Comparing and Contrasting Two White Leaders of the Tuskegee Airmen: Colonels Noel Parrish and Robert Selway Daniel Haulman (bio) The tuskegee airmen included the first african american pilots in American military service, but the group also included others who served alongside them, in their units or at their bases, between 1941 and 1949. Some of those personnel, including the commanders of some of the Tuskegee Airmen bases and units, were white. The most important of these were Colonel Noel F. Parrish and Colonel Robert R. Selway. During most of World War II, Parrish commanded the Tuskegee Army Air Field, located in Tuskegee, Alabama, where the first Black pilots in the United States Army trained to fly. Selway once commanded both of the only two Tuskegee Airmen flying groups, the 332nd Fighter Group and the 477th Bombardment Group. In the scholarly literature focused on the Tuskegee Airmen, Colonel Parrish has generally been considered a hero, while Selway has assumed the role of a villain.1 While there are good reasons for such an assessment, it is an oversimplification of the character and career of each man. The hero was not without [End Page 225] flaws, nor the villain without virtues, and what they had in common cannot be forgotten. Black military personnel served in the armed forces of the United States since the Revolutionary War, but despite playing important roles, their positions were typically in the lowest ranks, and they were usually placed under the leadership of white officers. Before World War II, the War Department did not allow African Americans to train or serve as pilots. Army leadership believed that Black recruits were inferior and lacked the ability to fly advanced military aircraft in combat, a sentiment expressed most notably in a 1925 Army War College report.2 When President Franklin D. Roosevelt ran for a third term for president in 1940, he promised to train Black pilots in the Army Air Corps, and he fulfilled his promise.3 In March 1941, the War Department activated the first African American flying unit, the 99th Pursuit Squadron (later the 99th Fighter Squadron) at Chanute Field, Illinois, under a white commander.4 The Army had already announced that the unit’s pilots would be trained at Tuskegee. Just as the conflict opened possibilities for Black pilots, World War II also marked a change in opportunities for Black leadership within the military; in fact, because of the Tuskegee Airmen, Black officers came to command not only groups and squadrons, but also bases. There had been few Black officers in the Army, and only a handful had attended the United States Military Academy at West Point. Training Black military pilots would vastly increase the number of Black officers, since pilots were typically officers, receiving their commissions as they graduated from advanced flight training. The Army did [End Page 226] not want Black officers in command of white enlisted men and therefore insisted that the training of the Black military pilots, and the unit to which they would be assigned, would be segregated. The 99th Fighter Squadron would eventually have Black commanders, but the squadron itself would have no white personnel. And more generally, many military leaders were skeptical of the abilities of Tuskegee pilots; Army leaders did not envision that Black flying units, groups or squadrons, would ever be sent into combat overseas. Tuskegee was chosen as the flight training area for a number of reasons. The Tuskegee Institute was already training African American pilots in the Civilian Pilot Training Program, and it had a reputation as one of the most famous and prestigious of Black institutions of higher learning. Tuskegee was also in an area in the South that had more days of good flying weather than potential sites farther north. And, because Alabama and Tuskegee were strictly segregated, the segregated nature of the training program would fit the climate with little danger of resistance; certainly, Tuskegee was not close to an urban area like Chicago or Detroit that leaders felt to be racially volatile.5 The African American flight training, like that for white pilots elsewhere, was divided into three phases: primary, basic, and advanced. The...
Read full abstract