Andreev Bound States Research Articles

Probing the minigap in topological insulator-based Josephson junctions under radio frequency irradiation**Project supported by the National Basic Research Program of China (Grant Nos. 2016YFA0300601, 2017YFA0304700, and 2015CB921402), the National Natural Science Foundation China (Grant Nos. 11527806, 91221203, 11174357, 91421303, and 11774405), and the Strategic Priority Research Program B of the Chinese Academy of Sciences (Grant Nos. XDB07010100 and XDB28000000), and

Recently, a contact-resistance-measurement method was developed to detect the minigap, hence the Andreev bound states (ABSs), in Josephson junctions constructed on the surface of three-dimensional topological insulators (3D TIs). In this work, we further generalize that method to the circumstance with radio frequency (rf) irradiation. We find that with the increase of the rf power, the measured minigap becomes broadened and extends to higher energies in a way similar to the rf power dependence of the outer border of the Shapiro step region. We show that the corresponding data of contact resistance under rf irradiation can be well interpreted by using the resistively shunted Josephson junction (RSJ) model and the Blonder–Tinkham–Klapwijk (BTK) theory. Our findings could be useful when using the contact-resistance-measurement method to study the Majorana-related physics in topological insulator-based Josephson junctions under rf irradiation.

Robust low-energy Andreev bound states in semiconductor-superconductor structures: Importance of partial separation of component Majorana bound states

Robust topologically trivial low-energy Andreev bound states (ABSs) induced by position-dependent effective potentials have recently come under renewed focus, in light of a remarkable set of experiments observing robust quantized zero-bias conductance plateaus in semiconductor-superconductor heterostructures. We show that (1) the partial spatial separation of the wave functions of the component Majorana bound states (MBSs) is crucial for the creation and stability of topologically trivial near-zero-energy Andreev bound states, (2) the signs of the spin polarizations of the component MBSs can be either the same or opposite, depending on the profile of the inducing potential, and (3) the spin polarizations do not play a fundamental role in generating vastly different coupling strengths to local probes and/or ensuring the robustness of the near-zero-energy ABS. Consequently, in contrast to recent theoretical claims (Vuik et al., arXiv:1806.02801), we find that a robust, quantized zero-bias conductance plateau of height 2e^2/h measured in the topologically trivial regime necessarily requires partially separated ABSs (ps-ABSs), independent of the relative signs of the spin-polarizations. In addition, we show that (4) well-defined energy splitting oscillations involve MBSs characterized by exponential tails pointing toward each other, and (5) ps-ABSs generated by the tunnel barrier itself produce zero-bias conductance peaks with a characteristic width that increases strongly with the applied magnetic field. Finally, we propose (6) a quantitative scheme for analyzing the stability of Majorana modes based on probability distributions of splitting susceptibilities and show that a ps-ABS mode can be remarkably robust when judged based on its signature in a charge tunneling experiment, but, in essence, is topologically unprotected.

Fractional Skyrmion and Absence of Low-lying Andreev Bound States in a Micro Fractional-flux Quantum Vortex

We investigate quasi-particle excitation modes and the topological number of a fractional-flux quantum vortex in a layered (multi-component) superconductor. The Bogoliubov equation for a half-flux quantum vortex is solved to show that there is no low-lying Andreev bound state near zero energy in the core of a quantum vortex, which is surprisingly in contrast to the result for an inter-flux vortex. Related to this result, there are singular excitation modes that have opposite angular momenta, moving in the opposite direction around the core of the vortex. The topological index (skyrmion number) for a fractional-flux quantum vortex becomes fractional since the topological index is divided into two parts where one from the vortex (bulk) and the other from the kink (domain wall, boundary). The topological numbers for both the vortex and the kink (domain wall) are fractional, and their sum becomes an integer. This shows an interesting analogy between this result and the index theorem for manifolds with boundary. We argue that fractional-flux quantum vortices are not commutative each other and follow non-abelian statistics. This non-abelian statistics of vortices is different from that in p-wave superconductors.

