Chemical recycling of thermoset composites has been focused largely on recovering high-value carbon fibers with property retention, while recovery and reuse of decomposed polymer matrix residues is generally overlooked, despite the fact that matrix recycling constitutes an essential component of a sustainable approach to the overall problem. Our previous study demonstrated that oxidative acid digestion can be deployed effectively to recover near-virgin quality carbon fibers from amine-cured epoxy composites. In the present study, we investigate the viability of recovery and reuse of the decomposed amine/epoxy residue after acid digestion of the matrix, effectively closing the recycling loop. We find that polymer matrix residues recovered from acid digestion solutions via neutralization and precipitation contain molecular components of the epoxies in which aromatic regions are preserved. The recovered matrix residues are blended into virgin resin formulations and two approaches are evaluate for potential reuse. Approach I utilizes the matrix residue as an accelerator for a virgin anhydride/epoxy formulation that contains no accelerator and thus cannot be self-catalyzed. We discover that adding matrix residue produces catalytic effects on the curing reaction. In general, anhydride/epoxy samples blended and cured with recovered matrix residues are homogenous and exhibit thermal and mechanical properties comparable to specimens cured with a commercial accelerator. Approach II deployed the matrix residue as a filler for virgin anhydride-based epoxies with a commercial accelerator to produce blended formulations. In such cases, blended formulations yielded acceptable retention of thermal and mechanical properties, provided the fraction of matrix residue added did not exceed 10 wt%.