Frame Analysis Research Articles

The view from ‘My Pitch’: Homeless voices in The Big Issue during the cost-of-living crisis

This paper presents a framing analysis of 12 editions of The Big Issue published in the last 3 months of 2023. The study employs framing analysis to investigate the language used by the magazine to report on poverty and homelessness. The paper analyses the ‘My Pitch’ column which represents the voice of the often-homeless vendors who sell the magazine. Using Entman’s approach to framing we analyse how individuals with lived experience of poverty and homelessness define the causes and solutions to poverty and homelessness. Furthermore, the paper offers a critical examination of the claims of the magazine to provide a platform for marginalised voices. We find that the magazine offers a platform for people with lived experience of poverty and/or homelessness to have their voices heard, although the My Pitch column offers limited space to inform the magazine’s readers of the wider context of homelessness. It also reinforces social enterprise solutions to poverty and homelessness. This framing avoids discussing shortfalls in the UK welfare system although the narrative logic of these profiles offers latent evidence of welfare dysfunction.

Five Models Used in Contrastive Semantics: A Comprehensive Synthesis and Analysis

The present study aims to assess and contrast five different approaches in the field of contrastive semantics: natural semantic metalanguage (NSM), conceptual metaphor theory (CMT), frame semantics (FC), semantic field theory (SFT), and cognitive grammar (CG). The research is set to review the available literature on the described techniques in order to focus on their distinguishing characteristics, practical applications, and illustrative samples. The findings reveal that these five models do play an insightful role when it comes to analyzing and comparing synonymous and semantically related profiles across distinct languages. Relations of semantic elements are the core concern of NSM while CMT investigates the internal schemata of the mind. As opposed to cognitive frame analysis, where knowledge structures are the central object of study, in SFT are language units grouped according to their meaning, while CG sees no separation of grammatical and meaning structures. This paper expounds on how these frameworks fill the gaps left by each of them and offers a broader understanding of the ways words encode meaning and how speakers of different cultures think about the world. Moreover, this study augments the knowledge regarding the variations of languages and gives an understanding of how languages relate to cognition, culture, and how people think about the world through words.

Analisis Framing Portal Berita Kompas.Com dan Mediaindonesia.Com atas Pemberitaan Program Makan Siang Gratis oleh Paslon 02 (Prabowo-Gibran) Pada Periode 28 November 2023 - 10 Februari 2024

2024 is a crucial year for Indonesia as it marks the presidential and vice-presidential transition. The General Elections Commission (KPU) has nominated three candidate pairs, one of which is Prabowo Subianto-Gibran Rakabuming Raka (candidate pair 02), who proposed a free lunch program. This program has sparked considerable debate in various media, prompting this study to analyze the framing of news coverage about the free lunch program by candidate pair 02 (Prabowo-Gibran) on the online news portals Kompas.com and Mediaindonesia.com during the period of November 28, 2024, to February 10, 2024. The research employs a descriptive qualitative method to describe or explain the underlying meanings of reality. Data analysis is conducted using Zhongdang Pan and Gerald M. Kosicki's framing analysis model, which includes syntactic, script, thematic, and rhetorical structures. The findings indicate that Kompas.com’s coverage is supportive of the free lunch program. On the other hand, the coverage on Mediaindonesia.com is firmly against the free lunch program

Fatigue reliability analysis of bogie frames considering parameter uncertainty

With the increasing service life of bogie frames, the risk of fatigue failure becomes significant, making fatigue reliability analysis crucial for ensuring operational safety. However, accurately analyzing fatigue reliability presents a significant challenge with uncertain factors such as load fluctuations, unstable material shaping, and dimensional manufacturing deviations. To address this, this paper establishes a comprehensive active learning reliability framework based on surrogate models, enabling high-fidelity modeling and precise fatigue reliability analysis of welded frames under parameter uncertainty. The material utilization method was developed using APDL for secondary development to efficiently evaluate frame fatigue failure indicators. The effectiveness of this method was validated by combining the improved Goodman-Smith fatigue limit diagram and test bench fatigue tests, which helped identify the locations on the frame most prone to fatigue fractures. An Atom Search Optimization-BP Neural Network surrogate model was established with the objective of maximum material utilization, and the fatigue reliability of the bogie frame was obtained by combining the active learning function and the Monte Carlo method. The results show that the uncertainty design parameters greatly impact the fatigue reliability of critical welded structures. The proposed method improves the accuracy and efficiency of the fatigue reliability analysis of the bogie frame.