Magnetoelectrically tunable Andreev bound state spectra and spin polarization in p -wave Josephson junctions

We demonstrate how the boundary-driven reconstruction of the superconducting order parameter can be employed to manipulate the zero-energy Majorana bound states (MBSs) occurring in a topological Josephson junction. We focus on an interface of two p-wave superconductors, which are described by a spin-vector order parameter $\bf{d}$. Apart from the sensitivity of $\bf{d}$ to external Zeeman/exchange fields, here, we show that the orientation of $\bf{d}$ throughout the junction can be controlled by electrically gating the weak link. The remarkable local character of this knob is a manifestation of the edge reconstruction of the order parameter, which takes place whenever different $\bf{d}$-vector configurations in each superconductor compete and are close in energy. As a consequence, the spin-dependent superconducting-phase difference across the junction is switchable from $0$ to $\pi$. Moreover, in the regime where multiple edge MBSs occur for each superconductor, the Andreev-bound-state (ABS) spectra can be twisted by the application of either a charge- or spin-phase difference across the interface, and give rise to a rich diversity of nonstandard ABS dispersions. Interestingly, some of these dispersions show band crossings protected by fermion parity, despite their $2\pi$-periodic character. These crossings additionally unlock the possibility of nontrivial topology in synthetic spaces, when considering networks of such 1D junctions. Lastly, the interface MBSs induce a distinct elecronic spin polarization near the junction, which possesses a characteristic spatial pattern that allows the detection of MBSs using spin-polarized scanning tunneling microscopy. These findings unveil novel paths to mechanisms for ABS engineering and single-out signatures relevant for the experimental detection and manipulation of MBSs.

Synthetic Weyl Points and Chiral Anomaly in Majorana Devices with Nonstandard Andreev-Bound-State Spectra.

We demonstrate how to design various nonstandard types of Andreev-bound-state (ABS) dispersions, via a composite construction relying on Majorana bound states (MBSs). Here, the MBSs appear at the interface of a Josephson junction consisting of two topological superconductors (TSCs). Each TSC harbors multiple MBSs per edge by virtue of a chiral or unitary symmetry. We find that, while the ABS dispersions are 2π periodic, they still contain multiple crossings which are protected by the conservation of fermion parity. A single junction with four interface MBSs and all MBS couplings fully controllable, or networks of such coupled junctions with partial coupling tunability, open the door for topological band structures with Weyl points or nodes in synthetic dimensions, which in turn allow for fermion-parity (FP) pumping with a cycle set by the ABS-dispersion details. In fact, in the case of nodes, the FP pumping is a manifestation of chiral anomaly in 2D synthetic spacetime. The possible experimental demonstration of ABS engineering in these devices further promises to unveil new paths for the detection of MBSs and higher-dimensional chiral anomaly.

Classifying Induced Superconductivity in Atomically Thin Dirac-Cone Materials

Recently, Kayyalha et al. (Phys. Rev. Lett., 2019, 122, 047003) reported on the anomalous enhancement of the self-field critical currents (Ic (sf, T)) at low temperatures in Nb/BiSbTeSe2-nanoribbon/Nb Josephson junctions. The enhancement was attributed to the low-energy Andreev-bound states arising from the winding of the electronic wave function around the circumference of the topological insulator BiSbTeSe2 nanoribbon. It should be noted that identical enhancement in Ic (sf, T) and in the upper critical field (Bc2 (T)) in approximately the same reduced temperatures, were reported by several research groups in atomically thin junctions based on a variety of Dirac-cone materials (DCM) earlier. The analysis shows that in all these S/DCM/S systems, the enhancement is due to a new superconducting band opening. Taking into account that several intrinsic superconductors also exhibit the effect of new superconducting band(s) opening when sample thickness becomes thinner than the out-of-plane coherence length (c (0)), we reaffirm our previous proposal that there is a new phenomenon of additional superconducting band(s) opening in atomically thin films.

