Calcium-protein interactions are of paramount importance in biochemistry. They are a key element in a number of biological processes, such as neuronal signaling. Therefore, an understanding of the interaction at the molecular level is highly desirable. Here, we study the zwitterionic model peptide l-alanyl-l-alanine (2Ala), which has two distinct and competing binding sites for Ca2+: The carbonyl of the peptide bond and the C-terminus, the carboxylate group. We perform linear and two-dimensional IR spectroscopy experiments and find that the spectroscopic signatures of both moieties in the IR spectra change in amplitude and peak position upon the addition of CaCl2: A blueshift of the asymmetric carboxylate band and a redshift for the amide I mode. Ab initio molecular dynamics simulations confirm the direct interaction of the Ca2+ ion at both the carboxylate and the amide CO site leading to different spectral responses. The blueshift of the asymmetric carboxylate band is caused by a localization of the charge, leading to a decoupling of the CO stretching modes of the carboxylate group. The slight redshift of the amide I mode of 2Ala upon the addition of CaCl2 contrasts the blueshift that has been observed for isolated amide motifs, such as N-methylacetamide (NMA). This difference is caused by the smaller number of water molecules being replaced by the Ca2+ ion for 2Ala's amide compared to less sterically hindered, isolated amide carbonyls, in conjunction with vibrational Stark effects. Our results highlight the importance of considering potential competing binding sites, such as the amide CO backbone, the termini and residues, as well as the nature of the hydration of both peptide and ion, when exploring ions' interacting with small peptides and larger proteins.