Microbes and marginalisation: ‘Facing’ antimicrobial resistance in bedridden patients in a peri-urban area of Thailand

Reducing human-microbial encounters through improved infection prevention and control (IPC) is widely acknowledged to be critical for reducing the emergence, transmission and burden of antimicrobial resistance (AMR). However, despite its centrality in the Global Action Plan (GAP) on AMR and adoption as a goal in National Action Plans around the world, there has been limited progress on reducing the incidence of antimicrobial resistant infections globally. In this paper, we argue that closer attention to different faces of AMR could propel progress in this area, with a focus on bedridden people situated in liminal spaces in the Thai health system and suburban economy. Our ethnographic fieldwork followed the cases of 16 bedridden people through the eyes of their carers and medical staff. We 'descended into the ordinary' to encounter individuals living - and dying - in the shadows of the labour-intensive suburbs of Bangkok. Here, AMR and IPC protocols are operationalised in the context of competing priorities and pragmatic decision-making. Focussing on three ethnographic vignettes, we use the analytic frames of precarity and care to consider how particular (bedridden) bodies are differentially exposed to AMR infections in the context of economic, social, and political arrangements that structure embodied vulnerabilities and forms and foci of care. Whilst the political work of calculating the burden of AMR may be oriented around galvanising support through a sense of magnitude and generalised risk, this research serves as a reminder that the faces of AMR include those who disproportionately shoulder the global burden of AMR, making it at once exceptional and ordinary.

Online News: Media Framing On Indonesia’s Capital City Relocation Policy

Objectives: The research aims to describe the position of the media in Indonesia in constructing an event using framing analysis. Methods: One of the framing analysis forms existing in communications research is that by Zhongdang Pan and Gerald M. Kosicki, which involves four major structures, namely, syntactic structures, script structures, thematic structures, and rhetorical structures. Framing analysis is a form of qualitative research. It particularly has relevance to the phenomenon of capital city relocation news reporting. Data were collected from online news reports by four media outlets, namely, Metro TV, CNN Indonesia, CNBC Indonesia, and Kompas TV. The news reports analyzed were set within the time frame between April of 2019 and January of 2022. All the online news reports pertaining to the capital city relocation were compared between the four media outlets to draw a conclusion as to how the media outlets positioned themselves in constructing the event under investigation. Results: The findings indicated that each television media outlet presented news on the capital city relocation policy in their respective fashions: Metro TV showed approval, CNBC Indonesia and CNN Indonesia did an inclination towards disapproval, and Kompas TV did a neutral view regarding the capital city relocation policy. Conclusions: The four media that were the object of research show that each media has a different agenda regarding events that occurred in Indonesia, especially the relocation of the capital city. These differences come from differences in motives, vision and mission, ideology, political affiliation and goals.

Social Media and Conflict: A Visual Analysis of War and Peace Frames in Pakistan

Based on traditional peace communication scholarship, this study, embedded in journalism studies and visual politics literature, analyzes photographs of conflict using war and peace frames and explores the role social media can play in digital peacebuilding practices. A content analysis of 674 visuals of the second deadliest terrorist attack in Pakistan posted on Twitter revealed the dominance of war photographs. The majority of the visual tweets were related to the afflicted victims and the visiting elites. Our analysis revealed that the visual narrative predominantly adopted a war approach. Results also showed significant variations in the war and peace narrative over time. Overall, this study challenges the views of peace journalism scholars that social media would lead to a more peace-oriented approach. We argue that peace narratives may be difficult to occur on digital platforms in securitized national conflicts where elites and a dominant public opinion oppose alternative perspectives.

