valence tautomerization. The energy profile of the single crystal of 6b showed the temperature-dependent structural variations assigned to the dynamic mutual exchange between the two Cs-symmetric structures, which was also supported by changes in the chemical shifts of variable-temperature 1H NMR spectra in the solution phase. Both experimental and computational results revealed the importance of introducing heteroaromatic rings into 4nπ systems for controlling the PJTE and manifesting the antiaromatic and open-shell natures originating from the high-symmetric structure. The findings of this study advance the understanding of antiaromaticity characterized by the PJTE by controlling the energy barrier for bond-shift valence tautomerizations, potentially leading to the rational design of optoelectronic devices based on novel antiaromatic molecules possessing the strong contributions of their high-symmetric geometries.

Xanthene-Separated 24 π-Electron Antiaromatic Rosarin Dimer.

Antiaromatic molecules have recently received attention because of their intrinsic properties, such as high reactivity and their narrow HOMO-LUMO gaps. Stacking of antiaromatic molecules has been predicted to induce three-dimensional aromaticity via frontier orbital interactions. Here, we report a covalently linked π-π stacked rosarin dimer that has been examined experimentally by steady-state absorption and transient absorption measurements and theoretically by quantum chemical calculations, including time-dependent density functional theory, anisotropy of induced current density, and nucleus-independent chemical shift calculations. Relative to the corresponding monomer, the dimer exhibits diminished antiaromaticity upon lowering the temperature to 77 K, a finding ascribed to intramolecular interactions between the macrocyclic rosarin subunits.

Frontier Orbital Views of Stacked Aromaticity.

Recent studies have theoretically and experimentally demonstrated that antiaromatic molecules with 4n π electrons exhibit stacked aromaticity according to π-π stacking when arranged in a face-to-face manner. However, the mechanism of its occurrence has not been clearly studied. In this study, we investigated the mechanism of stacked aromaticity using cyclobutadiene. When the antiaromatic molecules are stacked in a face-to-face manner, the orbital interactions between the degenerate singly occupied molecular orbitals (SOMOs) of the monomer unit cause a larger energy gap between the degenerate highest-occupied molecular orbitals (HOMOs) and the lowest-unoccupied molecular orbitals (LUMOs) of the dimer. However, the antiaromatic molecules are more stable in less symmetric conformations, mainly because of pseudo-Jahn-Teller distortions. In the case of cyclobutadiene, the two SOMOs of the monomer unit split into HOMO and LUMO because of the bond alternation. When the molecules are stacked in a face-to-face manner, the HOMO-LUMO gap of the dimer is smaller than that of the monomer due to the interactions between the HOMOs and LUMOs of the two monomer units. When the monomer units are within a specific distance of each other, the HOMO and LUMO of the dimer, which correspond to antibonding and bonding between the units, respectively, are interchanged. This alternation of molecular orbitals may result in an increase in the bond strength between the monomer units, exhibiting stacked aromaticity. We demonstrated that it is possible to control the distance exhibited by stacked aromaticity by engineering the HOMO-LUMO gap of the monomer units.

Cover Feature: How Different are the Diamagnetic and Paramagnetic Contributions to Off‐Nucleus Shielding in Aromatic and Antiaromatic Rings? (ChemPhysChem 9/2023)

The Cover Feature shows how the change in the balance between the diamagnetic and paramagnetic contributions to shielding in benzene and cyclobutadiene leads to overall shielding distributions characteristic of aromatic and antiaromatic molecules, respectively. More information can be found in the Research Article by Peter B. Karadakov.

Quadripartite bond length rule applied to two prototypical aromatic and antiaromatic molecules

ContextIn 2000, a remarkably simple relationship was introduced, which connected the calculated geometries of isomolecular states of three different multiplicities. These encompass a ground single state, the first excited triplet state, as well as related radical anion and radical cation. The rule allows the prediction of the geometry of one of the species if the three remaining ones are known. Here, we verify the applicability of this bond length rule for two small planar cyclic organic molecules, i.e., benzene and cyclobutadiene, which stand as prototypical examples of, respectively, aromatic and antiaromatic systems. We see that the rule works fairly well to benzene, and it works independently for quinoid as well as for anti-quinoid minima, despite the fact that radical anion species poses challenges for correct theoretical description.MethodsTo obtain chosen electronic state equilibrium geometries, three types of computational approaches were utilized: fast and efficient density functional theory DFT, the coupled cluster method CC2, the complete active space self-consistent field (CASSCF) approach, and the most accurate but also resource-consuming perturbation theory with multireference wavefunction (CASPT2) with a default value and without IPEA-shift. Dunning and co-workers correlation-consistent basis sets (aug-)cc-pVXZ (X = D, T, Q) were employed. Gaussian 16 revision A.03, Turbomole 7.1, and Molcas 8.0 computational software were used.

How Different are the Diamagnetic and Paramagnetic Contributions to Off-Nucleus Shielding in Aromatic and Antiaromatic Rings?

The spatial variations in the diamagnetic and paramagnetic contributions to the off-nucleus isotropic shielding, , and to the zz component of the off-nucleus shielding tensor, , around benzene (C6 H6 ) and cyclobutadiene (C4 H4 ) are investigated using complete-active-space self-consistent field wavefunctions. Despite the substantial differences between and around the aromatic C6 H6 and the antiaromatic C4 H4 , the diamagnetic and paramagnetic contributions to these quantities, and , and and , are found to behave similarly in the two molecules, shielding and deshielding, respectively, each ring and its surroundings. The different signs of the most popular aromaticity criterion, the nucleus-independent chemical shift (NICS), in C6 H6 and C4 H4 are shown to follow from a change in the balance between the respective diamagnetic and paramagnetic contributions. Thus, the different NICS values for antiaromatic and antiaromatic molecules cannot be attributed to differences in the ease of access to excited states only; differences in the electron density, which determines the overall bonding picture, also play an important role.

All are aromatic: A 3D globally aromatic cage containing five types of 2D aromatic macrocycles

All are aromatic: A 3D globally aromatic cage containing five types of 2D aromatic macrocycles