Analytical solution of the finite-length Kitaev chain coupled to a quantum dot

We solve analytically the problem of a finite length Kitaev chain coupled to a quantum dot (QD), which extends the standard Kitaev chain problem making it more closely related to the quantum dot-semiconductor-superconductor (QD-SM-SC) nanowire heterostructure that is currently under intense investigation for possible occurrence of Majorana zero modes (MZMs). Our analytical solution reveals the emergence of a robust Andreev bound state (ABSs) localized in the quantum dot region as the generic lowest energy solution in the topologically trivial phase. By contrast, in the bare Kitaev chain problem such a solution does not exist. The robustness of the ABS in the topologically trivial phase is due to a partial decoupling of the component Majorana bound states (MBSs) over the length of the dot potential. As a result, the signatures of the ABS in measurements that couple locally to the quantum dot, e.g., tunneling measurements, are identical to the signatures of topologically-protected MZMs, which arise only in the topological superconducting (TS) phase of the Kitaev chain.

Anomalous Low-Temperature Enhancement of Supercurrent in Topological-Insulator Nanoribbon Josephson Junctions: Evidence for Low-Energy Andreev Bound States.

We report anomalous enhancement of the critical current at low temperatures in gate-tunable Josephson junctions made from topological insulator BiSbTeSe_{2} nanoribbons with superconducting Nb electrodes. In contrast to conventional junctions, as a function of the decreasing temperature T, the increasing critical current I_{c} exhibits a sharp upturn at a temperature T_{*} around 20% of the junction critical temperature for several different samples and various gate voltages. The I_{c} vs T demonstrates a short junction behavior for T>T_{*}, but crosses over to a long junction behavior for T<T_{*} with an exponential T dependence I_{c}∝exp(-k_{B}T/δ), where k_{B} is the Boltzmann constant. The extracted characteristic energy scale δ is found to be an order of magnitude smaller than the induced superconducting gap of the junction. We attribute the long-junction behavior with such a small δ to low-energy Andreev bound states arising from winding of the electronic wave function around the circumference of the topological insulator nanoribbon.

Andreev bound states in a few-electron quantum dot coupled to superconductors

A direct measurement of the density of Andreev bound states (ABSs) is experimentally investigated in a superconductor--quantum dot--superconductor hybrid nanowire system. A hard proximity-induced superconducting gap is observed, arising from superconducting correlations, in the transport spectrum of the hybrid system. Conductance peaks observed inside the superconducting gap reveal that the subgap states participate in the transport of the hybrid junction. We explore the evolution of low-energy Andreev bound states in a few-electron quantum dot (QD) coupled to superconductors, by probing the magnetic field dependence of exquisite detailed conductance spectra with a small bias voltage applied on the superconducting lead. In the presence of low magnetic fields, the resonance current is enhanced and broadened, attributed to the transport through Andreev bound states in QD, as the energy of ABSs reaches the threshold set by the applied bias voltage with the increase of the magnetic field. The simulated transport spectrum matches the experimentally observed evolution patterns of conductance, further implying the superconducting correlation nature of the observed electron transport. At high magnetic fields, the conductance maxes as the Fermi level reaches the degeneration point of Landau levels, leading to conductance peaks shown in the alternating narrow and wide patterns of Coulomb blockade oscillations.

Lifetime of Majorana qubits in Rashba nanowires with nonuniform chemical potential

We study the lifetime of topological qubits based on Majorana bound states hosted in a one-dimensional Rashba nanowire (NW) with proximity-induced superconductivity and non-uniform chemical potential needed for manipulation and read-out. If nearby gates tune the chemical potential locally so that part of the NW is in the trivial phase, Andreev bound states (ABSs) can emerge which are localized at the interface between topological and trivial phases with energies significantly less than the gap. The emergence of such subgap states strongly decreases the Majorana qubit lifetime at finite temperatures due to local perturbations that can excite the system into these ABSs. Using Keldysh formalism, we study such excitations caused by fluctuating charges in capacitively coupled gates and calculate the corresponding Majorana lifetimes due to thermal noise, which are shown to be much shorter than those in NWs with uniform chemical potential.

Protected gap closing in Josephson junctions constructed on Bi2Te3 surface

On the road of searching for Majorana zero modes (MZMs) in topological insulator-based Josephson junctions, a highly sought signature is the protected full transparency of electron transport through the junctions due to the existence of the MZMs, associated with complete gap closing between the electronlike and holelike Andreev bound states (ABSs). Here we present direct experimental evidence of gap closing and full transparency in single Josephson junctions constructed on the surface of three-dimensional topological insulator (3D TI) ${\mathrm{Bi}}_{2}{\mathrm{Te}}_{3}$. Our results demonstrate that the two-dimensional (2D) surface of 3D TIs provides a promising platform for hosting and manipulating MZMs.