Structure Analysis of Hybrid Marine Renewable Energy Platform

Abstract The Pilot Project Energy Laut Hybrid for coastal communities utilises a hybrid-based tripod pontoon structure. Hydrodynamic analysis was conducted using Computational Fluid Dynamic (CFD) simulations and Detail Engineering Design (DED) testing at the Hydrodynamics Laboratory of Indonesia (LHI). This research aims to conduct a structural analysis of the tripod pontoon frame, including redesigning and comparing the strength between the existing and modified designs. An analysis using the software SACS V15.1 was employed to obtain unity check values and stress distribution. The analysis revealed that the unity check values for the existing model, with airy wave01, airy wave02, stokes wave01, and stokes wave02, were 0.508, 0.498, 0.509, and 0.5, respectively. In contrast, the unity check values for the modified model, with airy wave01, airy wave02, stokes wave01 and stokes wave02, were 0.827, 0.81, 0.827, and 0.813, respectively, indicating a 63% increase in unity check for the modified model. The largest shear stress was observed on member A5-1-A5-2 in both models, which still complies with the API RP 2A-WSD standard. Additionally, the modified model was 21% lighter than the existing model, with Z shear stress increasing by 63% for both airy and stokes wave types.

Pemberitaan Pemain Naturalisasi Dalam Media dengan Analisis DNA Dan Visone

Sports mass media have recently been discussing the discourse on the naturalization of national team players. This discourse is a project initiated by PSSI (All Indonesia Football Association) and BTN (National Team Agency). The reason for doing this is to boost the national team's performance to achieve more in the international arena. This naturalization discourse has raised pros and cons in the eyes of national football lovers. This naturalization issue has been linked to media interest in reporting it. From this problem, the author has a question: how do the media in Indonesia frame the news of the Naturalization of Indonesian National Team Players in recent times? The study used qualitative research and media framing analysis techniques. Data collection was carried out by observation and observation of several media. As for the data analysis technique, this study used media framing analysis with the DNA and Visone applications to determine the media's bias in its reporting. The existence of these similarities makes a country's sovereignty that must be loved. Several specific media reports naturalized players with certain frames to lead readers to be pro or con. This study concluded that some media in Indonesia framed the news of naturalization positively because the increasing achievements of the national team can prove it. A small portion of the media viewed it negatively because it was difficult for local players to defend the Indonesian national team. Keywords: Naturalized player, Framing analysis, DNA and Visone

Analysis of Reinforced Concrete Structure Subjected to Blast Load

The research focuses on a specific standoff distance of 15m & 20m , a critical parameter in blast analysis, to gain a understanding of the building's behavior under static loading conditions of blast load weight of 150kgs & 100kgs of TNT. To simulate realistic scenarios, the models are subjected to appropriate boundary conditions, including foundation constraints to account for the building's interaction with the ground. The blast load is assigned as joint loads, considering the standoff distance of the blast from the source. The standoff distance significantly influences the building's response to the blast, with profound implications for structural integrity and security. The Analysis of the Bare frame with blast load added as Joint Load, the deflection is controlled by adding Shear walls along various location along the periphery & core for 10 Story RCC Structures. The analysis is conducted using linear time history analysis (Response Spectrum Analysis) within ETABS, capturing the response of the building. Roof Displacement, Base Shear, Story Drift, Stiffness, Time period & Modal participation mass ratios are monitored during the analysis. The outcomes of this study contribute valuable insights into the structural responses of buildings to blast loads at specific standoff distances. This research advances our understanding of blast effects on buildings thereby enhancing the security and resilience of vital infrastructure in the face of evolving threats. Keywords: Blast Load, Response Spectrum Method, Roof Displacement, Base Shear, Story Drift, Stiffness, Time period & Modal participation mass ratios.

