To the End of the Earth: A History of the Crypto-Jews of New by Stanley M. Hordes. New York: Columbia University Press, 2005. 348 pp. $39.50. According this publication, a substantial number of secret or crypto-Jews who fled the Inquisition were among the Catholic founders of today's New Mexican Hispano community. book's first two chapters reflect the author's doctoral research on the well documented settlement of Portuguese crypto-Jews in colonial Old But the balance of the book is a procrustean effort identify Old Mexico's indisputably Portuguese crypto-Jews as modern New Mexico's indisputably founding fathers. In this way Stanley M. Hordes attempts justify his own well documented history of misrepresenting the region's modern, and largely Protestant, folkways, as colonial and crypto-Jewish. Hordes' claims were disconfirmed in my article in Jewish Folklore and Ethnology Review in 1996 and thus remain noteworthy for their ongoing popularity, rather than their scholarly accuracy. To a significant extent, local Hispano acceptance reflects the traditional mode of asserting overvalued, white ancestral descent in the multiracial Spanish-Americas, where, as Raphael Patai wrote in his article The Jewish Indians of Mexico, Spanish [white] descent, even Jewish descent, means a step up on the social scale. At the same time, widespread Jewish acceptance seems reflect a beleaguered peoples' need believe itself indomitable, as evidenced by a miraculous survival. However, despite acceptance at the popular level, it is ultimately Hordes who must go to the end of the earth defend a thesis that scholarship can only refute. Not surprisingly, he does it the only way it can be done: by abandoning scholarly method and relying, instead, on serious violations of scholarship norms. For example, Hordes introduces me his readers as Folklorist Judith Neulander, who has dismissed any presence in New either historical or contemporary . (p. 221). He thus misrepresents my disconfirmation of 1996, as well as my doctoral dissertation, both of which are cited in the book, and both of which clearly state: have consciously avoided suggesting that a presence never existed in New Mexico, not mention insist only that the canon is no evidence of that presence [I keep] an open mind on the possibility of cultural variation, and that would include crypto-Judaism in New Mexico. My position could not be clearer. Yet, in every reference my work, Hordes makes no attempt provide better scholarship. Rather, as in the example above, he responds scholarly argument the only way he can: by voicing righteous indignation at irrational positions that I have never taken. As always, Hordes' primary research strategy is over-generalization of superficially related cultural items. In this new book he resurrects an ancient Roman gambling top (in global Hispanic use), which he earlier claimed was a variant of the Hanukkah dreydl. Long before he made this claim, however, it was refuted by scholars whose work he never consulted; the dreydl is a Yiddish toy that appeared much later, borrowed from a pagan tradition in England and Germany, which was never used by Iberian Jews. In response this criticism, Hordes has revised the claim, now citing the toy as crypto-Jewish in that it was (purportedly) used by Hispanos celebrate Hanukkah when they first learned of the Ashkenazi custom. For support, he cites a colleague who eagerly provides it (unless Hordes misrepresents him, as well) by defining bricolage incorrectly, sweeping it into the same category as cultural borrowing: Kunin believed the toy may well exemplify the anthropological concept of bricolage, or the borrowing by one culture of elements from others. …
Read full abstract