Multifaceted properties of Andreev bound states: interplay of symmetry and topology.

Andreev bound states (ABSs) ubiquitously emerge as a consequence of non-trivial topological structures of the order parameter of superfluids and superconductors and significantly contribute to thermodynamics and low-energy quantum transport phenomena. We here share the current status of our knowledge on their multifaceted properties such as Majorana fermions and odd-frequency pairing. A unified concept behind ABSs originates from a soliton state in the one-dimensional Dirac equation with mass domain wall and interplay of ABSs with symmetry and topology enrich their physical characteristics. We make an overview of ABSs with a special focus on superfluid 3He. The quantum liquid confined to restricted geometries serves as a rich repository of noteworthy quantum phenomena, such as the mass acquisition of Majorana fermions driven by spontaneous symmetry breaking, topological quantum criticality, Weyl superfluidity and the anomalous magnetic response. The marriage of the superfluid 3He and nano-fabrication techniques will take one to a new horizon of topological quantum phenomena associated with ABSs.This article is part of the theme issue 'Andreev bound states'.

Nonlocal supercurrent of quartets in a three-terminal Josephson junction

A novel nonlocal supercurrent, carried by quartets, each consisting of four electrons, is expected to appear in a voltage-biased three-terminal Josephson junction. This supercurrent results from a nonlocal Andreev bound state (ABS), formed among three superconducting terminals. While in a two-terminal Josephson junction the usual ABS, and thus the dc Josephson current, exists only in equilibrium, the ABS, which gives rise to the quartet supercurrent, persists in the nonlinear regime. In this work, we report such resonance in a highly coherent three-terminal Josephson junction made in an InAs nanowire in proximity to an aluminum superconductor. In addition to nonlocal conductance measurements, cross-correlation measurements of current fluctuations provided a distinctive signature of the quartet supercurrent. Multiple device geometries had been tested, allowing us to rule out competing mechanisms and to establish the underlying microscopic origin of this coherent nondissipative current.

Andreev tunneling and Josephson current in light irradiated graphene

We investigate the Andreev tunneling and Josephson current in graphene irradiated with high-frequency linearly polarized light. The corresponding stroboscopic dynamics can be solved using Floquet mechanism which results in an effective stationary theory to the problem exhibiting an anisotropic Dirac spectrum and modified pseudospin-momentum locking. When applied to an irradiated normal graphene - superconductor (NS) interface, such analysis reveal Andreev reflection (AR) to become an oscillatory function of the optical strength. Specifically we find that, by varying the polarization direction we can both suppress AR considerably or cause the Andreev transport to remain maximum at sub-gap excitation energies even in the presence of Fermi level mismatch. Furthermore, we study the optical effect on the Andreev bound states (ABS) within a short normal-graphene sheet, sandwiched between two s-wave superconductors. It shows redistribution of the low energy regime in the ABS spectrum, which in turn, has major effect in shaping the Josephson super-current. Subjected to efficient tuning, such current can be sufficiently altered even at the charge neutrality point. Our observations provide useful feedback in regulating the quantum transport in Dirac-like systems, achieved via controlled off-resonant optical irradiation on them.

Distinguishing Majorana bound states from localized Andreev bound states by interferometry

Experimental evidence for Majorana bound states (MBSs) is so far mainly based on the robustness of a zero-bias conductance peak. However, similar features can also arise due to Andreev bound states (ABSs) localized at the end of an island. We show that these two scenarios can be distinguished by an interferometry experiment based on embedding a Coulomb-blockaded island into an Aharonov-Bohm ring. For two ABSs, when the ground state is nearly degenerate, cotunneling can change the state of the island and interference is suppressed. By contrast, for two MBSs the ground state is nondegenerate and cotunneling has to preserve the island state, which leads to $h / e$-periodic conductance oscillations with magnetic flux. Such interference setups can be realized with semiconducting nanowires or two-dimensional electron gases with proximity-induced superconductivity and may also be a useful spectroscopic tool for parity-flip mechanisms.