Laughing like a caveman: excess and experience inside Georges Bataille’s Lascaux

ABSTRACT Towards the end of his life, Bataille became increasingly fascinated by prehistoric culture. His analysis of the Lascaux cave frames it as the symbolic site of our birth, envisioning in its art the final step to anthropogenesis: we, as a species, became human once we began smearing pigment on cave walls. Bataille’s account of this dual birth of art and humanity is neither an ode to our rational mind nor to our capacity for aesthetic contemplation. Rather, the murals adorning the cave would be the result of primordial ecstatic experiences. For Bataille, art ties in with excess: an activity devoid of use-value rising above necessity or instinct. Lascaux becomes the scene of a primordial crime against utility. Bataille’s cave stands as a counterargument to the enlightenment’s fixation on progress and productivity. The decades since, have seen our obsession with productivity grow even more pervasive. This paper explores the constellation of excessive behaviours which Bataille presents as key to the birth of art and, through an autoethnographic study, asks whether, and how, this ‘spectrum of excess’ is still relevant to artists today.

Heat in the news: Geothermal energy in Chilean newspaper coverage

Although Chile has abundant geothermal resources and is home to the first geothermal power plant in South America, the country faces uncertainties regarding the future development of geothermal energy. Lack of economic incentives, insufficient regulatory framework, and social opposition to geothermal power plant projects are some of the main challenges faced in the last years. To reflect on the pitfalls of the geothermal energy public debate and promote the integration of social aspects in the geothermal energy discussion, this study examines how geothermal energy has been portrayed in two influential Chilean newspapers from 2008 to 2021. Based on the idea that the mass media plays a critical role in public perception, this paper presents a framing analysis of 259 newspaper press to reflect on the public discourse of geothermal energy. The study shows that the media focused mainly on deep, high-enthalpy geothermal projects and the energy concession market. Geothermal energy has been mostly part of the finance discussion, and the coverage has been primarily event-driven, with limited visibility beyond specific events. Two events, the controversial exploration project in El Tatio (2009) and the successful commissioning of the first geothermal plant Cerro Pabellón (2017) attracted significant attention and presented geothermal energy from contrasting perspectives. Geothermal energy is mainly portrayed as an abundant, clean, and renewable energy source. However, geothermal development is described as a “business” or a “resource to be exploited”. There is a notable absence of discussion regarding the success of Latin American geothermal initiatives. Instead, European cases are the most prevalent in the discourse, serving as exemplars for potential future action. This result calls for the promotion of a new geothermal narrative and relationship with geothermal energy that acknowledges the experience from Latin American countries such as Costa Rica or El Salvador, the importance that geothermal energy has had for Indigenous peoples and promotes its use in the light of social demands for a more sustainable relationship with the environment, instead the main geothermal frame reproduces the commodification of natural resources in Chile.

Managing ignorance to preserve anti-doping cosmology – the case of contamination

ABSTRACT This article addresses contamination within anti-doping as a scientifically complex and politically critical source of ignorance, representing a threat to the World Anti-Doping Agency’s (WADA) credibility. Contamination can be described as any situation in which athletes come in contact with prohibited substances through their environment, without their fault, and is an unknown looming over athletes and anti-doping organisations alike. Dealing with contamination is a vital stake for WADA as the phenomenon jeopardises institutional features of anti-doping, including the strict liability principle whereby athletes are deemed responsible for whatever is present in their body. Building on studies of ignorance in organisations, this article draws from frame analysis to apprehend WADA’s policy response to contamination. Through WADA Minutes and other releases over the period 2000–2023, we analyse how WADA handles and justifies shifts in its framing of contamination towards its global audiences. Our results show that organisational attitude towards ignorance is a dynamic process. This process intertwines with the organisation’s need to maintain its credibility, especially where elucidating the issue threatens components constitutive of its community’s cosmology as defined by Goffman. The concept of ‘frame consistency’ illuminates how this requires the organisation to retain the community’s trust by convincing them that its framing remains coherent over time and that the policy issue can be mastered without undermining the system’s overarching principles. To achieve these goals, WADA mobilises techniques of impression management, also relying on the institutions of science and the law as guardians of its cosmology.

