Racial/ethnic differences in the distribution of births across the childbearing years are indeed dramatic and likely reflect powerful economic and sociocultural influences on the timing of births—influences determining who is selected into the pool of women giving birth at older ages. We know that fewer births occur among African American women than among White women after 30 years of age.1,2 We also know that postponement of first birth may be intentional or unintentional, and in the latter case postponement may be due to a medically complicated history. Since intentional postponement is associated with higher income and African Americans have lower average incomes than Whites, we might expect a smaller proportion of first births to older African American women to result from intentional postponement. By default, a higher proportion would result from medical problems. That the effect of maternal age on birthweight is slightly attenuated among second births to African Americans is consistent with this reasoning, since the pool of women having a second birth is reduced by the number of women who experienced the most serious medical problems in relation to first birth. However, multivariate analyses show that the effect of maternal aging on African American births is independent of parity, which would argue against a selection hypothesis, and is exacerbated for the poorest women. As suggested by Geronimus, poverty and the stresses that accompany poverty may work to erode overall health among African American women, with serious consequences for birthweight regardless of birth order.3 The appropriateness of the term “weathering” to name this process is debatable, and the underlying mechanisms deserve further study, but some combination of increased exposure and heightened susceptibility over time is operating. Recent work points to the role of chronic stressors in preterm birth,4,5 possibly mediated by infection,6,7 and both conditions are more prevalent among African American and low-income women.8,9 With respect to childbearing in the United States, social selection is anything but “natural” in the Darwinian sense. Rather, selection forces are socially produced—a consequence of limited choices, diminished resources, and structural constraints. The focus on maternal age–related patterns of risk merely highlights the cumulative nature of the problem. The challenge for public health is to identify the fundamental sources of risk, explore mechanisms that translate social risk into biological adversity, and design policies and interventions to ameliorate this risk among African American women of all ages.10
Read full abstract