Two-terminal charge tunneling: Disentangling Majorana zero modes from partially separated Andreev bound states in semiconductor-superconductor heterostructures

We demonstrate that partially overlapping Majorana bound states (MBSs) represent a generic low-energy feature that emerges in non-homogeneous semiconductor nanowires coupled to superconductors in the presence of a Zeeman field. The emergence of these low-energy modes is not correlated with any topological quantum phase transition that the system may undergo as the Zeeman field and other control parameters are varied. Increasing the characteristic length scale of the variations in the potential leads to a continuous evolution from strongly overlapping MBSs, which can be viewed as "regular" Andreev bound states (ABSs) that cross zero energy, to well separated weakly overlapping MBSs, which have nearly zero energy in a significant range of parameters and generate signatures similar to the non-degenerate zero-energy Majorana zero modes (MZMs) that emerge in the topological superconducting phase. We show that using charge (or spin) transport measurements it is virtually impossible to distinguish MZMs from weakly overlapping MBSs emerging in the topologically-trivial regime.

Tunable hybridization of Majorana bound states at the quantum spin Hall edge

Confinement at the helical edge of a topological insulator is possible in the presence of proximity-induced magnetic (F) or superconducting (S) order. The interplay of both phenomena leads to the formation of localized Majorana bound states (MBS) or likewise (under certain resonance conditions) the formation of ordinary Andreev bound states (ABS). We investigate the properties of bound states in junctions composed of alternating regions of F or S barriers. Interestingly, the direction of magnetization in F regions and the relative superconducting phase between S regions can be exploited to hybridize MBS or ABS at will. We show that the local properties of MBS translate into a particular nonlocal superconducting pairing amplitude. Remarkably, the symmetry of the pairing amplitude contains information about the nature of the bound state that it stems from. Hence, this symmetry can in principle be used to distinguish MBS from ABS, owing to the strong connection between local density of states and nonlocal pairing in our setup.

Josephson current through a quantum dot molecule with a Majorana zero mode and Andreev bound states

Based on the Green's function method, we investigate the interplay between Majorana zero mode (MZM) and Andreev bound states (ABSs) in a quantum dot molecule side coupled to a topological superconducting nanowire with a pair of MZMs forming a Josephson junction. Since the strong electron–hole asymmetry induced by the nanowire with a topologically non-trivial phase, the MZM suppress the ABSs. The suppression induced by the MZM is robust against the Coulomb repulsion. The interplay between the MZM and the ABSs in Josephson junction presents a feasible experimental means for distinguish between the presence of MZM and ABSs.

Imaging the paramagnetic nonlinear Meissner effect in nodal gap superconductors

Boundary surfaces of nodal gap superconductors can host Andreev bound states (ABS) which develop a paramagnetic response under external RF field in contrast to the bulk diamagnetic response of the bulk superconductor. At low temperature this surface paramagnetic response dominates and enhances the nonlinear RF response of the sample. With a recently developed photoresponse imaging technique, the anisotropy of this "paramagnetic" nonlinear Meissner response, and its current direction (angular) and RF power dependence has been systematically studied. A theoretical model describing the current flow in the surface paramagnetic Andreev bound state, the bulk diamagnetic Meissner state, and their response to optical illumination is proposed and it shows good agreement with the experimental results.

Probing electron-hole components of subgap states in Coulomb blockaded Majorana islands

Recent tunneling spectroscopy experiments in semiconducting nanowires with proximity-induced superconductivity have reported robust zero-bias conductance peaks. Such a feature can be compatible with the existence of topological Majorana bound states (MBSs) and with a trivial Andreev bound state (ABS) near zero energy. Here, we argue that additional information, that can distinguish between the two cases, can be extracted from Coulomb-blockade experiments of Majorana islands. The key is the ratio of peak heights of consecutive conductance peaks give information about the electron and hole components of the lowest-energy subgap state. In the MBS case, this ratio goes to one half for long wires, while for short wires with finite MBS overlap it oscillates a function of Zeeman energy with the same period as the MBS energy splitting. We explain how the additional information might help to distinguish a trivial ABS at zero energy from a true MBS and show case examples.