STRUCTURAL DESIGN AND ANALYSIS OF A 20-STORY MIXED-USE HIGH-RISE RESIDENTIAL AND COMMERCIAL BUILDING IN DHAKA: SEISMIC AND WIND LOAD CONSIDERATIONS

This study, conducted in the Department of Civil Engineering at Stamford University Bangladesh, focuses on the structural design and analysis of a 20-story mixed-use high-rise building in Dhaka, accommodating both residential and commercial functions. The objective of the study is to gain insights into the design and analysis of an intermediate moment-resisting frame that addresses the specific challenges posed by seismic and wind loads in a dense urban environment. A commercial building, defined as a structure primarily dedicated to business activities, requires specialized design considerations that extend beyond residential construction, including the need for larger beams, increased floor space, and accommodation for various commercial functions. In high-density urban areas, like Dhaka, the design of multi-story commercial buildings, such as shopping malls and office complexes, presents additional challenges related to space constraints, vertical shopping preferences, and the high cost of land. The study emphasizes the importance of creating a structural design that balances rentable space, aesthetics, cost, safety, and comfort, while addressing the lateral forces caused by wind and seismic activity. This analysis aims to assist engineers and architects in meeting the growing demand for multifunctional high-rise structures, ensuring both safety and functionality in the face of complex environmental and structural factors.

Out of Sight, Out of Mind? UK–EU Member States Bilateralism as an Enabler of Europeanisation

AbstractWhilst an extensive scholarship has questioned the role of the United Kingdom in multilateral and mini‐lateral venues, less attention has been devoted to the signature of 24 bilateral declarations between the United Kingdom and EU member states from 2021 to 2023. Bilateralism has indeed been one of the preferred UK strategies to achieve foreign policy co‐ordination with EU member states post‐Brexit. Questioning the intentionality of the United Kingdom in initiating and investing these arrangements, we find that despite the clear attempts to deEUise its foreign policy, we are also not witnessing purposes of de‐Europeanisation that would imply a repudiation of European shared values, a divergence from common priorities and an end to social encounters between UK and EU member states' officials. Instead, through a frame analysis of these declarations and interviews, we highlight that bilateralism has enabled continued Europeanisation, even though to a lesser extent in comparison with the pre‐Brexit situation. Closer relations with European capitals are thus enabling Europeanisation of UK foreign policy to persist. In other words, we conclude that whilst there has been, on the side of the United Kingdom, a repudiation of the EU as a political entity, there has been no rejection of common European values and priorities, which remain shared with EU member states.

Sensibility Analysis of Traditional Span Frame

ABSTRACT Traditional timber frames may have a complex mechanical behavior regarding to today engineer skills and design standards. For an identical rebuilding as required for the Notre-Dame de Paris Cathedral, accurate modeling must be performed to assess modern reliability. Identical rebuilt means same green oak material, same geometry and timber connections. In the context of the rebuilt of the Notre-Dame carpentry, a part of the timber frame based on the original schemes of the nave extracted from historical graphic document was reproduced. A full-scale replica was erected in order to perform mechanical tests. Through an in-situ monitoring, this structure represents a case study in order to provide data relative to the kinetics of displacements. This investigation allows to evaluate the global behavior of the structure. Based on the finite element method (F.E.M), a dedicated model is used to analyze the sensitivity of the material properties, the beam geometry and the wood-to-wood connections in order to design the testing carried out on the wooden structure. From these full-scale tests, we determine the real stiffness of the carpentry. Then, a retro-analysis was proposed to evaluate the axial stiffness of connections according to the corresponding finite element model, by fitting data to reproduce the real displacements. The study reveals that this property is substantial to describe the global behavior. Furthermore, we carried out in the laboratory an experimental campaign consisting in characterizing traditional joints. The goal was to estimate their stiffness and their specific failure modes by using image correlation. Concomitantly, numerical simulations were developed in order to investigate the dependence of the stiffness according to moisture content variation of oak species. The global research supplies useful tools and results, which may be able to improve the understanding of the mechanical performance of traditional structures and provide valuable information for design purposes.

