Bianchi's permutability theorem, can be stated under the following form.' Let two W-congruences have one focal sheet in common, let the other focal sheets be respectively S' and S, then there are oo 'surfaces which are together with S' and S the focal sheets of two other W-congruences. The conviction that it is possible to state a converse of Bianchi's permutability theorem, has led G. Fubini,2 to consider this problem in a paper in the Annals of Mathematics, but without giving it a complete solution. Because of the role played by this theorem in metric and projective differential geometry, and in Fubini's theory of stratifiable-congruences of lines, a complete proof of the converse of this theorem, should be of interest. The converse of Bianchi's permutability theorem, which we prove here, can be stated as follows: If co' surfaces M' are congruence-transforms of two surfaces Mo and M2, all the congruences (M'Mo) and (M'M2) are W-congruences. For proving this theorem, we shall use Cartan's3 method of the moving reference system. Let the coordinates of the four points Mi(i = 0, 1, 2, 3) be functions of two parameters u, v, which generate, as u, v, vary, four surfaces, such that the surfaces Mo and M2 are congruence-transforms2 of the surfaces Ml and M3. Then the tangent planes to the surfaces Mi(i = 0, 2) and M,(p = 1, 3) pass respectively through Ml, M3 and Mo, M2. As a moving reference system, we consider the tetrahedron depending on the parameters u, v and formed by the points Mo, 1112 and by two arbitrary points of the M' i. e Ml and M3. Therefore Mj = Ml + pjM3. Consequently3 we have:
Read full abstract