Modal characteristics analysis of agricultural vehicle support frame

Modal characteristics analysis of agricultural vehicle support frame

Deformation Characteristics and Influence Factors of Shear Force Lateral Stiffness Matching Index for Non-Rigid Plate Bent Frame Structures

The period ratio and the drift ratio are commonly used as plane regularity control indices for multi-story buildings. However, they fail to reasonably reflect the regularity of lateral force-resisting component configuration and deformation characteristics in non-rigid plate bent frame structures. This study focuses on the analysis of non-rigid single-span bent frames, examining the variation patterns of a suitable regularity index for non-rigid plate bent frame structures, referred to as the shear force lateral stiffness matching index, under various parameters. Additionally, it introduces indices to quantify the deformation response of non-rigid plate bent frame structures, providing a detailed analysis of the impact of factors such as eccentricity, torsional stiffness, and roof slab stiffness on the deformation characteristics of non-rigid plate bent frame structures and the shear force lateral stiffness matching index. The results show that the shear force lateral stiffness matching index can reflect the inconsistency in the horizontal displacement response of lateral force-resisting components caused by deformations in the roof slab. The proposed indices for torsional and bending deformations accurately quantify the roof slab’s deformation response, revealing the horizontal deformation characteristics of lateral force-resisting components in non-rigid frames. When eccentricity is present, the stiffness of the roof slab has a non-monotonic effect on the torsional component of the structural seismic response.

Perception of carbon capture and utilization - a framing analysis of German-speaking media

Carbon dioxide capture and utilization (CCU) technologies are one building block in Germany’s industrial decarbonization strategy. With CCU technologies, carbon dioxide emissions are captured from an industrial point source or the ambient air (direct air capture, DAC) and either used directly as an industrial feedstock or transformed and used as a carbon resource in industry. Despite the potential benefits of CCU in decreasing industrial dependency on fossil fuels and decreasing global CO2 emissions, robust empirical evidence of the general public opinion and societal acceptance of carbon capture and utilization technologies is lacking. Here, we studied the German-speaking media discourse as a proxy for the public discussion of carbon capture and utilization (CCU) technologies. We show that CCU technologies are overall framed more positively than negatively. Responsible for the optimistic framing are the two dominant media frames: “climate protection-frame” and “benefit-frame,” which are mainly used by scientists and policy actors or representatives from the industry sector respectively.

Expanding infrastructure ontologies: Integrative and critical insights for coastal studies and governance

Diverse knowledge insights are essential to inform action on bringing about transformations in how societies live with changing Earth, ocean and coastal systems. However, knowledge forms typically used in governance systems are stubbornly limited. This paper analyzes the extent to which an expanding ontology of the concept of ‘infrastructure’ can contribute to building more integrated knowledge for governance in ocean and coastal contexts. This paper asks: What can creative and critical engagement with infrastructure thinking offer to efforts to bring together diverse forms of knowledge and to develop more effective and ethical governance in changing coastal contexts? Employing a qualitative assessment of how the concept of infrastructure is defined in multiple disciplines and contexts, the paper identifies three heuristic types of structures, things and processes that can collectively inform interdisciplinary dialogue and governance dialogue: (i) built/physical infrastructure, (ii) environmental infrastructure, and (iii) societal/cultural infrastructure. Drawing on insights from critical infrastructure studies and more-than-human perspectives, the paper then identifies ontological and methodological challenges of integration, values, and power/agency for those who engage a multi-faceted conception of infrastructure to frame analysis and action. Bringing these insights together, the paper argues that infrastructure thinking provides a means to facilitate interdisciplinary dialogue, and a useful lens with which to analytically integrate diverse forms of knowledge about/in ocean and coastal contexts. However, cautious and critical perspectives are needed to support efforts in (re)thinking and integrating for collective action and governance.